- 40,768
Which I'd also say is pretty indicative of a slow news day, or one of those other things I mentioned.It had nothing to do with being a slow news day: we've covered a bunch of other automotive news lately.
That's because it's being used as a point of comparison due to the specific wording EDK used in his original response.The only mention I've seen of the Suggestions forum came from you, not anybody else.
No, it absolutely does not. The Challenger thread was not the sprawling cesspit of the GT Sport General Discussion thread, where day to day what people are talking about changes and the thread moves so fast that you would have to basically skip anything talked about previously. It was a thread about a specific car model that really only ever talked about that specific car model. Trim levels and updates are still relevant when they are of fundamentally the same vehicle. The "narrative" for this car has from the start directly followed the same "narrative" that the Challenger has had since it debuted; and the "narrative" that the Hellcat in particular had which this car is a derivative of.The Demon is a pretty significant update to an existing car. It generates a lot of discussion on its own. Instead of dropping it into a three-year old thread and hoping those that haven't been keeping a close eye on it know where the relevant discussion starts, spinning it off into its own thread makes it easier for people to talk about it and follow the narrative.
Going from that:
It makes it considerably harder to chase down specific past posts discussing the topic, for one. It makes it more inconvenient to find points of conversation that may have already been discussed, for two. It breaks up the flow of discussion into something actually confusing when it's not easy to ascertain whether a post should go in an existing thread that is similar or a different thread that is also similar, which can and almost always does cause overlap between the smaller threads, for three. You probably disagree with all three of those, and likely EDK would as well; but you're not the only one who is a moderator on a large fan forum and those are my experiences.What's silly about having more concise threads on particular subjects?
This thread was talking about the first PR photos on Sunday. Nonetheless, I misspoke on "official."I'm looking at the calendar, and the official reveal happened Tuesday night.
Last edited: