People have given this car lots of flack because it's a BMW shared with Toyota. Like BMW's version of the Toyota Supra, or Toyota's version of the BMW Z4. Now having said all of that, I have always been fond of the Z-series of BMWs since the 2002 ones. This one we're debating is not my favorite of the BMW Z cars (my favorite is the 2009-2016 model Z4's), but I think this is a sharply-designed head-turner of a car. It isn't bonkers, it isn't gorgeous, and it's anything but mundane. You all can debate the Z4/Supra connection 'till kingdom come, but I'll give this a (solid) Cool.