High Stakes on PSX is my absolute favourite.
It also seems to be the most refined from EA Canada. Eden did great with Porsche 2000. Any Black Box era game eats Criterion or Ghost releases, specially with game direction (with some exceptions). It's so difficult to chose a game from them because even when flawed, they are quite special.
Past that, I think NFS peaked with Hot Pursuit 2010. And on a side note, I think SMS never did a greater game than Shift 2.