Top Gran Turismo Gear

  • Thread starter Vol Jbolaz
  • 19 comments
  • 1,914 views

Vol Jbolaz

Hermits United
Premium
2,254
United States
Burlington, NC, USA
a_garris/Vol_Jbolaz
I imagine most everyone here is a fan of Top Gear. If you are like me, you only follow the BBC version. You watch an episode of the Ozzy or US version, but they just don't have that same magic. That same dry, slightly self-deprecating humor. They don't have Captain Slow and his penchance for something a bit more refined. They don't have The Hamster, who is not only an opening for short jokes, but hates the best decade ever, the '80s, and loves daft American muscle cars.

I have this idea bouncing around in my head. Quite a lot. It is persistent and aggressive. I'm sure this idea has been done, but I haven't seen it. Where is it? And if it isn't out there... why not? Should we try it? Would anyone be interested?

I envision a slickly produced, monthly video series that uses GT5 in game footage with clever Top Gear style voice overs to review in-game cars. Not only that, but compare them, and have challenges with them.

Quickly one day I wrote this down before it completely escaped my mind. It is something of a rough draft:




[Fade in on a 280SX in profile. Panning and fading shots]​

That long, low bonnet. Tight back-end. The cabin set way back. Sleek. Gorgeous. And totally nicked.

[Enter Jaguar E-Type, parking between the 280 and the camera]​

From what may be the best Jaguar ever designed, the E-Type.

[cut to E-Type alone on Eiger]​

Born in 1961, the E-Type is peace-loving, big afro, fring-topped, fish-tank platforms meets clandestine operations of international super agents. It is the sexy, best that the '60s had to offer.

In 2008, The Daily Telegraph listed it as one of the 100 most beautiful cars of all time. Enzo Ferrari himself said it was the most beautiful car ever made when it was introduced. It is one of only two cars on display in Manhattan's Museum of Modern Art.

Look at it and you can see why. It is fantastic. I like it so much, I have two.

But, it isn't all rose-colored glasses. The E-Type is not without fault. It's inline 6 only produces 270 break horse power. That isn't pushing what is possible in a 4-cyclinder hot hatch today.

The suspension is soft, and the tires…. Well. Contact patches of a figure skater. Oh, but what a figure.

[cut to standing shots on TGTT]​

Used, it should only set you back about thirty eight thousand credits. And that is well worth it. GT5 is all about tuning, though. The first thing you'll want to address is the roly-poly, tug boat suspension. And while you can pull much more power out of the engine, the E-Type is a case where more is not always better. There comes a point where more power just makes the car harder to handle without resorting to modern conveniences such as a limited slip differential.

At that point, you might as well change the badge and call it a Mit-Sue-Bee-She.




I'd like to add some more to this. For example, 0-60 and top speed numbers and a good closing. This just spilled out all at once one morning (as most of my writing usually does).

In this age of video capture, editing, and vlogs, I'm surprised that this isn't out there. I'm not saying this would be easy. I wouldn't even attempt this without a group of people willing to work closely together. You'd need three voices, but you'd also need one or two more people to do camera work and editing. And I would love if there were truly someone with an eye as a director (or at least director of photography).
 
Last edited:
Top Gear US's first season was pretty lame, but so was the UK version's. Hopefully it'll get better.

They need to get rid of that fat guy.
 
Top Gear US's first season was pretty lame, but so was the UK version's. Hopefully it'll get better.

They need to get rid of that fat guy.

I quite like Rutledge Wood personally, he seems the most natural and enthusiastic on the show. Give them time, they'll get better as they get used to each other and the format.

As for this particular idea, I think it has potential, but you should also be careful too not to stick too close to the TG formula. Doing this via Gran Turismo 5 will have significant strengths and weaknesses, and one would be wise to adapt to them.
 
I do fancy doing a sort of 'budget challenge'.

Like, everyone has say, 12,000 credits with which to buy something between 1990 and 2011, and compete in challenges.
 
As for this particular idea, I think it has potential, but you should also be careful too not to stick too close to the TG formula. Doing this via Gran Turismo 5 will have significant strengths and weaknesses, and one would be wise to adapt to them.

I agree completely. And I am well aware that I won't be able to see all the wonderful ways that this can be done in a GT5 manner, so I do appreciate some input.

Thoughts that I've had already: a real car review focuses on things that aren't a consideration in GT, such as ride comfort and build quality, cargo space or off-road capability. There are aspects of a GT review that should be included, such as tuning options and for which events a car can be entered.

