I still think news articles not spawning a forum thread but a comment section is a big mistake. BIG.
Yeah, I'm building a new system to integrate news articles with forum discussion threads again. It will be rolled out in a few weeks.
I wonder what´s the motivation behind that change?
Well, since you asked... there's a lot of things that go into a decision like that.
First, the old article/thread system was very fragile. It would break at the worst possible times and required constant maintenance. Because much of the code only ran when articles were published, troubleshooting and debugging was extremely difficult. The fully custom bridge required getting WordPress and XenForo — two software platforms that really don't want to talk with one another — to talk to one another. It also required additional work of the writers, when threads needed to be moved and merged. Snarky comments from users upset when their own thread wasn't associated with articles certainly didn't help.
Second, while browsing other sites I was frequently reminded of how nice it is to simply scroll down below the articles to start reading the comments. We had that arrangement for the first 8 years or so of GTPlanet's news blog and it worked really well (there are hundreds of thousands of comments on those older articles). I thought returning to that and lowering the barrier to entry into discussions around articles would be a good thing. You may be surprised to learn there is actually not a lot of overlap between our forum users and news article readers. Articles get tons of traffic from Google News and Search, but it's hard to get those users to stick around, much less leave a comment. I want to expose them to our community as much as possible and eliminating that extra click to get to the discussions was part of that.
Third, the unusual and unique article/thread combination resulted in some weird and unexpected consequences in Google Search. Google is obviously an important source of traffic for us, so mitigating issues in that area is a priority.
Fourth, the forum software update was so significant, the entire article/thread system would have to be
completely rebuilt from the ground up. Rebuilding it would have added at least another month to GTP16's development and added another layer of complexity to the already complex upgrade process for me.
In short, this was a good opportunity to experiment with the original comment system again. However, I really miss the associated comment threads, and the sudden drop in article comments suggests many of you feel the same way, too. (Having said that, this is the weirdest/slowest time for Gran Turismo and the sim-racing niche that I've seen in 20 years, so I'm not sure the drop in participation can be entirely blamed on the comment system. There's just not a lot to talk about right now.)
So, I'm rebuilding the article/thread system while attempting to address a lot of the problems we had in maintaining it, but it's going to take a while.