Wall-E

  • Thread starter DQuaN
  • 35 comments
  • 2,309 views
I saw it a while back, and while it is good fun for kids it commits the two biggest issues I have with animated films.

1) It gets preachy (consumerism is destroying the Earth - the irony from Disney/Pixar is too much)

2) Live actors included that doesn't actually play part of the story (Who Framed Roger Rabbit and Cool World did this well). It is one thing when live action and animation cross paths and it plays into the story, it is another thing when I am supposed to believe that neither of them notice. The animation is good, but not that good.
 
I'LL NEVER BE TOO OLD FOR PIXAR FILMS!!!
Same here! :D

I loved it.
After I watched it, I wanted to do some exercise...just in case..

But my favorite kid movies are still Ratatouille, The Lion King, and Aladdin.
 
I saw this film last week, and I think it was pretty good. There was nothing really wrong with it at all, apart from the plot had less obvious direction than the M6 toll road!
 
Ah, you just reminded me about this movie, I've been wondering why everyone calls me Wall*E lately, :lol:

I'll probably see this when it goes to DVD/Blu-Ray, or after The Dark Knight.

From,
Chris.
 
I watched it with my girl at the cinima a few days ago, wasn't the one we intended to see but what can you do when the one your going to watch (and really don't want to watch) is sold out :D It was better than i hoped for also it was a pretty cool film, and yeh I get what you mean FK about the consumerism but I found it comical the way they executed it so it made up for it.
 
I saw Wall-E on opening day, and I absolutely loved it. I love that little Robot so much, and to be honest, I even liked Wall-E better than Rattitouile (however its spelled). Granted, it does hit you over the head with some pretty blatant anti-consumerism things, and certainly, the message of "do it yourself or don't do it at all" rings through clearly too.

I actually cried towards the end, I won't lie. I still consider it my third favorite movie of the year (TDK --> Iron Man --> Wall-E), but as it has sat and matured, it sits pretty high on my list of all-time bests.
 
We watched this right after it came out and its a pretty good movie. Hard to believe almost all the voice acting was by a computer and not real voices.
 
Actually the voice acting was done by people, just with effects on their voices. I think Wall-Es' voice was played by one of the lead animators for his character.

It was a cute movie all the way around, and i really enjoyed it. If you think you're gonna see a kid's movie and not be taught a message then you must be crazy. :lol:

I also like the fact that the film had almost no dialogue. Pretty interesting, in a good way.
 
I saw it on Friday and thought Wall E was a cheap ripoff of Johnny 5 from Short Circuit.

Re-hashed Pixar garbage if you ask me. Formulaic and boring.
 
Re-hashed Pixar garbage if you ask me. Formulaic and boring.
What? You mean replacing penguins with robots and Antarctica with space ISN'T ground breaking?

I'm glad to see someone other than me noticed that it wasn't super awesome. If I was a kid I would have enjoyed it, but as I am old enough to be getting ready to have a kid my perspective has changed a bit.
 
What? You mean replacing penguins with robots and Antarctica with space ISN'T ground breaking?

I'm glad to see someone other than me noticed that it wasn't super awesome. If I was a kid I would have enjoyed it, but as I am old enough to be getting ready to have a kid my perspective has changed a bit.

Agreed. It did have its funny bits, and the kids in the theatre were laughing, but watch The Iron Giant instead; now there's a good robot movie. AND, it ain't from Disney, so you know it's good.

iron_giant.gif.png
 
Last edited:
Agreed. It did have its funny bits, and the kids in the theatre were laughing, but watch The Iron Giant instead; now there's a good robot movie. AND, it ain't from Disney, so you know it's good.
I own The Iron Giant.

That is an epically awesome movie. And the message of not fearing things just because you don't understand them is much easier to get behind than this repetitive environmentalist stuff we've been getting a lot of lately.
 
I own The Iron Giant.

That is an epically awesome movie. And the message of not fearing things just because you don't understand them is much easier to get behind than this repetitive environmentalist stuff we've been getting a lot of lately.
Agreed. In fact, I wish I owned it on DVD/BR rather than VHS (that's how long I've owned it).

I enjoyed Wall-E pretty much start to finish, but I certainly don't think it was hilarious and the "message" was so blatantly delivered (and so derivative) that I dismissed it out of hand in the first 15 minutes and ignored it for the rest of the movie.
 
Agreed. In fact, I wish I owned it on DVD/BR rather than VHS (that's how long I've owned it).
I think I got my DVD copy out of the $5 bin at Wal*Mart. They are practically giving the thing away.

It is easily one of the most underrated animated films.
 
I remember when the released Iron Giant in theatres, and Disney decided the world needed a re-release of The Little Mermaid, so hundreds of thousands of children went to see that crap instead of a movie with a true message.

I do have quite a bit of disdain for Disney (but not as much as I do for George Lucas!)
 
All I gotta say is if this movie doesn't win awards... Heads will roll!

Why? It really doesn't deserve any awards, except possibly for some of the technical aspects of it. The story and script just weren't that good.
 
If it does win any awards, eyes will roll...MINE!

Why? It really doesn't deserve any awards, except possibly for some of the technical aspects of it. The story and script just weren't that good.
Oh, good. I thought I was alone on this.

In my opinion even the technical aspects get ruined when you throw live action into animated films and it just contrasts how un-real your animation is. If your animation was that good you could animate realistic looking people. I know it was meant to show how humans have changed due to consumerism, but by throwing live actors in it doesn't look just like we became fat and lazy, but that we also became animated.

Story and script-wise, I still stand by my belief that if you take Happy Feet and replace Antarctica with space and penguins with robots you have the same story. Or it could be that, as Heinlein said, there are only three types of stories in the world, and at this point we have run through every variation you can make on them.
 
The first time I saw advertisements for this movie, I thought it was some remake of Short Circuit. As far as children's movies featuring robots, I don't mind Robots, Robin Williams is always fun.
 
If it does win any awards, eyes will roll...MINE!

It'll clearly win Best Animated Feature, everything else this year was tripe. But I wouldn't be surprised if it got a nomination for Best Original Score. Thomas Newman did a great job to keep the story flowing with the lack of dialogue in the first half of the film.
 
There was a lot of elements that you could relate to with ET. I guess maybe I'm reading too much into stuff... :indiff:
 
The part where Wall-e goes into outer space that's all a reference to Star Trek Next Gen right? lol
 
I saw Wall-E on Thanksgiving afternoon, and I think I was the only one in the room who liked the "quiet" of it all. It is rare to see a Disney movie where everything is not a polished piece of visual perfection with too much singing and dancing.

Not very big on jokes and humor, although I found myself laughing while everyone else was quiet, especially at the neck-less, ankle-less, people who believe blue is the new red. Say what you want about it being "anti-corporate", but I personally think it was showing people the danger of identifying yourself with a brand name, instead of being an individual (which is a common Disney theme of sorts).

What happens when civilization collapses? The only remnants were trash, decay, and an incomplete vision of the future. Of course there's an irony when Disney owns a piece of my state that's 50 square miles in area. So a beautifully displayed movie, but predictable and unlovable characters. Visually memorable, but there's only so much warmth robots can show on a screen.
 
Last edited:
I personally think it was showing people the danger of identifying yourself with a brand name, instead of being an individual (which is a common Disney theme of sorts).

Now there's supreme irony for you, considering that Disney never met an idea they couldn't rip off, sanitize and homogenize, and then make 5 slightly-different copies of.

Visually memorable, but there's only so much warmth robots can show on a screen.

Tell that to my 16-year-old daughter who was openly crying when Wall-E got greased.
 
Back