I’m not sure which article is being referred above, but I’m probably guessing what journalists are hating on is not the game (don’t think most outlets in the US have review codes yet), but the company and its culture. Things like crunch culture, treatment of LGBTQ+ issues, the marketing campaign, etc.
Not all of it is unique to CDPR, but it does have a bit a of godly status among some of the gaming community and seems like any criticism is met with a lot of resistance. I do have to say I’ve been caught up in the hype wave myself. Reflecting on it a bit, I have to say that it’s possible to be excited about the game, while still not dismissing other issues related to the company making it and the way they operate.