MuRRe "The Undecisive" - T500 thoughts/comparison

  • Thread starter MuRRe
  • 21 comments
  • 1,731 views
485
Sweden
@Home
WTF-MuRRe
Most of you know the story, I have been reading and writing alot here.
After getting me myself a DFGT and playing with it for 4 days I realized the pedals wasn't doing it for me. I can confirm ISR thoughts about them.
Now I didn't try the bungy cord thing though.
Now, if you are gonna order a DFGT and don't mind the 110 euros Logitech charge (including the 20%) you should def. buy directly from them.
Atleast the support here in Sweden is AWESOME.

To try and maybe help a little I just wanna give you a fast run through how I was thinking a reasoning when choosing the T500.

Basically there are the following choices (in order of price for ME including shipping with a 9,4 sek/euro (not the case anymore, but back "then"):
DFGT - 110 euros (including the 20% from Logitech)
911 Carrera - 180 euros
911 Carrera + RSW - 222 euros
G27 - 255 euros (including the 20% from Logitech)
GT3 RS + Clubsport - 350 euros
T500 - 430 euros

So, I wanted you know this because of course the price reflects upon the decision.
After reading a review of the 911 (can't remember which user, sorry) I just made the decision that going from a DFGT to 911 wouldn't be worth it for me.
Now, the 911 + RSW would be interesting, but it was too late. I had already ordered the T500. I must say though, in retrospect if that package would have been out I might have gone with it simply because it's a great price.

Now, onto one of the big 3 contestors (correct spelling?), the G27.
This wheel is loved by many, and there are good reasons.
I have played with the G25 (my brother owned one but sold it a couple of years ago). First off, back then we couldn't get it work that well with any games.
Since GT5 is one of my main games I just didn't feel like it was the correct choice for me. You can't set the FFB and there is still the same dead zone as with the DFGT (correct?).

Now we are down to the last 2, the GT3 CSP and the T500.
This was not as hard in the end as I thought it would be.
The price difference for me was 70 euros.
That's money too, but at the price point we are at now I didn't feel like that should be the deciding factor.

In favor for the GT3 are the pedals which is accredited to be the BEST ones.
T500 have a bigger wheel and better FFB.
For me, support was also in favor of T500 when ordering (might have changed a little, heard some not so good feedback in the T500 thread).

Onto the T500.
I'm going to try and keep it structured, but I'm not that great at it so I will probably remove and add stuff as time goes by.

T500 - the pedals
As I said before it's common knowledge that the CSP has the edge.
For me though, going from DFGT to this was exactly what I wanted.
Without even installing the brake mod the resistance is very strong (on the brake pedal).
This is actually my only problem right now with playing on my desk.
The resistance is so big my chair tend to move :D.
The set is HEAVY, which is awesome. It still have a tendency to move, but it's not a huge problem.

Don't know about the gas, there isn't a lot of resistance, but enough for it to be good to great and we all know must us T500 users don't really use the clutch that much :P.
I have only played in GT mode (when the light is red), maybe I will switch it around (any thoughts here?).
I like metal plate that your feet rests on. It feels robust and not as plastic as the G27 pedals. Compared to the CSP, well I guess it's a matter of taste.

Overall from the little experience I have this is a great set of pedals. The quality is there and with a brake mod I can't really see how they wouldn't be able to compete with the CSP or modded G27's.

T500 - The Wheel (including the whole body and paddles)
Gonna start from the bottom with the clamp.
I just wanna debunk any myths that this wheel can't be played without hard mounting it.
With the clamp and a stable table or desk it's ROCK solid.
Sure, my desk squeaks from time to time but hell, the wheel won't move.
I love the design, I like the color since it doesn't stick out.

One of the things that people put as a negative is that the paddles doesn't move with the wheel.
Since I have played VERY little with moving ones I can't really say that much about that part, either it's good or bad.
For me it works, sure there are times when it would a little nicer for them to move.
They are BIG, yes. The feel is awesome and you are never uncertain either you shifted or not. They are BIG, like in HUGE.

Another thing people have opinion about is the fact that it's rubberized grip and not leather.
Well, all I can say is this. My hands tend to sweat when I play and I think for me the rubber is better. The grip is also great, you never slip.

