Mike's Book Review Thread.

  • Thread starter Mike Rotch
  • 125 comments
  • 9,101 views
Mike Rotch
Writing your own book is pretty damn impressive Red. I'll bare that linky in mind when i can spare so time.

Yeah. I've spent just over a year on it. But lately, I haven't written much in it. I figure it'll take me another year to edit and add enough material to the story (side-plots I guess) to make it a real meaty novel. :)

Hopefully, now that I have my own computer back, I can type out the rest of it and edit from there. I should have the next few parts up at DeviantArt soonish. Nice site, it is.
 
I would imagine for a part-time writer (as in someone who has a job other then writing full time), the inspiration comes in bursts and you have to make the most of it when it happens?
 
Mike Rotch
I would imagine for a part-time writer (as in someone who has a job other then writing full time), the inspiration comes in bursts and you have to make the most of it when it happens?

Well, I'm kind of a "part-time" writer, though I could write pretty much anytime my materials are available which is almost all the time. I'm 17 and still in high school so when I'm not busy, I write there. When I'm at home not practicing my guitar (with only five strings. lol), I play GT3 or when the inspiration or feeling comes, I'm working on my novel. Unfortunately, I think my greatest writing occurs when I'm about to fall asleep when I'm thinking the most and I can focus on it (as much as a sleepy person can). Problem here is I don't have the energy to get up, get my folder and pencil and start writing it out. To fix that, I went and bought me a thick but small spiral notebook that I keep as close as I can at all times, almost more so than the folder with my story in it . I keep a pencil next to my bed, too. When I get a good scene in my head (which is how I write, one badass scene or emotional scene, whatever, to the next scene; whatever is in between takes time) I write it down.

Writing is something you can't do all the time. You have to feel like writing or it just comes out forced and, generally, very shoddy. Sometimes just feeling like writing is a challenge in itself, nevermind coming up with the story, the scenes, the characters.... I mean, yes, you CAN physically write any time you want, but actually wanting to is something else. When you're happy with the story, though--and I mean REALLY happy with it--writing it is easy. But there are those parts that are difficult to write and it's hard to get around them sometimes. The best way then is to push on through, get it done and edit it later.

As far as inspiration goes, I find it EVERYWHERE. It's very much the way an artist might find a brick beautiful and then go home to paint it. It sounds very silly but you'll some of the stupidest sounding ideas into a really cool story or scene or, if you write poetry, it makes for good poetry, too. Being discouraged is, basically, a sin in writing. Everything will work for your purposes but you have to make it work. If you give up once, you'll keep doing it. I suppose, in spite of that, trying something new is always good and fun if nothing else. The trick to fining inspiration is to get out of your four walls, go someplace that isn't familiar so much. I'll go for a walk to the Dollar Store not a quarter of a mile from my house and find inspiration for something in a cloud or someone who happens to be walking down the sidewalk in the distance. I literally found ispiration looking down the sidewalk thinking, "What if I kept walking? How far would I go before I decided to go home? What if I decided not to go home and just to keep walking?" It was a bit like the movie Forest Gump I guess (he just suddenly decides to run across the country in the middle of the movie, then does it like 3 more times).

To answer your question: yes. :D
 
Are you going to get your book published? Sorry if you've already said. I've heard its quite expensive.

By the way good luck with your book. I would like to write a book myself but you have to be naturally good at English. I'm O.K, but I would really need to study it. Well my English teacher said I've got potential, between level 5 and 6 in Year 9 (if you know the UK level system). The test was on types of writing, scary, intense ect. I'm also very good at persuasive writing, I got level 8 I think and that's exceptional.
 
G.T
Are you going to get your book published? Sorry if you've already said. I've heard its quite expensive.

By the way good luck with your book. I would like to write a book myself but you have to be naturally good at English. I'm O.K, but I would really need to study it. Well my English teacher said I've got potential, between level 5 and 6 in Year 9 (if you know the UK level system). The test was on types of writing, scary, intense ect. I'm also very good at persuasive writing, I got level 8 I think and that's exceptional.

Thanks. I didn't mention whether or not I would. But yes I will. I want to get it self-published. I have a money-raising effort in the works. Still, I have plenty of time before publication. The story is almost finished (I'd say about another ten pages and I have over 130 already written by hand). Once I am finished, I am going to edit it all which will probably take several months.

Good news is that I have the time to type most of it now. I can't tell you how nervous I am with nothing but the hard copy! It's all up on my DA page. So far the first 11 parts are here. Admittedly, this book is certainly not everyone's cup of tea. I think paying attention more to the general message than to the relatively unothodox story is more important.
 
Last Book Read: The Lexus Story
Publisher: Melcher Media, 2004
Author: Jonathan Mahler, Maxmillian Potter
Genre: Public Relations and/or Specific Automotive History (?)
Acquired: Award for setting such high standards at work in 2003. Cheap as in free.

Review: This book is all about Lexus, for the 6 or 7 people who were anxiously awaiting the entire story behind the marque. It starts out with a lot of color pictures, mainly press release-type stuff. Nice, but nothing a Lexus afficianado hasn't seen a few dozen times already. The meat of the history is all about why Toyota wanted to make a luxury car brand to rival Europe's best sedans. This is the one fascinating aspect of The Story; the painstaking development of the original LS400, including rare and unrelased prototypes, sketches, drawings, and behind the scenes photos. It even goes on to talk about the initla problems Lexus delt with by entering the market, aas well as few mishaps that occured during the first few months of the launch.

So it starts off interesting; after halfway through the book, it starts to talk about the SC400, the evolution of it's design, and how it came about on the heels of the Lexus success. But the Story seems to lose it's way: It doesn't talk about the failures of the ES250 or the not-so-exciting 1st generation GS300. There's a little talk about the '95 sales drop, but from then on, it's as if the company could do no wrong. Which makes for a bit of a boring read. There's not much talk about the newer GS, the GX, or why the LX450 was just a hastily-rebadged Land Cruiser.

The cover is bound in soft leather, with a real lexus logo (which is talked about in The Story) on it. A very nice tactile feeling when reading, admittedly. That's the other aspect of Lexus, the part that has nothing to do with driving...or reading, for that matter.

Conclusion: 3 out of 10...it took me 6 months to read it because I was interested in the history (which makes for good, relevant conversation with some of my car-geeked customers) of Lexus, because I work for them. So if you don't work for Lexus, or if you don't consider yourself a Lexus Fanatic, or care much for fluffy automotive historical accounts, then this book obviously isn't for you.
 
I'm currently reading The Elements of Typographic Style, but I bet I (and maybe Chris and ALPHA) are the only ones who give a rat's ass about such matters. I'm also (at the same time!) reading The Ultimate Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy (all six books crammed together – and for only $15), but I imagine many people here have already read at least a few of the stories.
 
pupik
Last Book Read: The Lexus Story

Review: The meat of the history is all about why Toyota wanted to make a luxury car brand to rival Europe's best sedans.
Because Honda did. End story.
 
Duke
Because Honda did. End story.
That tarted-up Accord and the Civic with flip-up headlights really set the world on fire in 1986.

When Acura sells as more cars than Lexus does in a year, I'll write the Acura Story.
 
Last book read: A Rumour of War
Author: Philip Caputo

Acquired from: ABE.com
Edition/Type: Softcover, third ed. 19xx (?)
Rating: 7.6/10

Type: Non-Fiction

Comment: Caputo wrote this book any years after having returned from Vietnam. It was the first time he had related his experiences there, and the emotion of having lost and killed perculates through his writing.

Caputo joined the Army "in search of an experience", in order to "grow up", and because he thought it patriotic. He left the army bitter, empty and cynical.

Without revealing too much of the story, it relates his time first as a platoon commander in the beginning of the war, his unwanted move to a desk in Vietnam where he was as he put it "an Officer in charge of the Dead". His job was to record maimings and casualties for war records. He then returned to his command, minus most of the men he had commanded.

The book conveys a good sense of the miserable conditions they operated under. rom neverending rain, to hidden snipers, to heat, to boobytraps to beaurocratic, useless superior commanders.

Its a good telling of Vietnam from a soldiers perspective. A bit slow in places, but let its pace deceive you at your peril.
 
RedWolfRacer
Last Book Read: Black Hawk Down
Author: Mark Bowden

Acquired: Local thrift store (along with a Tom Clancy book or other)
Genre: Military History (independent, unofficial, unauthorized, etc)

*snip*

If you can, I recommend checking out the 3-Disc Deluxe Edition DVD Set. A bit pricey, I know, but it comes with some excellent Special Features.
 
I have FINALLY gotten my hands on a copy of the movie Black Hawk Down. I know this isn't a MOVIE review thread but since I've previously reviewed the book and this thread needs some resuscitation, I'm gonna do it anyways!

I'll forward this by saying read my review of the book. Throughout it I echo, as the author does in the book, that the mission was succesful despite the losses. In the movie, the fact that the mission was a success is completely lost and I was disappointed that none of the CNN footage was included in the ending. The ending, in fact, came quickly, almost as if it were rushed or they couldn't decide how to finish it. No dramatic monologue, just a little bit of text and names.

Despite those "problems", the movie itself is technically astounding. Every even in the book is instantly recognizable in the movie. I will complain that Josh Hartnett seemed like an unlikely actor for the role of Capt. Eversman (sp) but you get used to it. And though the book follows more than 100 people, the movie has only the ability to capture about 40 in a coherent story. Even with less than half of the people, the movie is relatively long at just over 2 hours while following the events that unfolded over 24 hours. I am disappointed that some scenes were cut (my favorite being when a soldier gets his finger shot off, curses, picks up his gun, and shoots the enemy in the head, the very same one who shot his finger!) but what is retained is very well done. The sound and video quality is very good, the acting superb, and the story, though lacking, remains coherent and cut for a general audience--those who have not read the book, for example.

For a complete look at a military operation, the book is a must. For anyone looking for a good recruiting tool for the Army, I'd take the movie. It'll make you cry (probably) or at least angry that such things could happen. Even now, the situation is worsening. As of this week, Somalia's neighboring countries are closing their borders to refugees from Somalia who are looking to avoid the tribal warfare. This some 12 years after the events described in Black Hawk Down.
 
Last book read: Bloody Skies: A 15th AAF B-17 Combat Crew, How They Lived And Died
Author: Melvin McGuire

Acquired from: ABE.com
Edition/Type: Harcover, first ed. with dust jacket 19xx (?)
Rating: 8.5/10

Type: Non-Fiction

Comment: If you are looking for a neatly written account of the end to end experience of a WWII B-17 aviator, you cant do much better than this book. The story is a autobiographical account of Melvin McGuire’s enlistment, training and deployment to Italy as a waist gunner aboard a Flying Fortress. What makes the book special is the little detail added in terms of other crew members. The underlying theme that is cleverly knitted is of a brotherly bond between original crew that was unbreakable through time.

Although the chronology is at time a bit errant, the details of adversity in the air is brilliantly framed against a backdrop of destruction and mortality. The author gives a lovely background of conditions in the air, from lack of oxygen, flak, fire and cold. The stories keep you riveted and the feeling of awe is constant and mounting. Photos adorn the text in relevant places to add colour and setting to his time in Italy and complete the book nicely.

The coup de grace is the epilogue, of lost contact with his original crew for decades, of lost comrades and friends in the jaws of victory and of final burning cruelty when all was won. A fantastic read and a valuable commentary on hero’s forgotten efforts.
 
I apologise to Mike Rotch for stealing his layout...

Last book read: The Very Hungry Caterpillar
Author: Eric Carle

Acquired from: A book shop
Edition/Type: I don't know
Rating: 8/10

Type: Non-Fiction

Comment: I thoroughly enjoyed this book. I couldn't put it down, and from the very first page I knew this would be a great book.
In the light of the moon a little egg lay on a leaf." So begins "The Very Hungry Caterpillar".
This book follows the ravenous caterpillar's path as he eats his way through one apple (and the pages of the book itself) on Monday, two pears on Tuesday, three plums on Wednesday, and so on, through cherry pie and sausage - -until he is really fat and has a stomachache -- I bet you can guess what happens then! The book has a great story and Eric Carle's wonderful collage-like artistry.

It is good for teaching nutrition, counting, science (stages of a butterfly) and the days of the week.

The ending was exciting, and there was a sense of shock at the end, when the faterpillar turns into a Butterfly.

I would thoroughly recommend this book, as it kept me on the edge of my seat throughout.
 
ultrabeat
I apologise to Mike Rotch for stealing his layout...
👍

Last book read: Freakonomics
Author: Steven Levitt and some other guy

Acquired from: T'was a gift
Edition/Type: I don't know
Rating: 1/10

Type: Non-Fiction

Comment: Freakonomics is probably the poorest attempt at writing a cohesive book I have ever encountered. It is billed as “an investigation into hidden side of everything”, but is more like a book of nothing. Do I really care how and why teachers cheat or why crime declined in the 90’s? No, and I surely don’t care for research telling me if a childs name affects their success in life. There is no common thread through the chapters and the subject matter is hardly edge of the seat stuff. I don’t really see the point of why it was published, other then to make money. It contains no message or moral – its could just as easy pass as random academic draft working papers stapled together and bound.

It is a book which has style over substance, and was a sad waste of two hours. I would recommend steering clear of it, there are just so many better books out there to read than this claptrap.
 
Last book read: Haynes Kit Car Manual
Author: Ian Ayre

Acquired from: Online Retailer
Rating: 7.7/10

Type: Non-Fiction

Comment: This is the Haynes manual on kit cars, written by a guy who has previously built two xk120 replicas. a Cobra, a jeep and a few Austin Healy hybrids.

The structure is logical and fluid, beginning with chosing a kit, preparing the garage and tools necessary. It then moves to hints and tips regarding chassis, body, engine, tranny and brake construction. The author keeps the tone light and airy and it helps keep the reading interesting. Various anecdotes are sprinkled around - such as how to appease your significant other, and I found this added a nice personal touch.

There are many colour pictures to illustrate his points and I found myself considering issues not previously thought of. The book was a bit pricey, but I would imagine for someone nearing the purchase of a kit, it could prove invaluable.
 
Book: Mechwarrior:Dark Age--Ghost War
Author: Michael Stackpole

Acquired from: Local store because they didn't have any other decent MW books
Price: About $5 USD I think

Type: Fiction/Science-fiction

The MechWarrior series is--to my knowledge--the longest living science-fiction world to date. If I remember correctly, it was first called BattleTech in the 1980s and was a game played with miniatures. It was something in the vein of Dungeons & Dragons but it played out in mechanized robots known as BattleMechs. When it first started, there were a lot of tournaments. Much as a player would use the historical background of an adventure in D&D, there were historical backgrounds to every battle in BattleTech and in these tournaments, more history would be formed and stories made.

Having lasted twenty years now, the story has become quite complex, so for your convenience, the story has been compiled in a very cool but somewhat confusing digest. This is not it. This is: http://www.classicbattletech.com/cbt_cbt_history.html

Now that you have a very tenuous grasp of the insane amount of detail in the BattleTech universe, you could probably tell that the Dark Age series is a new "chapter" of the story. Despite that, you could read and enjoy this book without much of a background. However, you'll probably want to stay close t o a computer and google search anything you're unfamiliar with.

The author is a veteran of the MechWarrior and BattleTech series of books. In fact, he wrote the first one. He also co-wrote that history digest I linked above. This means that he assumes the reader is fairly familiar with the universe. This means that you won't know your Mad Cats[/b] from your AgroMechs. Fortunately for you, since this is based on the latest iteration of the game, there are tons of pre-painted pictures of the figures that he refers to at the wizkids games site.

Myself, I'm familiar with the background but the start of this book was fairly slow to me. It involved a singular character who worked in an AgroMech. An AgroMech--a detuned version of my favorite BattleMechs designed solely for cutting trees. I felt this was pretty lame, but the story soon picked up. I can't describe how because that's a HUGE plot twist, quite possibly the craziest one I've ever had the pleasure to read.

