My review of the Fanatec 911 Carrera wheel

  • Thread starter mf-dif
  • 31 comments
  • 15,869 views
161
mf-dif
SCTuning
Update 11/02/10:
Initial set-up video review with Playseat Evo.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1-4dCKNrju4

NEW Firmware 681 gameplay video review with GT5P, Dirt 2 and NFS Shift.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=we-1x0ufOlE

Just for some background, the wheels that I have owned most recently include the Logitech G25 and MS Xbox 360 wheels. So I will be offering some comparisons between those. I'm 100% a console guy...so I cannot speak to things PC.

P1020511.jpg


U_DSC_0014.jpg


The wheel itself is a little bit larger than the G25 and a lot larger than the MS unit. It has what I believe to be the core of the GT3 RS Fanatec wheel…same shape and face. The grip however is rubber and not anthracite. I’m fine with rubber grips…the MS rubber wheel grip is great but this one I’m not a fan of. Mainly because it feels sticky. I think it’s purely a preference thing, but the rubber grips too well. With gaming wheels and real driving, when I turn right, I like to slowly release my grip and allow the wheel to rotate back to the left and return to a straight line. Can’t really do that with this because it sticks right to your hands.

The button integration is very slickly done. All the silver markings you see are button with multiple touch points. I was a bit worried since I only use this on PS3 since I didn’t see anything that looked like a dpad…but its there on the bottom spoke very natural looking.

U_DSC_0024.jpg


The gearshift while it doesn’t look as good as the Logitech offerings, feels a lot better than the G25. It’s tight, has good resistance, and the piston handle is very sturdy. The G25 was very sloppy and hollow feeling. The only thing that catches me up sometimes is a mis-shift into 2nd…since reverse gear is up and to the left.

U_DSC_0021.jpg


The pedal gets the job done but is one of the weak points in this package. The gas pedal I really like…feels great. The brake pedal while it has a good amount of resistance…has a very short amount of travel. Essentially pressing what would be considered half way, is the bottom of the pedal travel. The clutch pedal is springy…feels good until about half way…after that it falls right down to the floor with little resistance.

U_DSC_0019.jpg


So the important part…how it works. The wheel itself has decent force feedback. If you’ve never had a FF wheel before you will be blown away. If you have…again comparing it to the G25 chain drive (as this model is chain drive as well), it feels a little lazy. It’s not as snappy as the Logitech offerings. The Fanatec can give you a forearm work out for sure…but it acts kind of lazily while doing so. It’s not as “twitchy”…but for some that could be a big plus. The gearshift is awesome feeling, and the pedals respond very well to minor inputs. There are a lot of options to the wheel that you can adjust on the fly that the Logitech wheels simply don’t offer. You can adjust dead zones, FF, abs, and a few more I can’t remember…but it also lets you save multiple setups.

Compatibility wise…it works on GT5P, NFS Shift, Dirt 2….those are the only games I def know it works on that I can speak for. It does not work on Sega Rally Evo…where the G25 did. I dunno what that means…but I suspect older PS3 games this may not work on….although GT5P is really old but I’m sure they designed this wheel with that game on their radar.

Overall for the price, this is not a bad buy. With a FF wheel, 3 pedals, and 6spd gearbox…nothing really offers all that at this price unless you go used market. It is exactly what I believe Fanatec set this wheel out to be…a casual games wheel. It’s not as rewarding as a high-end wheel, but right in the middle ground that gives you a taste of what those 300-400 wheels could be like.
 
Last edited:
Thanks for the review. Some comments:
1. The FF on PSE has just been improved a lot with the new FW 678 which is available on my blog at 911wheel.com. On some PWCs we had some issues after the FW was installed so please wait for the next FW release but there will be some significant imporvement here.

2. Clutch
Well, the strange feeling you described is actually a feature ;)
Not sure if you have driven a car with clutch before but the resistance of a clutch is declining after it is disengaged. We tried to emulate that feeling and not just let the clucth pedal feel like any of the other pedals as you know it from your G25.

3. Your comments on the grip are noted
If we get more complaints we can make the grip harder but so far everybody reported that they like it. But this is certainly a matter of taste.

Thomas
 
Didn't know these wheels could receive firmware upgrades...thats a big plus in my book! Can't wait for the next reflash. On the clutch feel...I guess I'm just used to the heavy clutch in my Subaru. It's stiff as nails, but I know most cars are not like that.
 
Last edited:
Didn't know these wheels could receive firmware upgrades...thats a big plus in my book! Can't wait for the next reflash. On the clutch feel...I guess I'm just used to the heavy clutch in my Subaru. It's stiff as nails, but I know most cars are not like that.

Sounds like your Subie clutch engages and disengages almost a the bottom of travel. I know my clutch is about half way down.
 
Loving the wheel, (FFB does seem abit light though!) Just a few questions for Thomas (Fanatec...)
Do I still have to pay those massive fees of like 18€ when buying a 2€ item?

The bottom shifter rod for me is a rock! Hard to put in, hard to get in. I have tried loosening those things but it doesn't work. Any suggestions?
 
Loving the wheel, (FFB does seem abit light though!) Just a few questions for Thomas (Fanatec...)
Do I still have to pay those massive fees of like 18€ when buying a 2€ item?

The bottom shifter rod for me is a rock! Hard to put in, hard to get in. I have tried loosening those things but it doesn't work. Any suggestions?

Get a hammer and pound it in with short taps. That's what I did with the bottom rod as well. Put a hand towel over the tip of the rod to protect it from damage.
 
