Have a Minute? I'd Like to Pick GTP's Brain... [Results Posted]

  • Thread starter YSSMAN
  • 55 comments
  • 2,913 views

YSSMAN

Super-Cool Since 2013
Premium
21,286
United States
GR-MI-USA
YSSMAN
YSSMAN
Okay, nothing too crazy here. With all the changes coming to market over the next 9-12 months, I'm interested to see how some of your tastes would play out when shopping for a new car. I've put together a little survey to gauge some interest in some new vehicles for 2013.

A simple FAQ:

Q: Why are you doing this?
A: I'm genuinely interested, and was a little bored on my day off

Q: What kind of questions do I have to answer?
A: Nothing too difficult. Choose a new car from a list within classes, or suggest one that I forgot (silly American, you don't have cool stuff!). Click and submit.

Q: What are you going to do with the answers?
A: Given enough responses, I'll gather some data and put them into some fancy graphs or something. Just to see how people voted. Probably should have done some demographics. Maybe next time, for SCIENCE!

Q: Can I get a sample question?
A: Sure, I suppose that's okay...

"Affordable" Sport Coupe
* Scion FR-S/Toyota GT-86
* Subaru BRZ
* Hyundai Genesis Coupe
* Ford Mustang V6 Track Pack
* Chevrolet Camaro V6 RS
* Dodge Challenger V6 Rallye
* MINI Cooper S Coupe
* Nissan 370Z
* Other:



So, I'm genuinely interested to see what you guys have to say. Feel free to debate whatever mistakes I may have made. In a weird way, this is almost easier than doing the GTP Best Car competition. Huh, who know?


=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=


THE RESULTS ARE IN!

After a few more than 80 responses, I figure it's time to post. You can check out the entire album here, graphs and details to come!

H3EBH.png

The Ford Fiesta managed to pull this one out, which surprised me, as the Fiat 500 was shaping up to take the top place. Top marks to quality and performance? It is difficult to say. Some of the "other" nominations focused on the Toyota Yaris Hybrid, Audi A1 and Vauxhall Corsa... None of which we have in North America.

lgcqW.png

The Volkswagen Jetta/Golf took this one by a short bit, likely due to the quality and performance of the car in the European market. I have to say I was surprised, particularly when the North American models are regarded in a pretty negative way. Unsurprisingly, the Ford Focus had a strong performance, but the Dodge Dart really surprised me. For a car we know so little about, votes were quite high. Interestingly enough, the Alfa Romeo Giulietta received several votes, which is what the Dart is based upon.

loTk0.png

The Volkswagen GTI got top marks here. Good value and performance, along with solid capabilities likely won the day. The Abarth came in second, and with the 2012 run completely sold out in the US, it doesn't seem all too surprising. Some of the "other" votes included the Renault Megane RS, Volkswagen Scirocco, and Audi S3.

aoFFn.png

The High-Po Compact class leaned pretty heavily on the Subaru WRX STI. Other results were inconsequential. The Audi TTRS perhaps being the one that I should have included, but forgot about.

5PSYs.png

The performance of the BRZ was interesting when compared to the other Toyobaru twin. The American votes are definitely visible on the Mustang V6, which initially had an early lead over the little Japanese coupe. I just want to know who thought they were clever and nominated the Peugeot RCZ...

1f80x.png

The Ford Fusion ran away with this one, and seeing as how it will be a global model also sold as the Mondeo, it isn't much of a surprise. Only the Volkswagen Passat managed to pull up a result greater than half of the Fusion, which surprised me. Although it appears to be a great car, the differences between the American and European version would have seemed polarizing. As someone pointed out, I missed the Nissan Altima. That could have played a role.

lHqAv.png

The Dodge Charger. 'Nuff said. There were nominations for the Nissan Maxima, which caught me off-guard. It is surprising how quickly a car that hasn't been updated in quite some time can fall completely off the radar. The Holden Commodore was also nominated, which will get international exposure again when Chevrolet introduces the SS Sedan for 2014.

sibDO.png

It was pretty much a dead-heat between the Nissan Juke and Mazda CX-5. Both are reasonably sized, small crossovers that are not only fun to look at, but also fun to drive. Someone was clever and mentioned the Skoda Yeti, which I completely support. I would have expected a better performance for the Ford Escape, but it just wasn't there.

oNXRu.png

Well, that one was one-sided. I'll get my coat...

pZE8q.png

It seems like BMW gets a lot of love pretty easily.