The battles in the story were surely played out before hand using the MechWarior: Dark Age game set but it's written in a way that really makes it impossible to tell. Of course, this is THE BattleTech novelist we're talking about so he has plenty of experience in this regard. Unfortunately, compared to other MechWarrior books, there aren't many battles. However, this fits in with the story anyway so there isn't much to complain about, I guess.

Okay, I know that this was a huge review, but it needs it! I think if you haven't gotten a taste of the BattleTech universe, then you're really missing out on some good sci-fi. Even if you think giant robots are corny, the BattleTech and MechWarrior novels are worth checking out, though many are now out of print. This book is perhaps not a good introduction to the overall story, but it is very convenient for the new Dark Age stories. This book is very well written but there were parts were even I was confused--mostly parts involving tactics that were discussed before the battle began.

The good: the plot is one of the best I've read. It's sci-fi the way it should be.

The bad: the premise is awkward for a war-centered game. It's an anti-war environment in the story but with war in the shadows. It also requires a knowledge of the background because it isn't described enough in the story or on its cover.

Overall: 8/10
 
For some reason, yesterday it asked me to login after posting and then came up with some error or other that I can't remember. I didn't mean to double post. In fact, I didn't even think it DID post until just now!

My apologies, especially because it was such a long double post. :ouch:
 
RedWolfRacer, were you meant to post that twice? :odd:

ultrabeat
I apologise to Mike Rotch for stealing his layout...

Last book read: The Very Hungry Caterpillar
Author: Eric Carle

Acquired from: A book shop
Edition/Type: I don't know
Rating: 8/10

Type: Non-Fiction

Comment: I thoroughly enjoyed this book. I couldn't put it down, and from the very first page I knew this would be a great book.
In the light of the moon a little egg lay on a leaf." So begins "The Very Hungry Caterpillar".
This book follows the ravenous caterpillar's path as he eats his way through one apple (and the pages of the book itself) on Monday, two pears on Tuesday, three plums on Wednesday, and so on, through cherry pie and sausage - -until he is really fat and has a stomachache -- I bet you can guess what happens then! The book has a great story and Eric Carle's wonderful collage-like artistry.

It is good for teaching nutrition, counting, science (stages of a butterfly) and the days of the week.

The ending was exciting, and there was a sense of shock at the end, when the faterpillar turns into a Butterfly.

I would thoroughly recommend this book, as it kept me on the edge of my seat throughout.
:lol:👍




I haven't read any books myself for a while lately. I should though. :indiff:
 
Book: Night Shift
Author: Stephen King

Acquired from: Flea Market
Rating: 9/10

Type: Horror Fiction

Comment:

In all my years as a Stephen King fan, I have always believed his short stories to be some of the best horror fiction out there. Amazing, then, that I somehow managed to miss reading Night Shift. Next to Nightmares & Dreamscapes, this is his best short story collection. Classic stories like "Graveyard Shift" and "The Manlger" are actually quite chilling, if you allow your imagination to run wild (which is an absolute prerequisite for reading King's horror).

Pick it up and check it out. The nice thing about a collection of short stories is you can take a break from reading in between stories and not lose any necessary information for when you decide to start reading again, and you can skip a story if it hasn't entertained you in the first two pages...
 
Currently reading the very first MechWarrior/BattleTech book "Lethal Heritage", part 1 of the Blood of Kerensky trilogy. Confusing a bit, but still very good thusfar.

Will update when I finish which should be promptly (two weeks depending on how busy I am).
 
Book: Angels and Demons
Author: Dan Brown
Aquired From: Barnes and Noble
Edition/Type: Hardback/Paperback
Genre: Fiction/ Thriller
Rating: 10 of 10

Comments: This book is BRILLIANT, i cannot think of a better word for it. The vivid details and mind bending suspense was very captivating! This book is nothing short from a masterpiece. excellent read! I ended up reading it more than once.

Recommend it? Definately.
 