In Top Gear, they may have a segment where they compare three luxury European saloons. We could do that sort of thing, but we can also compare GT Planet tuners. We can compare the stock Civic Type-R, with the Mugen and the Spoon, and with tunes from the forums (e.g. https://www.gtplanet.net/forum/showthread.php?p=5254048#post5254048 ).

Budget challenges will be fantastic. I really don't like throw-everything-at-it tunes, and I think Budget tunes can show not only which cars blossom well, but which parts are more bang for the buck.

Regrettably, we can't do cross country challenges, and we don't have break-downs. Those are some of the best parts of Top Gear.
 
I do fancy doing a sort of 'budget challenge'.

Like, everyone has say, 12,000 credits with which to buy something between 1990 and 2011, and compete in challenges.

Me and my brother did that once. 20,000 Cr to buy any car/tuning/tires e.t.c. and then raced online. It's amazing how much car you can get for that cash.
 
TenEightyOne, I was referring to Jason Dawe. He was rubbish.

Yoman, no. They don't do a lot of improv. Some of what they say is off the cuff, but the reviews, the studio bits, it is a mix of rephrasing until they get what they want (and edited together so it looks like one take), or previously written and rehearsed. Mind you, I suspect they write a lot of it themselves.

Keep in mind, Clarkson and May both have previous and current careers writing car reviews (read up on May's employment history, particularly the Autocar & Motor Magazine). That is their "day job" so to speak, in that if Top Gear is ever cancelled, they still have that.

Mind you, I'm not that funny. For starters, I'm American. And I'm not morbidly obese or overly self-centered, so I'm not a particularly good American. But I think that quick draft could be punched up quite nicely not only by someone witty, but by someone with a nice Hammondian delivery.
 
Mind you, I'm not that funny. For starters, I'm American. And I'm not morbidly obese or overly self-centered, so I'm not a particularly good American.

How dare you defy global stereotypes?
 
a. As far as the 'comedy quotient' in this little sample, I'd say that's a pretty decent "Captain Slow".
(It's his voice I heard in my head when I was reading it...)
:cool:

b. On the topic of 'global stereotypes', I guess I should be considered only 50% American - because I'm not self-centered...
:irked:
 
Vol Jbolaz
I agree completely. And I am well aware that I won't be able to see all the wonderful ways that this can be done in a GT5 manner, so I do appreciate some input.

Thoughts that I've had already: a real car review focuses on things that aren't a consideration in GT, such as ride comfort and build quality, cargo space or off-road capability. There are aspects of a GT review that should be included, such as tuning options and for which events a car can be entered.

In Top Gear, they may have a segment where they compare three luxury European saloons. We could do that sort of thing, but we can also compare GT Planet tuners. We can compare the stock Civic Type-R, with the Mugen and the Spoon, and with tunes from the forums (e.g. https://www.gtplanet.net/forum/showthread.php?p=5254048#post5254048 ).

Budget challenges will be fantastic. I really don't like throw-everything-at-it tunes, and I think Budget tunes can show not only which cars blossom well, but which parts are more bang for the buck.

Regrettably, we can't do cross country challenges, and we don't have break-downs. Those are some of the best parts of Top Gear.

It just has to LOOK like a cross country challenge, you could show carous clips of Tokyo r246, ssr7 and 5, heck maybe even the nurburgring and have some normal looking street cars driving around to look like traffic driving around at the speed limit, I'm sure you could find many in new dealership or the ucd, like hynduai, Kia, maybe some BMWs or Mercedes too, or minivans and sedans and coupes too, and the driver driving a GT-R or Mclaren, or Lambo, maybe even Bugatti, and show in car side views of the drivers head in replay like you would see on the show :D
 
Keep in mind, Clarkson and May both have previous and current careers writing car reviews (read up on May's employment history, particularly the Autocar & Motor Magazine). That is their "day job" so to speak, in that if Top Gear is ever cancelled, they still have that.

Don't forget that Top Gear is a print publication too, that's where James May transferred to the TV magazine from. All the TG presenters have had journalistic careers behind them of one kind or another - but that's normal for magazine formats. TG is unusual for the BBC (along with Doctor Who) in that it's spawned a hugely profitable franchise. That's why they get away with the expensive production that they do!

Clarkson also writes for right-wing newspapers, I find his strong political views to be mostly disgusting but he's an excellently comedic writer so I read his stuff anyway :D
 

Latest Posts

Back