Originally posted by Hooligan
IMO, no. I never liked this Z. Let me correct that: I wanted to like this Z, but it is more a quick scraping together of semi-decent parts rather than a truly great car. The original Z (and most of its descendants) were practically custom-made. You can't tell me that the alloy engine that's used in an SUV is good enough for a flagship sports car. You just can't. Not without me smacking you good and calling you Susan.
Now that there's a copy -- a slower, stodgier copy -- that seems to invalidate the 350Z's sport character. If it's so easily changed from sports coupe to luxury coupe, how much of a sports coupe was it, if ever? I have yet to drive one, so I can't really say. Given some of the reviews, it seems that the car is very much E36 M3 as compared to the E30 M3: not really a M3.
Now that I've seen the G35 coupe (in Kentucky, of all places, and don't as how the flight was because we nearly died, thankyouveddymuch) and I much prefer it to the 350Z. It's more honest to it's character, and to its origins. I think it's the better car.
As for whether the G35 is the US-Skyline, it is. But it's nothing like the previous generation (R34) Skyline. In fact, it's 100% different, sharing name only. For the next generation of the true Skyline, look for the "Nissan GT-R"...and don't expect that to be anyhthing like the R34, either. :-/