Get a hammer and pound it in with short taps. That's what I did with the bottom rod as well. Put a hand towel over the tip of the rod to protect it from damage.

Or you could just use a rubber hammer 👍
 
The new firmware changes this thing into a different wheel on the PS3. My main hang up was the force feedback rebound which is now fixed! For example making a 90 degree turn, the wheel would not rebound back to center after coming out of the turn. Now it does this effortlessly.
 
The new firmware changes this thing into a different wheel on the PS3. My main hang up was the force feedback rebound which is now fixed! For example making a 90 degree turn, the wheel would not rebound back to center after coming out of the turn. Now it does this effortlessly.

This is why I am such a supporter of Fanatec wheels, they seem to continually improve them, having either noticed a fault or being told of one by their customers.

However, I am well aware of the counter argument that they should have been as they later become when they first came out of the box!!!!!!!
 
Thanks for the review. Some comments:
1. The FF on PSE has just been improved a lot with the new FW 678 which is available on my blog at 911wheel.com. On some PWCs we had some issues after the FW was installed so please wait for the next FW release but there will be some significant imporvement here.

2. Clutch
Well, the strange feeling you described is actually a feature ;)
Not sure if you have driven a car with clutch before but the resistance of a clutch is declining after it is disengaged. We tried to emulate that feeling and not just let the clucth pedal feel like any of the other pedals as you know it from your G25.

3. Your comments on the grip are noted
If we get more complaints we can make the grip harder but so far everybody reported that they like it. But this is certainly a matter of taste.

Thomas

Ok! This right here was my selling point! I was still a bit undecided about the wheel, but after this reply I am now convinced and will definitely purchase this wheel in the next few weeks!
 
So, after this review, can we say that this Porsche wheel is better than the G27 (that costs twice the price) ?
 
So, after this review, can we say that this Porsche wheel is better than the G27 (that costs twice the price) ?

No, the G27 is quieter (to an extent), and the pedal set is better, not sure about the FFB though.
So is it more value for money... yes.
Is it better... not really.
 
Nice review. I have some questions about the FW update. Which button is the Base button? Is it that one on the left you have to press along with select to get in to the PS3 mode? And in step 12 those 4 lower main buttons are those which on the right side would be X,O, square and triangle and on the left they would be LSB, RSB?

Thank you and sorry for dumb question

EDIT: solved
 
Last edited:
No, the G27 is quieter (to an extent), and the pedal set is better, not sure about the FFB though.
So is it more value for money... yes.
Is it better... not really.

You're right, I didn't mean to say that the Fanatec wheel is better than the G27, but at least as good as the G27. I dont really care about the noise. I just hope it is easy to replace the wheel by a real one. An d also to separate the shift lever from the base of the wheel. And I have an idea how to ''invert'' the pedals.

So Fanatec wheel will be my next Christmas gift !

Thanks for the review and the answers to my questions !
 
Nice review and seeing the Playseat takes me back a bit.

Ive always had the same reservations about the grip looking a bit cheap and wondered how it would feel in the hand. Also why Fanatec choose to make this blue? Not found of the blue/black mixmatch.

Personally I think for an extra 10-15 in currency if the whole wheel was black and had a leather, even faux leather wheel rim.
Forme anyways it would of improved it and would of matched the black pedals/shifter better.

Compared to other wheels like the DFGT/Ferrari this one seems the best wheel yet the oddest in looks and the wheel rim is in my view a cost saving measure too far. It would be nice to see Fanatec considering a revised V2 then again for the price it is hard to fault the wheel.
 
Last edited:
Nice review and seeing the Playseat takes me back a bit.

Ive always had the same reservations about the grip looking a bit cheap and wondered how it would feel in the hand. Also why Fanatec choose to make this blue? Not found of the blue/black mixmatch.

Personally I think for an extra 10-15 in currency if the whole wheel was black and had a leather, even faux leather wheel rim.
Forme anyways it would of improved it and would of matched the black pedals/shifter better.

Compared to other wheels like the DFGT/Ferrari this one seems the best wheel yet the oddest in looks and the wheel rim is in my view a cost saving measure too far. It would be nice to see Fanatec considering a revised V2 then again for the price it is hard to fault the wheel.

I would like if this had the grip of the DFGT, the looks kinda shaky, but I hardly look at the wheel when racing.
 
Hi guys, I would like to know what is the BACK BUTTON.
I know only the BASE BUTTON, but the Back Button+Base Button is manadatory to switch from PC Mode to PS3 Mode !

pls help me.
 
gunboy,

I bet they called it the Back button by accident. On my PWTS, I have a Back button (an Xbox term), but on the PWC, it's where the Select button is. Try holding the Base and Select buttons to enter PS3 mode.
 
gunboy,

I bet they called it the Back button by accident. On my PWTS, I have a Back button (an Xbox term), but on the PWC, it's where the Select button is. Try holding the Base and Select buttons to enter PS3 mode.

YES !!!
I've solved the issue.

Best regards.
 
Hi all. :) Anyone know if f/w update 681 is still available for d/l. I can't get the link at Thomas' site to work, the older 678 will download but not 681?
 
Try again. The link works for me as of right now. It might have been down for a bit because they just revised the file with additional documentation.
 
Try again. The link works for me as of right now. It might have been down for a bit because they just revised the file with additional documentation.

....Lucky 🤬 your getting a free new Fanatec wheel, proper new... latest model :drool:
 
Back