The "Rate My Photo" thread! **Read the OP Before You Post**

[DSUjoeDirte9]

[/url] Laguna Seca Raceway_4 by wilza01, on Flickr[/IMG]

This is a very nice photo especially considering it has not been edited at all as far as i can tell. It has the blue tint from that cool filter that makes it look like a nice drive in the morning. The only problem i have with it is its too centered on the car. I think you may have been able to angle is a little bit better towards were you were going and make a little more of a interesting look. For me... and my rating system, 7.8523/10 (7.9/10)

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Mine: Its my first attempt at a snow edit and while im not really satisfied with it, i need some feedback to see were im at with the editing. Ps... this is also my first edit that took more than 5 seconds using some filter on photoshop. So be constructively mean XD

Origional: http://imageshack.us/a/img33/4720/nrburgringnordschleifeh.jpg

I know the sunrise kinda messes it up a bit but idk how to fix that.. or the tips of trees all that well.

 

[driftinziggy]

@DSU.. It's not the kind of edit I'm qualified to rate because I don't do the "heavy" edits.. but here goes.. 7/10.. The overall tone is a little too blue for me and I'm not sure where my attention is supposed to be.. I'm drawn to the sun more than the cars.. maybe someone else would like it a bit more..

Trans Cammer 1 by driftinziggy, on Flickr

Trans Cammer 3 by driftinziggy, on Flickr

 

[GTracer98]

Oh god, those are fantastic! I don't know what to criticize. Maybe the last shot would have been a tad better if it was done in the middle of tunnel but that doesn't change the fact that I love those photos. It's a 9.5 from me.


Pure Monster - The F40 by DocArmor98, on Flickr

 

[EstonianBeast]

I like the fisheye effect, the angle is a little weird for me tho. The colors are nice and vibrant. I'd give this 8/10, i would also like to add that in my opinion the pic would be more awsome if it would focus on the engine.

Here's mine, these are unedited:

 

[F3000]

^^^^
1. i give a 9/10 i like that old feel to it with the black and white filter

2. 5/10 i just can't deal with the angle.

3. 8/10 it's good, it has a nice sense of speed.

 

[wiithepeople]

7/10 not the best drifting angle I've seen but it's a great unedited photo.

 

[Fazerfan]

wiithepeople:

1: The car doesnt stand out, it has been blended to the asphalt. Not my cup of tea

2: Very artistic pic, i personally dont like it.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------



Click for bigger version!

 

[GTracer98]

I'd say 7.5/10. Love the atmosfere but I think that the composition could be a bit better, also the numberplate feels wrong.


Beautiful Spring by DocArmor98, on Flickr

 

[Taiga]

I'd say 7.5/10. Love the atmosfere but I think that the composition could be a bit better, also the numberplate feels wrong.


Beautiful Spring by DocArmor98, on Flickr

The picture looks absolutely wonderful! Love the dark, muted tones in here.
The soft filter is doing the image justice; brings forth a 'ghostly' feel that is very much felt.

You've managed to make the car stand out in the photo and not let it blend into the objects around it.
Your colour choice provides the 'pop' a photo with muted tones like this very much would benefit from.
The contrast of the photos is also done very well, aiding the object of focus in standing out but I feel that the shadows and midtones could be lightened just a little, especially around the body of the car.
The over-exposed sky fits very nicely into the 'ghostly' theme pushed through.

Composition, while great, can be improved on if you left more space between the car and the right border. It would also provide a much better perspective, IMHO, if the focal length was decreased a bit.

Great photo, great mood, great tonal work, good composition. Tiny areas of improvements, but a solid 8.5 for you.


My turn:

​

 

[ECGadget]

Lets revive this!
I like that picture, good use of the angles. I think it is a little dull in colour though, but it definately has character. 8/10!

 

[r00tzownage]

I will give it a 6/10. Just because the angle is pretty default and the positioning too. Sorry bro

 

[IREWolfman]

 

[Metry45tacos]

 

[Beeblebrox237]

Hmm, I think I'd give this photo a 6/10. Ilike the toning, and the colour of the car is great. However, the angle is a bit unnatural, and the composition seems a bit random, without any sort of unification. Also, the dive planes detract from the look of the car.

​

 

[BlazeTheCat05]

​

I'll give this an 8/10. Nice colors and essence of speed, but not a huge fan of the 'fisheye' effect. Still a nice pic.

Here's my contribution, straight from GT5 (unedited):

 

[Metry45tacos]

. Can u even see this

 

[driftinziggy]

^nope

 

[Metry45tacos]

^nope

What do ya think?

 

[shmogt]

^looks pretty sick 8/10