We need a next-gen pool/billiards game

  • Thread starter Jedi2016
  • 10 comments
  • 3,249 views
Who else agrees? I would imagine the reason we haven't already seen one is demand. Virtual billiards games have always been little more than a niche genre. But this is the age of the downloadable game, which cuts overhead significantly. And let's be frank, a pool game probably doesn't warrant a full DVD or Blu-ray disc anyway. And let's not forget the online component.

There's one game that I picked up very early on in the PS2's lifetime called Real Pool. It's nothing special, really. First-gen jaggy graphics (especially on the big-screen), simplified interface, sometimes seems too easy against the computer. But every time I make a run to turn in old games at Gamestop, this one always gets left behind, and I find myself dusting it off every few months and playing a few games. But, with today's HD anti-aliased high-dynamic-range graphics and newfangled physics engines, we need an update.

Now, in this wonderful next-gen era of ours (which is actually just "this gen" now), it seems like it would be rediculously easy to create a near-photorealistic pool game. And to dedicate an entire processor to nothing but physics calculation for the balls.

From my digging, there are only two "next-gen" pool games available. Bankshot Billiards 2 on Xbox360 (downloadable), and World Snooker Championship for everything. WSC can be discounted for me for two reasons.. for one, it's a European exclusive, never released here in the states. Second, it doesn't really look much better than the first-gen PS2 pool game I have downstairs. Which takes us back to Bankshot Billiards. Which I don't like mainly because it's only a top-down pool game without the POV view that I've gotten used to playing with. This was probably done to cut costs, since the tables don't have to actually be 3D in a fixed-view game. I've played the demo, which sucked... only offers you two minutes of gameplay, which is barely enough to get used to the controls, much less get a feel for the game. And it's fairly expensive for a downloadable title, at 1200 points.

The only other thing coming up is the pool games within PS Home. But I'm kind of iffy about that simply because of the environment, and having to go online into a little "world" to play it rather than just starting it up from the XMB. And, going back to the graphics issue, the PS Home world isn't really top-of-the-line, so the pool table can't push the limits very hard because of everything else that it's doing.

So what we need is a nice standalone title, with photorealistic next-gen graphics and next-gen physics, where we can jump in and play our billiards game of choice. Which is where PS Home might lag a bit, since most standalone games offer multiple types of billiards and various puzzle or trick-shot game types. Throw it up on XBL or PSN for five or ten bucks and let us go to town.

So WHO'S WITH ME!?!? :)






*crickets chirping*
 
The problem with billiards games is that they haven't come very far since the early 1990s, and, indeed, they don't have much of an ability to be improved with current technology. Maybe (and even then it is iffy) with on-the-fly physics calculations rather than the system that is probably usually used, but graphically there is only so much you can do with billiards. Not helping is the fact that it is typically more satisfying to just go to a bar or pool hall and play there than it is to play on a console.
And maybe I'm cynical, but I've played many of the more recent billiards video games, and none of them (with the possible exception of Q Ball: Billiards Master) hold a candle to games that came out on 16 bit systems. Billiards simply isn't a popular thing in gaming, and most of the games released are mediocre budget releases.
 
I think we need it! Although i also think we will be getting it but as a mini-game in PS Home for PS3. Same goes for Bowling.
 
You seem to be gung-ho on the 360/PS3 idea, but if I were interested in billiards videogames, I'd rather use a WiiMote than a controller.

In fact, Wii Play includes a somewhat simplistic version of billiards, although a full-blown game could add the polish and greater depth that you're looking for.
 
Why don't you play real pool? Go down to the local pool hall with three of your friends and play for an hour. Hell, one of my friends even has a table at her house.
 
Why don't you play real pool? Go down to the local pool hall with three of your friends and play for an hour. Hell, one of my friends even has a table at her house.
I was gonna suggest the same thing.
With the advent of clubs like "Side Pockets" which are all over the place in Kansas City, finding a real game isn't all that hard.
Finding some competition might be...
 
I'm well aware of that, and I occasionally go out with friends to do just that. :)

I just like pulling out a pool game now and again in the comfort of my living room, and it's somewhat frustrating that I have only two options.. a top-down arcade billiards game, or a more realistic title with first-gen PS2 graphics. I'd just like to see 'em push the realism in something like that.
 
It would be cool.
But they would have to go a LONG way.
You'd have to be able to visualize your pocket from several angles. I don't know if we've gone far enough with graphics to be able to see "deep" enough into the screen for that.
You'd have to be able to get high enough off the stick to see the diamonds for aiming bank shots. And would you be able to see enough of the table for the "infamous" 3 rail bank shot?
Building in correct english, especially side english with combinations of 3 or more balls would be a nightmare.
Getting the physics right for "kiss" shots would also be a bit of a conundrum, but easier than some of the other problems.

ANd can you really get all the "attitude" that is necessary to play against others?:lol:
 
there is a pool game on the PS3(can't remember the name) and bankshot billiards 2 on 360, which is one of my most played games...
 
As mentioned above a pool game will be built into Home on the PS3, and Pool Party is coming out for the Wii. Wii Play had a small 9-ball game that works well with the Wii mote because you actually have to pull back and then shoot forward like a real pool cue.
 
Back