Alternatives to the Dual Shock 2 controller?

[TheTaZ]

I have been looking for a replacement for my DS2 controller. My son has smashed it on the floor one too many times. I have tried a few, but they just s**k for GT4. I tried both the wired and the wireless Logitech controllers. The wired ones buttons were to stiff. I like to use the d-pad buttons for steering and after a few minutes my fingers got cramped, also it seems that the buttons were not precise and were giving improper inputs. The wireless one just did not respond good enough. The sensitivity for the buttons was terrible. Now I tried a wired Pelican chameleon. This one had great button response but the ergonomics of controller was terrible. Whenever you try to use the d-pad buttons your thumb rubs and pushes on the analog sticks. I also did not like the step down of the R2 and L2 buttons.

Unless someone has a suggestion for a controller the works as good or better than the Sony, then I'll just get another DS2.

Is there any difference in the colored ones vs. the regular black one?

Thanks.

 

[Gerco]

Buy a Logitech DFP

 

[Dave A]

The DS2 is the best pad, the DFP is the best controler for GT4 and other racing games.

 

[gt4_0109]

I use the Logitech Cordless Action Controller. There is nothin special except the fact that it is wireless. Works well for all games is an exellent controller.

 

[JParker]

I researched this thoroughly myself. The vast majority of reviews on other brand controllers was that they were subpar to the Sony DS2. If you plan to stick with a controller, you'd be best off to stick with Sony's.
Most here stand rock solid behind the use of the Driving Force Pro wheel. I haven't purchased one myself and still use the DS2. I really don't have the room to build/purchase a seat. A couple here do however use the wheel in their lap, with the pedals just sitting in the floor.

 

[Evolution.]

If you want controller:Go with Nyko Wireless PS2 Controllers Multiplayer Kit.Includes:

2 Wireless Controllers (2 AA Batteries Each,not included)
1 Signal Reciever for your PS2.

has 4 different channels so if someone in the same room is playing with the same controllers,just switch it to a different channel.

 

[MOTRSPRT]

I have been using a Lynx wireless controller for over a year now, used both on GT3 and GT4. These are made by Madcatz. Comfort allows for hours of playing time, the buttons are laid out nicely, and I, too, like to use the D-pad for steering--my thumb does not hit the analog stick by accident. My 2 controllers are black, unlike the clear plastic casing shown in this picture:
http://www.madcatz.com/Default.asp?Page=204&CategoryImg=Wireless
Your experience with wireless may be that you were not close enough to the receiver card. I get best response when I'm no more than 7' away, although I have been ~12' away and seen it respond. Battery life is greatly compromised if you use the dual 'shock' mode.
This has been my experience, and it's awesome not having any cords getting in the way.

 

[un_peacekeeper]

just get the DFP, it's the way to play GT4

 

[TheTaZ]

just get the DFP, it's the way to play GT4

I would love to get a DFP, but I don't have a dedicated monitor to play on where I can set up a proper cockpit. Plus my wife wouldn't let me put a setup in the middle of the family room.

But if your buying

 

[Car_Guy]

If you don't mind wireless, I highly recommend the Logitec, Cordless Action Controler, you can get then almost anywhere for $40, I think it's better then the original DS2, it's weighted perfectly and has a great feel to it, and best of all it's wireless