The thing is, a League of Judge would not be a weekly competition (once in a while) and would only be something to perk out who ever won a competition. Think of it like the UEFA Champions League (don't know if you familiar with it(football)).
Only the winner and the second classified in each home league (it depends, some leagues can put out more or less clubs), as long as the winner of Europa League and the past Champions league can get to said competition.
You don't have any competition to perk the competitions with less points in a home league.
The thing with a
Losers Competition, is that, if I understand correctly, the target is 99% of people who enter regular competitions. Yes, because, only a 1% of past winners are regular at competitions.
Also, who's to say you can enter a
Losers Competition? People who never made the poll? How are you going to account that? People who never won? - That's 99% of regular competitions. I doubt that people who don't get into poll in regular will get to the poll in a
Losers Competition (since you only take out 2 or 3 entries out of it), that if you have a poll limit.
If you don't, then that will be a pretty big mess when voting.
Oh, and in that note, I really don't understand people here. The other day, there was some talk that poll sizes should be lowered (creating less opportunity for members that don't get into poll often). Now they say there should be a competition so to create more opportunity for those who don't get into poll often. Contradiction much?
Ideally, and as I said, we would have free for all competitions. There are so many great ideas, like the Creative/Artistic Competition, Photo-Hut Competition (like mentioned earlier in this thread), Drift Competition, Rally Competition, and so on, that would enrich even more the community, than competition for ones and not for others.
Edit: If I recall correctly, weeks before GT5 release,
we were planning how we would like to see the Photomode area, giving out ideas to make it even better than the GT4 days. One thing that was of concern was cliques (whats happening in the competition forum). There is too much of a separation between people, whether you are a photomode GOD or you are a noob. How about I say that each and everyone who enters competitions, from the long coming to the short ones, are all big noobs, who don't know a thing and Photomode Gods in the same way? Because, that's really the way I always saw things.