GT6 vs Forza 5 lighting

[bashfulboson]

I found these images
what do you guys think?
It seems to me that Forza 5 is lacking of detail lighting
the brightness of sky doesn't change before and after car got out of the tunnel
In GT5 it does changes which is more close to reality

Notice that sky brightness doesn't change even cars were in different light condition

The situation doesn't change in different tracks

normally, human eye should adjust the apature under strong sun light that the sky will be much brighter than when you were in shadow

Notice the sky brightness changes in GT5 when F1 car was in shadow and under sun light

Real world situation

GT5 is pretty close to real

 

[Crumpet]

Forza uses overdone lighting effects to give the illusion of having good graphics.

 

[Gejabo]

Do we realy need another Forza vs GT thread?

 

[TheMokafan]

Personally I think Forza's graphics are superior to GT6 in nearly every way. Granted, the Xbox One is so much more powerful than the PS3. Though, I also thought Forza 4's motion blur and sense of presence was far better than GT5's.

 

[MasamuneDate]

Not trying to start a discussion, but Forza's graphics look disappointing for a next-gen racer.

 

[C_Raccoon23]

Here you go:

https://www.gtplanet.net/forum/threads/forza-5-vs-gt6-see-first-post-before-posting.282773/

 

[bashfulboson]

Not trying to start a discussion, but Forza's graphics look disappointing for a next-gen racer.

it's hugely downgrated from E3

 

[glassjaw]

To me Forza 5 looks exactly as 4 did, just with a higher poly count. The lighting in Forza has always been weak and it seems the same is true for 5. As consoles become more powerful, poly count has become less significant, and the real challenge for devs today is proper lighting and texturing. Throwing an insane amount of triangles at a problem can only get you so far, and I'm somewhat disappointed Turn 10 hasn't realized this yet. GT4 still stands as great example of a game that is lacking in poly count by today's standards, but still manages to look beautiful because of the supreme work PD did with lighting and texturing.

 

[PepeMickey]

Forza 5 is better, useless comparison to be honest.

 

[bashfulboson]

Forza uses overdone lighting effects to give the illusion of having good graphics.

Forza looks kinda fake to me, it just doesn't feel nature

 

[TokoTurismo]

Forza's lighting is waaaay to stylish... Reminds me of FM4 a lot, but on a next-gen console with better graphics.

Mind you it's only my opinion.

 

[bashfulboson]

Forza 5 is better, useless comparison to be honest.

how do you get that conclusion? I would like to hear

 

[Dodzzz]

What game is the reality.jpg?

Anyway, forza 5 graphic is better, the color is more natural.. while GT6's color appear too saturated.

 

[Mubble]

You can't compare an 8 year old console's graphics with the xBox One. The colours and lighting on GT6 look dated in comparison.

 

[Shirrako]

Forza 5 has amazing graphics but they seem cartoonish and unrealistic.

 

[bashfulboson]

Forza 5 has amazing graphics but they seem cartoonish and unrealistic.

so true

 

[bigspleen]

Forza 5 has amazing graphics but they seem cartoonish and unrealistic.

Most ugly next gen game I have seen..x1 is weaker so getting 1080p and 60 FPS they made a lot of sacrifices.

 

[bashfulboson]

You can't compare an 8 year old console's graphics with the xBox One. The colours and lighting on GT6 look dated in comparison.

I think GT5's lighting is more accurate compared to real world lighting

 

[bashfulboson]

What game is the reality.jpg?

Anyway, forza 5 graphic is better, the color is more natural.. while GT6's color appear too saturated.

are you even serious?

 

[Mubble]

I think GT5's lighting is more accurate compared to real world lighting

That might be true, but the result is unimpressive imo. Much is the same way that Kaz claims the engine sounds are accurately recorded and represented - which might also be true but.... (won't open that can of worms here).

 

[bashfulboson]

Most ugly next gen game I have seen..x1 is weaker so getting 1080p and 60 FPS they made a lot of sacrifices.

I think Forza 5 looks just like Forza 4

 

[Terronium-12]

Oh how I do enjoy these threads, however, this is the Gran Turismo 6 subforum in case any of you missed out on that. If you want to discuss GT and Forza there's a thread for that and this isn't one of them.