I bought the DFP wheel couple of weeks ago and it has most certainly improved my GT4 experience. Playing with the DS2 just doesnt seem right nemore.
Anywayz, my friend brought over his MadCatz wheel over yesterday so we could test and compare our wheels. The first impressions i got when using the wheel was that i had to turn it all the way to its lock position before i could actually make my car turn. Basically, the accuracy and the precision of the madcatz did not compare to that of the DFP. Gernally speaking, the DFP is made more durable and reliable then the MadCatz.
I have a laminate flooring so i got really frustrated when i had to keep moving the pedals into a comfortable position during a race where as the DFP pedals stuck to the floor like glue.
The little bar on teh madcatz that lights up when u accelerate seemed pretty kool but served no real purpose. In terms of design and feel, the DFP beats the Madcatz hands down. U just cant be a leather feel as compared to a plastic feel.
I use a desk for my wheel setup and the DFP fits perfectly onto it with the height aligned to my tv making for a nice racing experience. WHen i placed the madcatz on my desk, I kinda lost the "racing experience" i had with my DFP. Because the madcatz wheel was postioned at a lesser angle then the DFP, i kinda felt like i was driving a school bus instead of a car.
As for the clamping system, the suction cup system the madcatz has isnt going to hold the wheel down if ur a 'rough' person.
After a couple of hrs of playing, i eventually got used to the Madcatz and my friend eventually got used to the DFP. The difference in our driving was that he got BETTER in GT4 while it felt like i was LOSING my driving abilites in GT4.
In terms of force feedback, the DFP triumphs over the madcatz 100 fold but thats a no brainer
.
If u have not owned a wheel before, the madcatz is not a bad choice as youll have nuthing to compare it to so you'll naturally get used to it. But for people that have own previous wheels (I used to have the Micrsoft sidewinder wheel which i though was the greatest before i got my DFP), the DFP is the BEST wheel for obtainignt he BEST driving experience.