The Force Feed Back.
This is where I feel the most insecure about writing alot since I don't have that much experience with other wheels.
To be honest, it wasn't breathtaking going from a DFGT to this.
The DFGT has very strong FFB aswell.
The big difference is how much more defined it is, and yeah, it is stronger.
Put it to 10, take your X2010 and you will feel FFB :D


T500 - Conclusion/Thoughts/Ramble
I was going back and forth. 7 months ago I though I was buying a GT3 CSP, 2 months later a 911 Carrera.
Then onto the DFGT, back to the GT3... and it just goes on.
In the end I think the T500 is too good a product for me.
I'm quite a bad driver and the DFGT would had been enough for me to get better at driving.
Would I discourage you from buying it though? NO.
If you have the money I think that T500 is the best you can get right now (please note the THINK).
The pedals are nice, the wheel feels great.

If you came all this way, awesome. This review isn't that good and it's because of two things.
I haven't spend that much time on writing it (I will come back and do changes, I promise). Also I haven't had that much time with the wheel yet.
Will be doing some 4/24 hour Nürburgring soon so hopefully I will have some more info for you guys on what I think.

There is ONE person that deserves some extra thanks from me.
You know who you are ;)
 
Very nice inputs on the T500RS. I also want to buy this wheel but the problem is its availability locally in my country. Otherwise, I have to get one online.

Just a thought though, do you drive a real car? What's the feel of the T500RS compared to real driving. I just want to know how far is it from the real thing because I have been using a DS3 in GT5 but I also have been driving a car for almost 15 years. Would this feel like a toy or is it really comparable to real driving? Thanks.
 
Very nice inputs on the T500RS. I also want to buy this wheel but the problem is its availability locally in my country. Otherwise, I have to get one online.

Just a thought though, do you drive a real car? What's the feel of the T500RS compared to real driving. I just want to know how far is it from the real thing because I have been using a DS3 in GT5 but I also have been driving a car for almost 15 years. Would this feel like a toy or is it really comparable to real driving? Thanks.

Yeah, I do drive real cars, but I have never raced.
So I think you will have to get an answer from someone else.
What I can say though is this, I played GT5 for a couple of months with a DS3.
Didn't touch the game for a long time, getting a wheel is the best thing you can do to revitalize your interest.
Where do you live?
 
congratz mate, you have made you choice.
For GT5, I have the same feeling about T500 and DFGT, they just like "brothers" :)

G27, as many know, not well supported with GT5
GT3+CSP, I've tried it.. it have a lot of potential, love the pedals, and the vibrating motors, but for GT5, it just not maximized.

Edit:
One thing that emulates real life is the rotation speed. Drifting, to change direction you just let go the wheel, it will spin VERY fast, and you just grab it.. just as what i observed from passanger seat with drift car.
Using G27, you have to "push" the wheel to give extra rotation speed.
 
I'm chuffed you found your holy grail MuRRe.

Not sure if you play on PC but I think if you do you will be pleasantly surprised.

If not I would imagine all upcoming PS3 games will support your choice.

Even though I don't own that particular wheel, buying new games is a treat for wheel owners.

You will be amazed (or disappointed) in how each game will totally transform your wheels feel and effects. It's not just a generic experience across all games.

F1 2011 is on the horizon too and you'll share disappointments with all wheel users when a title doesn't support wheels at all.
(Driver Sanfrancisco I'm looking at you).

It's just the start of an up and down journey mate.

Enjoy.
 
I'm chuffed you found your holy grail MuRRe.

Not sure if you play on PC but I think if you do you will be pleasantly surprised.

If not I would imagine all upcoming PS3 games will support your choice.

Even though I don't own that particular wheel, buying new games is a treat for wheel owners.

You will be amazed (or disappointed) in how each game will totally transform your wheels feel and effects. It's not just a generic experience across all games.

F1 2011 is on the horizon too and you'll share disappointments with all wheel users when a title doesn't support wheels at all.
(Driver Sanfrancisco I'm looking at you).

It's just the start of an up and down journey mate.

Enjoy.

