Shot a 2.2 ton rocket at the moon looking for ice

So, they just thought "Why not just blow the **** out of the moon and see if there's something"...because that's and awesome job. "What you gonna do today?" "I'm gonna throw a spaceship into the moon REALLY FAST."
 
I'm just amused by all the clapping at NASA.

Well done guys, you've managed to hit THE MOON with a rocket. After managing to land several people safely on the moon, you wouldn't think it particularly difficult to just crash something into it. It's like being congratulated for managing to drive a car off the pier in Santa Monica and managing to hit the Pacific ocean.

Presumably the mission was derived from the "hitting a cow's arse with a paddle" school of science...
 
At both replies. :lol:

The funny thing is they didnt even do that right. There was supposed to be a 6 mile high explosions and we didnt even get to see a poof. :dunce:
 
I don't wish to be unkind, but it does seem a very stereotypically American way of investigating something :P

and we didnt even get to see a poof.

The rockets were unmanned. You wouldn't have seen anyone of any sexuality.
 
Roo
The rockets were unmanned.
Why do all the news stories insist on telling us that? The rockets were designed to crash into the moon. Not even the Americans would use manned rockets for that....
 
Roo
The rockets were unmanned. You wouldn't have seen anyone of any sexuality.

Touche
/
roger%20the%20leather%20man%201.jpg
 
So, they just thought "Why not just blow the **** out of the moon and see if there's something"...because that's and awesome job. "What you gonna do today?" "I'm gonna throw a spaceship into the moon REALLY FAST."
And learn a lot of very important things in the process. Yes.

I'm just amused by all the clapping at NASA.

Well done guys, you've managed to hit THE MOON with a rocket. After managing to land several people safely on the moon, you wouldn't think it particularly difficult to just crash something into it. It's like being congratulated for managing to drive a car off the pier in Santa Monica and managing to hit the Pacific ocean.

Presumably the mission was derived from the "hitting a cow's arse with a paddle" school of science...
It is not hitting the moon that is what all the clapping is about. It is hitting the moon in the exact spot they wanted to in order to hopefully stir up any possible ice so that it could be detected and measured.

So, they took a craft, sent it flying twice as fast as a bullet and hit the precise spot they wanted to hit in a crater that is perpetually in shadow and has never seen sunlight.

It is like managing to drive a car off the Santa Monica Pier at two miles per second (7,200 mph) and putting it perfectly through a 25 foot hoop after going around the Earth 8 times. Trust me, it was no small achievement.

I'm sure some of the physicists in here could attempt to explain the math and science involved, but our heads might explode.
 
Last edited:
It's a hard problem to be sure. There aren't many facilities in the world that can pull off a mission like that. That being said, yea this isn't exactly an engineering achievement that hasn't been done (even greatly surpassed) before. Deep Impact did the same thing - only harder. What's amazing is just how routine it is becoming, and how few people were needed to actually fly the thing. They've only got a handful of guys actually doing the navigation.
 
I think someone just watched Austin Powers: The Spy Who Shagged Me and thought it was a documentary.
 
I thought they would have results this afternoon already* (In western European time), haven't heard anything yet, anyone knows?

*according to my not always very trustworthy newspaper
 
It is not hitting the moon that is what all the clapping is about. It is hitting the moon in the exact spot they wanted to in order to hopefully stir up any possible ice so that it could be detected and measured.

And yet... nada.

So, they took a craft, sent it flying twice as fast as a bullet and hit the precise spot they wanted to hit in a crater that is perpetually in shadow and has never seen sunlight.

It is like managing to drive a car off the Santa Monica Pier at two miles per second (7,200 mph) and putting it perfectly through a 25 foot hoop after going around the Earth 8 times. Trust me, it was no small achievement.

Don't worry, I wasn't strictly being serious about it ;) I'm damn sure I wouldn't be able to do what they did!
 
And yet... nada.
Nothing is conclusive yet on their findings. We couldn't see anything, but they were scanning and analyzing in multiple ways. As this was in an area believed to be one of the coldest spots in our solar system any minor variations will be detectable when measuring non-visible spectrums.

And even not finding ice is important.
 
I agree with what David Letterman said: Just like the USA blow something up investigate afterward! NASA must not ever watch the SYFY TV because everybody knows what happens when you blow up the moon "It hits Earth":nervous:
 
I agree with what David Letterman said: Just like the USA blow something up investigate afterward! NASA must not ever watch the SYFY TV because everybody knows what happens when you blow up the moon "It hits Earth":nervous:
Good thing there were no bombs then.
 
Good thing there were no bombs then.


When you actually look at what they did, it's amazing, and it was justifiable, but you gotta admit, it's hilarious to the rest of the world that the US shot a rocket at the moon. :D
 
Yup thats the new official name for the old Sci Fi channel. It sounds much more hip and its sure to bring in a hip young audience.

Seriously? Wow, I didn't know that. No wonder I never watch it.
 
I agree with what David Letterman said: Just like the USA blow something up investigate afterward! NASA must not ever watch the SYFY TV because everybody knows what happens when you blow up the moon "It hits Earth":nervous:

I know this was a joke, but I just want to put this in perspective so that everyone understands how comically stupid Hollywood can be.

Causing the moon to hit the earth would be as hard as causing the moon to leave the earth.
 
Since no one else has bothered to actually mention the results to date:
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/science/...Moon-crash-mission-debris-plume-spotted.html#

NASA LCROSS Moon crash mission: debris plume spotted

By Tom Chivers
Published: 10:33AM BST 19 Oct 2009

moon_1504735c.jpg

NASA's first released image of the plume from the LCROSS impact Photo: NASA

Scientists had feared that the plume had been too small to be captured, as both observers on Earth and the Hubble Space Telescope failed to spot anything.

However, the spacecraft trailing behind the rocket, which itself hurtled into the Moon four minutes later, spotted a faint trace of ejecta rising around a kilometre (0.6 miles) into space.

Earth-bound observers would have been unable to spot any plume that was less than two kilometres high. LCROSS principal investigator Anthony Colaprete told New Scientst: "I think we are the only ones that have images.

"The ejecta had to only come out and get into the sunlight a little more than a kilometre [high] for us to see it. It only had to rise half as high."

It had been hoped that the plume would rise as high as 10km. But the hollow rocket and the slightly spongy surface of the Moon meant that this failed to materialise.

However, the lightweight impact, instead of a denser, “cannonball”-style design, meant that the crater would be wide and shallow rather than deep, kicking up more of the surface material the researchers are interested in.

Mr Colaprete said: "What we've been able to get with this is a nice, broad area at relatively shallow depth.

"That's kind of nice because we're interested in stuff a metre or 70 centimetres deep." Previous missions have detected hydrogen in the top 70cm of the lunar soil, which indicates that there may be water.

The researchers hope to have analysed the data from the LCROSS impact by mid-November. We will learn then whether there really is water on the Moon.
 
I know this was a joke, but I just want to put this in perspective so that everyone understands how comically stupid Hollywood can be.

Causing the moon to hit the earth would be as hard as causing the moon to leave the earth.

You could, if you told it you wanted a closer relationship with Cruithne. ;)
 
Back