Bogie, here's a breakdown further proving my point about how you make claims, and/or then, try to play a "truce" card.
I have to agree, the physics in GT5 are indeed a step down.
A step down from what? Certianly not Forza 3.
HBR's gives out a large post countering you.
https://www.gtplanet.net/forum/showthread.php?t=132607&page=12#post4448971
Your reply to HBR's post?
We will just have to agree to disagree on our opinions and experiences.
Then I chimed in the same post HBR replied to & you finally gave out an argument. This exert is why your "opinion" is being challenged in the first place.
Bogie 19th
Odd, because in GT5 it's like the cars don't even want to break loose, let alone over or understeer. Everything seems too controllable in GT5. Braking late and dumping the gas early has very little affect on whether the car will make the turn properly. GT is almost acting like it's on auto turn at times. This is indeed something I have not experienced in FM3.
Zer0 & I reply to your post though. Zer0 is the one who gets credit for posting video facts.
https://www.gtplanet.net/forum/showthread.php?t=132607&page=13#post4464683
What is your reply?
I appreciate your opinion.
The controllable physics, damage, & such issues you comment on as "opinion" show it's based on you not playing deep enough into the game.
There are numerous ways for anyone to experience what Zer0 & I posted about. You claim you've done them, but must be playing a different copy b/c you haven't seen such things. Past debates however, say you're merely commenting such things b/c of your views towards Forza rather than an honest opinion formed from actual gameplay.
Again, we will have to agree to disagree. I say that because we obviously have different experiences and views of the same games. No point in beating a dead horse over opinions.
You reply the same thing again, completely ignoring Zer0 and his videos.
At this point, both Big & I come to the conclusion you're playing with driving assists.
All I can imagine is that this is in reference to race cars with high downforce and slicks or playing with all assists because pretty much all cars can be chucked about with lift off and trail braking and anything with more than a few hundred horse power will power oversteer up to 3rd gear.
I did the Schwarzwald League in a bone stock RUF BGT and the only times I wasn't holding a slide was in long 4th and 5th corners. Putting the power down in 2nd and 3rd would always have the rear trying to overtake the front.
Your experience though, (obviously & by own choice) stems from you not playing with all aids off. That or you're lying b/c the examples I've given will pin point exactly what I'm talking about & where Forza gets its infamous debate regarding it never actually turning off aids.
If this wasn't the case, you wouldn't be so quick to play the, "Agree to disagree" card once your posts are challenged enough.
Granted I wasn't as nice with my words, it was 1 or the other. But, I apparently struck a nerve. It's also the point where you've now fully stated that you play with no driving aids.
I race with aids off.
I guess I didn't realize you were going to be childish. Disregard any conversation we had. I don't have time for antics like that.
Hypocrisy much? You speak as if your remarkably similar accusations that I was lying about having played FM3 didn't happen.
Get over yourself with the self-righteous act. Mclaren gave video evidence disproving your claims yet you continue to pretend it's a subjective experience.
And yes you are lying. At a bare minimal you're lying to yourself if nothing else.
Zer0 technically posted it, but it was in reply to the same claims you continue to make. But it humored me to see IM reach the same conclusion.
So, let's recap. You said GT5 cars act like they don't want to break lose. Zer0, HBR, & I challenged this claim. You either countered or said, "agree to disagree" & acted like it was all opinion ignoring video proof. 2 of us finally came to assumption that you must be playing with assists; that's the only way the cars will not break lose.
As quoted above, you have now "admitted", that you do not play with driving aids. Everything else is just a pissing contest after these posts esp. with these claims that no one is experiencing what I'm talking about. Read everything before this part before you lie again; I just quoted them for everyone's convenience.
So now begs the question that if you are not playing with driving aids, how is it that HBR, Zer0, myself, & BigYoSpeck have experienced GT5 cars breaking lose with ease, but you haven't? I know you said we must have different copies, but that's absurd & you know it.
Are you going to claim it's all opinion again? Are you going to say I'm the only person who has experienced such things again? Or will you say that we should agree to disagree because your copy is magically different from everyone else's?
I'm honestly wondering how you can't experience the cars breaking lose with no assists. I'd like an honest answer, but we all know better by this point.