Yeah, playing quite alot on PC.
Drift 3, iRacing, GTR 2/Evolution, GT Legends.

There is this sound that I'm worried about, I emailed Thrustmaster with a sample (the one I posted here).
They say it's normal.
 
I have read about an above average fan noise shall we say. The noise you have posted I can't hear on the iPhone sorry and I wouldn't be qualified anyhow.

Have other members who have the wheel responded to your question?

I am assuming it's the fan.
 
I have read about an above average fan noise shall we say. The noise you have posted I can't hear on the iPhone sorry and I wouldn't be qualified anyhow.

Have other members who have the wheel responded to your question?

I am assuming it's the fan.

No, it's when turning the wheel.
You can only hear with you turn it without any other sounds.
 
MuRRe
No, it's when turning the wheel.
You can only hear with you turn it without any other sounds.

Hmm. I know if I crank up the Force feedback on my GT 2 I can sometimes get a squeal from the belt.

Or does it sound more like a bearing noise?

No one else answered you mate?
 
Hmm. I know if I crank up the Force feedback on my GT 2 I can sometimes get a squeal from the belt.

Or does it sound more like a bearing noise?

No one else answered you mate?

Just one, and he didn't say if he had one himself or explained what it was.
Need confirmation on this, I get really uneasy with these things.
 
This is the perfect thread for me right now. I need a little help/opinions.

So I am saving to buy a T500 and shoukd be able to get it in 2-3 months. I just saw that the G27 is on sale for $200 and thoughts started to pop in my head about getting it. I could order it today. Maybe I don't need a T500 yet, I will be playing on my couch with a wheelstand pro and is that going to get the most out of the T500? Would I be better waiting to get the T500 when I have room to get a obutto or other type of seat?

I know the G27 is a quality wheel but how much does it not being maximized for GT 5 hurt it when you are on the track? Is it just assigning buttons that is limited or other features too?
 
G27 can be used fairly decently in GT5.
However. Rally gives it a workout it shakes the G27 to the bones.

Oscillation of the wheel. A rapid side to side movement can happen on the straights in high powered cars. I've been told this doesn't happen with the T500.

What games do you play? The T500 is not compatible to most in the PS3 back catalogue.

Going forward I would go with the T500 but the g27 is a reliable and all encompassing workhorse.
 
Just a thought though, do you drive a real car? What's the feel of the T500RS compared to real driving. I just want to know how far is it from the real thing because I have been using a DS3 in GT5 but I also have been driving a car for almost 15 years. Would this feel like a toy or is it really comparable to real driving? Thanks.

It's getting extremely close to reality driving with the 500RS. If the wheel is mounted properly to a heavy table or solid cockpit, it feels like a real car with real heavy and smooth FFB.
The G25/27 feels like a toy in comparison, and I used to think it felt pretty real.

When you first play with a wheel coming from a controller, you may think it doesn't feel real or natural, but you just have to keep driving and you start to understand it's actually spot on with reality.
The 500RS is worth it
 
G27 can be used fairly decently in GT5.
However. Rally gives it a workout it shakes the G27 to the bones.

Oscillation of the wheel. A rapid side to side movement can happen on the straights in high powered cars. I've been told this doesn't happen with the T500.

What games do you play? The T500 is not compatible to most in the PS3 back catalogue.

Going forward I would go with the T500 but the g27 is a reliable and all encompassing workhorse.

I mainly play GT5 but also own Shift2 and Dirt3. I would be switching from the DFP so I think g27 will still be a big step up.
 
Very nice inputs on the T500RS. I also want to buy this wheel but the problem is its availability locally in my country. Otherwise, I have to get one online.

Just a thought though, do you drive a real car? What's the feel of the T500RS compared to real driving. I just want to know how far is it from the real thing because I have been using a DS3 in GT5 but I also have been driving a car for almost 15 years. Would this feel like a toy or is it really comparable to real driving? Thanks.

I used to do some drag racing with a ford mustang. As far as the wheel itself- it feels like a real car. The other factors that I miss from doing real racing are things they can't easily duplicate such as forces up under yer seat, thrill of danger, etc

This is the perfect thread for me right now. I need a little help/opinions.

