Well think about this: a 412hp Mustang does 0-60 in 4.3 seconds.
A 425hp Challenger does 0-60 in 4.8 seconds. Now imagine that the Challenger had a 480hp and an 8A. It would be faster, and would compete better.
No the 290hp Challenger WILL NOT BEAT THE V6 MUSTANG. But it will compete BETTER with the group. Then again, you all missed one car: the Genesis Coupe. It's in fact better than the V6 Mustang.
And yes an 8 Speed Auto is too many gears, if Dodge could have sourced Fiat for a 7 Speed Dual-Clutch, it would be perfect. But look at this: Mercedes-Benz is introducing a 9-Speed Automatic in about 3 years (for a car codenamed SLV, a smaller SLS). I sure do think the 8 Speed Auto should stick where it's been, in Rolls-Royces and Bentleys (when you got one of these, you probably aren't even driving it.)
And am I smoking anything funny? No. I just like the idea of better competition and I have an optimistic approach to every new car, I want the car to be well-recieved. Cars like the Nassau (Sebring replacement), Fiat 500, the next New Beetle, upcoming Volvo S60 and Saab 9-5. I could go all day.
And I'm pretty sure my mom would wring my neck for the next 30.2 years of my life if I ever smoked anything.
Oh, before I forget, you are so welcome for the laugh. Even though it's not funny.