Hm, well glad we got the replacement deal. We asked if it covered mishaps that may occur as a result of having a new kitten in the house.
And they said "yes" - if the kitten did something nasty with the disc, they'd replace it. So I forked over the extra $3.
Assuming this would cover a flaw like that. Though it should be replaceable anyway if the game comes with a flaw, right?
Though, thus far I didn't have any issues.
But in my experience, it doesn't take much to have such issues. A small smudge of something in the right spot seems to be enough to monkey with certain disc data. How many of us actually wash our hands & blot them dry with a fresh towel carefully immediately before handling game discs? (Okay so some persnickety people probably do.
)
It reminds me of how a few years ago (not that many actually), I had this old Sega game player that the friend who had the apt I had had before me, had left behind. And I started using it to listen to CD audio books from the library.
It was working fine for that purpose. And then, right in the middle of what I was listening to (Mysterious Mr. Quinn - if anyone's interested
), it made a weird noise garbling the narrator, and shut the entire thing down. I turned it back on, and tried to continue from that spot, and at that spot, it powered down again. Usually a dirty CD from the library would simply skip. But I took the CD out to inspect it under a light, and noticed a glob of what looked like strawberry jam.
It was so near the center of the disc I had trouble imagining how it was causing the problem early in the recording, but then I don't really know how data is physically stored on discs. I cleaned it off, and it worked fine the rest of the time.
But anyway the reason I think of that is because sometimes minor flaws in discs might be a problem with the actual player (or game system as the case may be). As the optical reader might degrade for reading the disc, it could become more sensitive to problems with the given disc.
So I'm thinking that problems with the disc, might be yes, the disc, but also with the machine trying to play the disc in combination.
In short, I wouldn't rule out a problem with console, unfortunately.