So I am saving to buy a T500 and shoukd be able to get it in 2-3 months. I just saw that the G27 is on sale for $200 and thoughts started to pop in my head about getting it. I could order it today. Maybe I don't need a T500 yet, I will be playing on my couch with a wheelstand pro and is that going to get the most out of the T500? Would I be better waiting to get the T500 when I have room to get a obutto or other type of seat?

I know the G27 is a quality wheel but how much does it not being maximized for GT 5 hurt it when you are on the track? Is it just assigning buttons that is limited or other features too?

I play with my T500rs on a WSP and it does the job perfectly well. Very solid and stable.

I mainly play GT5 but also own Shift2 and Dirt3. I would be switching from the DFP so I think g27 will still be a big step up.

I play all 3. Shift 2 you have to play on PC where you can enjoy additional content and mods not available to the console versions. I currently play Dirt 3 on the Ps3 but will eventually get it on PC too. So only game from your list you cannot play on PS3 is shift 2 from your list. But the pc version is vastly superior in every way possible if you have a nice PC 👍 PC version has 3 DLCs (vs console which only has 2), plus they are all free, etc


Yeah, playing quite alot on PC.
Drift 3, iRacing, GTR 2/Evolution, GT Legends.

There is this sound that I'm worried about, I emailed Thrustmaster with a sample (the one I posted here).
They say it's normal.

No rFactor eh? That's a shame because the FFB in rFactor blows GTR2 out of the water. It's up there with iRacing. Now GTR Evo has nice FFB though
 
No rFactor eh? That's a shame because the FFB in rFactor blows GTR2 out of the water. It's up there with iRacing. Now GTR Evo has nice FFB though

Well, they are releasing rFactor in the near future, and somehow I can't get myself to buy a game for full price when the next one is coming within 6-12 months.
 
Oscillation of the wheel. A rapid side to side movement can happen on the straights in high powered cars. I've been told this doesn't happen with the T500.

This is a problem with the DFGT as well. Must be a Logitech thing.
 
Well, they are releasing rFactor in the near future, and somehow I can't get myself to buy a game for full price when the next one is coming within 6-12 months.

You do realize when rFactor 2 comes out- everyone will still be playing rFactor 1 for many, many months til rf2 is brought up to speed. All the cars & tracks, etc will still be on rFactor 1. Keep in mind rFactor is mostly all bout the community mods

[edit] Also, no one knows when rf2 will come out. ISI has been promising a "coming soon" status for rf2 for quite awhile now :)
 
Last edited:
You do realize when rFactor 2 comes out- everyone will still be playing rFactor 1 for many, many months til rf2 is brought up to speed. All the cars & tracks, etc will still be on rFactor 1. Keep in mind rFactor is mostly all bout the community mods

[edit] Also, no one knows when rf2 will come out. ISI has been promising a "coming soon" status for rf2 for quite awhile now :)

I hear you man.
Hands down, HOW much more true is iRacing in terms of REAL racing.
I don't mind the 12/month.
But getting into to D-license would run me like 50-60+ :(
 
Hm, that's a tough question. iRacing has incredible FFB and insanely good online racing series organization, etc. iRacing actually has better FFB than any other game I think off hand.... Hard to compete with that game since they have a full time dedicated FFB programmer. In everything it does- it does it top notch.... But they charge you for all the benefits of course....

Anyway you can hit D-class fast if u wish. Just do those time trials. Make sure you stay the entire time. Just keep lapping. Don't screw around and wreck, slide off track, nothing. just be 100% clean and you'll hit D fast. For a little taste of something different I would also do the real races and just drive clean, moving over for passing vehicles, etc. For the rookie time trials it doesnt even matter how fast you drive. More important to be a clean driver. I would barely get in 20 laps I would drive so slow, careful, and precise. Not sure if the iRating / ttRating takes a hit tho so double check with those vets in iRacing thread here (they are all like Class A+ and regularly win races!)

So to answer your question, if all you care about is 'realistic' racing then iRacing does that. rFactor physics varies from mod to mod. But no track in rFactor is laser scanned like iRacing tracks are
 
Back