I have the Lamborghini Gallardo, Ferrari Italia, MP4 McLaren and the Ferrari Scuderia.
Of the four, I'd say that;
The Italia is my least favorite, though I've not spent long with it.
The Gallardo is a handful, but its fun as hell.
The MP4 is powerful (Talking 860bhp max)
The Scuderia is very good bang for buck
Gallardo is 4WD, that can be useful, but its about which you prefer. I've heard the Lexus LFA (Which I'm calling the "Looks ****ing Awesome") is an awesome drive but I dont have that yet.
Of the four, if I had to choose, Gallardo for its looks, the aero kit is awesome, the car handles well and boy, is it fast. Plus its "Cheap"
Second to that would be the Scuderia, its very controllable and puts out a hell of a nice drift when you want it too. Beautiful too.
Lambo on the Nurb!