As it's said, "your mileage may vary." I'm with
MuoNiuLa. 👍 Between the Forza siblings, Forza Motorsport 4 is the game that bored me to tears. I played that for about six months, and haven't really picked it up since. I didn't just quit when I had Horizon to play; I quit when Horizon was
announced last spring. As soon as I had something better to look forward to, I couldn't stand to lap the same dreadfully uninteresting racetracks anymore. FM4 isn't a bad console sim, but I think T10 really missed the mark on the track list and singleplayer content. Without XBL Gold, it's a very repetitive and staid experience. With XBL Gold, it's just bland.
To compare Horizon's DLC to FM4 DLC is unfair, I think. It's a one-DVD game, which is what ultimately slashed the car list and left gaps that could
only be backfilled with DLC. We wouldn't have the E46 M3 at all if not for the GTR in this pack, for example, and I don't disagree with the folks at Top Gear
for selecting it. The DLC isn't a straight copy-paste, and if you're like me and you have no inclination to play FM4, there's no point getting hung up on cars we've seen before. It's a different game. If you ask me, it's a superior game.
Needless to say my experience with Horizon was completely different from yours,
Eunos_Cosmo. Rally is my favorite kind of racing, so I've thoroughly enjoyed the expansion, and racing in the game itself. Point-to-point sprints on roads and tight mixed-surface circuits are so refreshing after too many laps on the wide expanses of FM4's modern, sterile racetracks. Forza Motorsport 4 is a damned boring game. Horizon has earned a spot in my top three titles of all time. Everything is relative.