Book: Lamb: The Gospel According to Biff, Christ's Childhood Pal
Author: Christopher Moore
Acquired From: Bookshop in Salt Lake City Airport

Genre: Fiction/Humourous
Rating: 11 of 10! ;)

Comments: The most laugh-out-loud funny novel I've ever read!
The premise is this:-
It's well known from the Bible, that Jesus was born, and when he hit 30-ish he did a lot of healing, preaching and miracles. However, there's nothing in the Gospels about what he was like as a child.
In an attempt to rectify this, an angel (Raziel) is sent back to Earth to resurrect Christ's best childhood friend, named Biff (!) to tell the story!
Turns out Jesus wasn't the "Prince of Peace" immediately, from Biff's first meeting with Jesus (repeatedly resurrecting a small lizard which his brother keeps killing for entertainment!) to their quest to attain wisdom by seeking out the 3 wise men present at Jesus' birth (including kung-fu fights, a harem of Oriental babes and the "explanation" of the Bread and Fishes miracle!) and Biff's obsession with marrying Jesus' Mum when Joseph passes away!
If you're strictly Christian and uptight about it, this probably isn't for you as it's a little Sacreligious, however, if you have a basic knowledge of the New Testament and can keep the pinches of salt going, it's an incredibly funny and refreshing perspective! There's also the fact that Raziel confines Biff to a hotel room in the US to write his story while the Angel spends all his time watching TV, and Biff makes furtive trips to the bathroom with the copy of the Gideon Bible that he's most disappointed to discover makes no reference to him in relation to Jesus' story, and which makes for some entertaining modern-day related dialogue too! :lol:

Recommend it?: If you want a laugh, this is an absolute must read! I kept my wife awake for a few nights while reading in bed, with constant outbursts of laughter at some of the bizarre situations that they encounter! 👍

Read it & let me know what you think!
 
Last book read: A Beginners Guide to Reality
Author: IaJim Baggins

Acquired from: Local bookstore
Rating: 7.5/10

Type: Non-Fiction

Comment: This book did a great job of making me pick it off the shelf with some interesting blurbs and critical quotes announcing it as something quite special. My feelings are a bit mixed after reading it. The job was a bit tough – convincing the reader that reality is not actually reality. The subject matter covered is quite impressive, however the tone of the book is at time patronising and it detracts slightly from the message trying to be communicated.

The message of the author is quite simple; reality is not reality all. The cliché (but applicable) comparison made is that with the Matrix. Yes on the face of it, it sounds stupid. Reality is real. Isnt it? The stretch the author is making is that how would you know it is reality or not if it were you hooked up to the Matrix?

How the author goes about validating this brave statement in the meat of the book. He explores Plato’s Allagory of the Cave, the concept of the world existing only because human minds make it exist through intentionality, the concept of humans creating such false realities through simulation (e.g. Las Vegas as loose comparison) that true reality is blurred. He looks at whether an individuals reality is based on experience or sense. If experience it should be different for everyone, it by sense, who sure are we that our senses aren’t lying to us ala the Matrix.

As if to prove that he is not trying to lose you in philosophical conundrums, he tries to prove the same point using physics. He introduces special and general relativity and quantum mechanics and how through the Copenhagen Experiment, special and general relativity are potentially overridden and how via the Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen thought experiment and Schrodinger’s Cat postulate, quantum mechanics may not hold true. Given this, which reality is true?

An interesting book indeed requiring some previous knowledge of physics and quantum mechanics, soured marginally by the tone of the authors writing.



PS: Nice reviews guys 👍
 
Good news guys: I talked with a writer today who currently works for the regional newspaper. He's written a few novels and has agreed to help me come up with an edited draft and possibly aid me in getting my book published. My goal now is to have the first draft done by the end of the week. The next few weeks, I will generate my second draft with the aid of this mentor of mine. Hopefully the next step will be to fine-tune it for a final draft and send it off to get looked at by a publisher or agent. If I'm lucky, by the end of the year it'll be on the shelves for you to read and review!

Anywho, almost done reading my current book. A review will be posted sometime next week.
 
Back