CLOSED: POLL: The Photomode Competition: Week 24 - STRAIGHT POLL (WINNER: Pato Milan)

  • Thread starter SlipZtrEm
  • 42 comments
  • 2,859 views

THEME: Straight Lines

  • [URL="http://www.flickr.com/photos/gtpnismo_skyline/5711411090/in/photostream/"][img]http://farm3.st

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    99
  • Poll closed .
Status
Not open for further replies.

SlipZtrEm

can't kick this feeling
Staff Emeritus
27,387
Canada
Toronto
NewAesthetic
SlipZtrEm
pmcheaderwk24.jpg

Further explanation of the theme, provided by JediRage:

"What do you prefer? Slipstreaming towards the finish line on Fuji or shifting through the gears
on Suzuka's S curves? Would you rather listen to the roar of the wind on the Mulsanne Straight
or the groans of a car's engine as it handles Laguna Seca's Corkscrew at speed?"

CARS: Any
LOCATIONS: All except Autumn Ring
PHOTOTRAVEL: No
UNIQUE RESTRICTIONS: At least 1 car in photo

rulesh2h.jpg


Please, ensure you read and understand all requirements for this competition. Failure to follow the rules may result in disqualification.
If you have any questions, please, send me a Private Message.
This Thread has everything you need to know.

  • Be reminded that only the best 30 entries will get through the Classic Poll Style; and best 15 for each poll in a H2H Poll Style.
  • Do not vote on your entry;
  • Do not try to sway the poll;
  • In the event of a tie, a 24 hour poll is created;
  • In the event of a second tie, Judge's vote is the deciding factor;
  • Please, view each image in it's full size, before voting;

 
Poll News:

This side is an image down compared to Curves - one of the entries sent to me had a preview image too large. Go forth, vote!
 
6th Image isn't a Straight and Come on.
Neither did I nor Jamie make the Poll which is strange .But anyway congrats to those who did
 
RE: #6
As far as I know (though obviously it's JediRage's call, not mine), it was chosen because while the car in the image is rounding a turn, the highlight of the image, the focal point, is the straight?

Eh, my interpretation, though I'll even admit, it's a long stretch of one ;)
 
Hey bmxmitch, I told you your straight shot was good didn't I. :)
 
I have a question, why didn't my shot make the poll:

I'll tell you what I think when I see this photo. Your photo has subject, but it lacks strength because of its lack of illumination. The little speck of sky in the photo is too distracting from what you wanted to accomplish.

Low-key photography works only if there are no distracting elements within the frame. You had the idea, but executed it too poorly for it to be convincing and provocative.
 
Wow, surprise i didn't make into the poll. Thought i could get a ago on this PMC. :ill:
Mind share your thought on this? :D
 
Man, I thought I had a good chance at making this poll. Oh well, I'll have to cross my fingers for the CCCL poll:scared:
Some really great pics here, good job to everyone that made it!
 
6th Image isn't a Straight and Come on.
Neither did I nor Jamie make the Poll which is strange .But anyway congrats to those who did

Answer is below ...

i didnt make it either :(
and yeah whats up with the 6th?

Aidan, your pic was excellent with the backfire and I can understand how hard it was to capture it, but in close up shots I always get distracted by the circles not being circles but polygonals with slightly defined sides. If it's any consolation, you were one of the last to drop out.

Sorry :(

Any thoughts on why I didn't make it ?


While your pic is good, it is a little dark and didn't jump at me right away. I guess it's a matter of preference.

lololol #6.

answer below ...

RE: #6
As far as I know (though obviously it's JediRage's call, not mine), it was chosen because while the car in the image is rounding a turn, the highlight of the image, the focal point, is the straight?

Eh, my interpretation, though I'll even admit, it's a long stretch of one ;)

Yes, that is correct. This is one of the grey areas I was worried about. And at first I wasn't going to consider this. But take for example some of the shots in the curves poll. They have just exited or are entering a curve but not actually on it. But they still count as curves photos. I chose this photo because the primary focus was the long straight (and he's managed to get the pits too) and the lighting is just about right.

I have a question, why didn't my shot make the poll:


Good shot overall. Just like Aidan's you were perhaps the last one to drop out. The thing that decided against you were the lighting (I know you were going for a certain effect) but I had to strain my eyes to see the car and the road lines ahead. I like the idea but the execution was just a tad off. Maybe in 2.0 you might have been able to pull off what you wanted to do . :)

Wow, surprise i didn't make into the poll. Thought i could get a ago on this PMC. :ill:
Mind share your thought on this? :D

I might sound like a broken record here, but you were also one of the last to drop out. I just felt that it lacked a certain character, something to differentiate it from a regular high speed photo. In some ways it was harder to judge the straight lines because the margin between the entries was much closer.

I see B&W is a common trend in the straight bunch :D Bugatti and straight line go hand in hand.

Haha, yeah. I was aware that was the case, but what could I do? They were excellent all of them.

Man, I thought I had a good chance at making this poll. Oh well, I'll have to cross my fingers for the CCCL poll:scared:
Some really great pics here, good job to everyone that made it!

The brightness put me off a bit. Maybe if you had changed dimensions to a narrower image, it would have also helped to draw attention tot he straight behind it.

Hope this answers any lingering questions (and the confusion around #6). I'd like to point out that the theme was paramount to me and if your photo didn't make it, ask yourself if you were concentrating on the shape of the track and if the photo actually showed it. I saw some close ups of cars and close ups of rumble strips but I didn't think they fit the theme well.

Anymore questions, post them here or PM me. :)
 
Damn, didn't make the poll:



Judging by what DID make the poll, I should have either kept my original entry:

london2s.jpg


or entered the alternate version of my second shot:



Y U NO LOVE COLOUR JEDIRAGE?
 
Cant see a prob with pic 6 at all lol. That was the theme as i interpreted it. Glad to have done something a bit different to everyone else. Good luck to all that made it 👍
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back