For the time, it was like seeing an alien ship on wheel, in today's world it seems dated compared to other cars. And not the also forget that the MC12 seems like a better version of this and though similar, does everything better. The FXX if it were to have been the original probably would have got more coolness from me.
The car to me doesn't stand in the same realm as the other F cars (F40, F50) as looks and styling and overall wow factor goes. Sure it was a great performing car especially doing what everyone expects from Ferrari when they think of it, but once again other cars before and after did quite well. The only thing I think Ferrari made cool was building over the top halo cars, a market that has continued and only grown since the car. They also made it "cool" to hand pick as if a god themselves who can own their cars.
I give it a cool for the car but overall I don't find what it produced or rather Ferrari produced to be cool, but Ferrari isn't on the chopping block, so to be objective in a subjective matter (strange) it stays cool for me. Low cool, but cool.