Kf0hu.png

Rinse and repeat. I did forget the Jaguar XF. SHAME ON ME AND MY FAMILY.

imKn3.png

The big Mercedes lead this out pretty easily. The Germans taking the top spots without much of a problem. Also forgot the Jaguar. SHAME.

Duv90.png

The Mustang really wiped the floor clean here. Lower weight, lower price, high power from that 5.0L... Seems like a winning combo here.

55mCY.png

Horsepower wins the day, although things evened out more evenly than I had originally expected.

tl7Ul.png

The BMW wins, rinse and repeat. The single soul that voted for the Hyundai, you should receive a commendation! I did forget the Jaguar once again, for which I apologize. But hey, a couple of you mentioned the Audi RS6. As far as I can tell, it is no longer on sale.

ywFEE.png

This is the Internet, and there are GT-R fans here. Not much of a surprise. The SRT Viper had the early lead, which it had maintained through most of yesterday. I'm not sure where the tip toward the Nissan came from. I did forget the Lexus LF-A, which like the Nissan Maxima previously, I'm not that surprised about. When you create a product that doesn't move the chains, it is going to be forgotten.

xeZcT.png

The Mazda MX-5 really ran away here. Take that to heart, kids. Others included the Mercedes-Benz W123, various generations of the BMW 3-series (E30 and E36), the AW11 MR-2, and some guy thinking they're clever with the Pontiac Grand Am.​
 
Last edited:
Isn't the BRZ, FRS, and GT-86 the same car?

Technically, yes. But, the cars are tuned to slightly different specifications. The FR-S/GT-86 are set up to be a little more exciting, and should be slightly more easy to drift. The BRZ is set up to be slightly more comfortable, and slightly more predictable... A nod to the typical Subaru driver.

Beyond that, they are trimmed to separate levels as well, the BRZ being slightly more luxurious, and the price certainly reflecting that.
 
Finished. I did notice on the midsize car question, one of the options was the Kia Spectra. That was a compact car discontinued in 2008; I think you meant to say the Kia Optima. But other than that, I didn't see any errors. I'll be curious to see the results. :)
 
Done. And I'd like to make clear that I voted for the Fusion on the assumption that it'll now be basically a Mondeo. If the Americans go and ruin it I'd like to re-vote. I thank you.
 
These two categories are shaping up to be more interesting than what I thought:



The Subaru STI is running away with the high-performance sport-compact segment, much to my own surprise. The Mustang Track Pack is holding its own against the FR-S/GT-86, both of which are further ahead than the BRZ.

The pattern I'm seeing thus far is that, if it has a Blue Oval on the hood, it is having a much better time comparing to the others. The Mustang, Fusion, Fiesta, Focus and even the Escape are all performing quite well in their respective polls.

I'm hoping the Europeans add some interesting answers into the mix later today.
 
Mulally has done one hell of a job remaking Ford into the company it is today. Across all segments, they seem to be hitting on just what is needed for the vehicle to be just right. I wish I could go back, however, and change my vote for the small SUV to Other for the Chevrolet Equinox. I think it's the most solid buy in the segment, comes really well equipped, is incredibly comfortable, and is just right for the price.
 
Voted. As with everyone else, I do too look forward to seeing the results. :D
 
Completed. Too bad some of the stuff in the poll isn't actually sold here in the UK. Could have been a fairer test otherwise :lol:
 
Done. Ruined it with some Euro models and ruined it further because you'd forgotten a few significant luxury models...
 
Done.

Well, I did it a couple of hours ago, but whatever.
 
I submitted my answers. It'd be neat if you did up a complimentary survey of used/late model cars as well to expand on your last question. :)
 
Results are still coming in, and I have to say, some of the Europeans tilted the results in different ways. I'll be adding poll results as things stabilize, there were a few errors in some of the postings.
 
Back