- 1,086
- St-Hyacinthe, QC
- GTP_pilmat
- pilmat
A sad day came just before Christmas, my beloved G27 got to the point where it was no longer fun to drive. It didn't die or break, it is just plain worn out. There was a time when I was putting in way more hours a week than I would like to publicly admit Add to that my G27 was the test bed where I learned a lot about how the wheel was made (I've had it fully apart more than a few times) and the amount of customizing I've done. Then I beat it to a pulp with Dirt 3...
Alas, it knocks and bangs a lot, and it has gotten far to "thumpy" in FFB.
Something peculiar about my G27 is that it the only one that I have seen, and I've seen about a dozen, that spins as fast as it does in initialization. It gets to its end stops quickly and with a large bang! I have always enjoyed its great smoothness and fantastic "rear end feel" in FFB, and found that I always seemed a little faster on my home wheel.
But it has just gotten worse recently. I've re-greased the rack and pinion and added a bit of spring load to the rack spring, both helped a bit. It's just time to admit that it is worn out and move on.
The obvious question was "what to do?". Do I replace it with another G27, or change wheel altogether?
The title of this thread will tell you what I decided, but I'll give you my reasoning too. The G27, in my opinion, is the best FFB algorithm. It is the wheel that gives the driver the most natural feedback as to what the car is doing. I have run back to back tests with a T500 and G27 with several real race cars drivers and to their surprise, the feel of the G27 is the one they like the most. It is very accurate at telling you where the front tires are an the way into the corner, but is the best at providing you with timely information as to when the back starts to break loose. The T500 is very good at both as well, and combined with its stronger and smoother motor, gives a great drive. But the G27, even with the stock wheel, is just a bit better.
A good friend has a CSR Elite wheel and I have quite a bit of miles done with it. We can proudly say that his wheel has never given him any problems! But even after several firmware updates, the FFB algorithm is behind the Logitech and Thrustmaster offerings.
So why did I choose the T500, especially when I dislike the pedals and would prefer the paddles to be on the wheel? Well it is about long term durability. I use my rig for fun and as a teaching/learning tool for real cars, so I need to know that what I'm doing today will be the same as in several months from now
Now on to what I'm about to get into!
Pictured is a V5 wheel I found on Kijiji, the DSD T500RS wheel adapter (thanks Derek for the always swift shipping) and a modified Human Racing GT Chassis wheel mounting plate and risers. The JohnBodin G27 pedal adapter is in the mail.
The project should be straight forward (well it is in head). I'll remove the GT wheel and install my OMP Superturismo wheel and DSD SLI-M plate on the DSD wheel adapter. The SLI USB wire will be fed down a hole to be made in the adapter. This wire will then be fed through the yet-to-be removed T500 connector in the centre of the wheel and then out the back of the wheel to my PC. That's the way I wired the G27. The PS3 direct control is removed, but if I decide to get into GT6, I can use the DS3 to operate in the menus.
The monied rig plate and risers are an attempt to put the T500 a little bit closer to where the G27 is on the HR chassis. The T500 base is substantially larger than the G27 and it also moss the wheel closer to the driver and up. The lowered risers drop the wheel 16.5mm (0.680") and the re-drilled holes wove it back about the same. It's a small change but allows me to find a better wheel position on the chassis.
Also, it's important to remove the rubber feel from under the wheel. If they are left, the wheel frame can bend when the mounting screws are tightened!
That's it for now. The install should be complete over the next couple of days with lots of pictures
Alas, it knocks and bangs a lot, and it has gotten far to "thumpy" in FFB.
Something peculiar about my G27 is that it the only one that I have seen, and I've seen about a dozen, that spins as fast as it does in initialization. It gets to its end stops quickly and with a large bang! I have always enjoyed its great smoothness and fantastic "rear end feel" in FFB, and found that I always seemed a little faster on my home wheel.
But it has just gotten worse recently. I've re-greased the rack and pinion and added a bit of spring load to the rack spring, both helped a bit. It's just time to admit that it is worn out and move on.
The obvious question was "what to do?". Do I replace it with another G27, or change wheel altogether?
The title of this thread will tell you what I decided, but I'll give you my reasoning too. The G27, in my opinion, is the best FFB algorithm. It is the wheel that gives the driver the most natural feedback as to what the car is doing. I have run back to back tests with a T500 and G27 with several real race cars drivers and to their surprise, the feel of the G27 is the one they like the most. It is very accurate at telling you where the front tires are an the way into the corner, but is the best at providing you with timely information as to when the back starts to break loose. The T500 is very good at both as well, and combined with its stronger and smoother motor, gives a great drive. But the G27, even with the stock wheel, is just a bit better.
A good friend has a CSR Elite wheel and I have quite a bit of miles done with it. We can proudly say that his wheel has never given him any problems! But even after several firmware updates, the FFB algorithm is behind the Logitech and Thrustmaster offerings.
So why did I choose the T500, especially when I dislike the pedals and would prefer the paddles to be on the wheel? Well it is about long term durability. I use my rig for fun and as a teaching/learning tool for real cars, so I need to know that what I'm doing today will be the same as in several months from now
Now on to what I'm about to get into!
Pictured is a V5 wheel I found on Kijiji, the DSD T500RS wheel adapter (thanks Derek for the always swift shipping) and a modified Human Racing GT Chassis wheel mounting plate and risers. The JohnBodin G27 pedal adapter is in the mail.
The project should be straight forward (well it is in head). I'll remove the GT wheel and install my OMP Superturismo wheel and DSD SLI-M plate on the DSD wheel adapter. The SLI USB wire will be fed down a hole to be made in the adapter. This wire will then be fed through the yet-to-be removed T500 connector in the centre of the wheel and then out the back of the wheel to my PC. That's the way I wired the G27. The PS3 direct control is removed, but if I decide to get into GT6, I can use the DS3 to operate in the menus.
The monied rig plate and risers are an attempt to put the T500 a little bit closer to where the G27 is on the HR chassis. The T500 base is substantially larger than the G27 and it also moss the wheel closer to the driver and up. The lowered risers drop the wheel 16.5mm (0.680") and the re-drilled holes wove it back about the same. It's a small change but allows me to find a better wheel position on the chassis.
Also, it's important to remove the rubber feel from under the wheel. If they are left, the wheel frame can bend when the mounting screws are tightened!
That's it for now. The install should be complete over the next couple of days with lots of pictures