- 29,273
- Glasgow
- GTP_Mars
It's a difficult question, but I don't agree that it is the fault of the people who are tasked with controlling the US border. There are plenty of perfectly legitimate reasons why there should be a hard border and for controlling who is allowed to cross it and who isn't.What amazes me the most is the border patrols compliance. Why would anyone enforce such a policy? If trump wants to play hardball play hardball back, as long as this policy is in place you coincidently stop finding any illegal border crossings... it's that simple as I can't find it in my heart to call these things that enforce this policy people.
Isn't there this qoute that says something about if a law is unjust it not only right to disobey it's you obligation.
Or an easy one all it takes for evil to prevail is for good man to do nothing.
Also I agree there are some.issues with illegal immigration but like you I disagree with Trumps continious blackmail. It's it only negotiationtactic and might work once or twice on a guy but the world gets it now so it's not really that strong of a tactic no more.
The main thing wrong with Trump's current policy is the fact that a direct result of it is that children are being forcibly separated from their parents - but even if that policy were reversed tomorrow, there would still be the issue of unaccompanied children for whom the US authorities assume responsibility and at least provide them with shelter and their basic needs - in that respect, the border forces do a very good job. Part of the problem is that so many refugees and immigrants have no documentation or proof that the children with them are actually theirs, and thus even without the policy of jailing parents separately, there is still the problem of what to do with the children who are left behind. But the current policy doesn't make enough allowance for the fact that children are being separated from their parents for the "Crime" of seeking asylum in the US via the incorrect method, and that the consequences of detaining children and parents separately could be severe - it is not even certain when or even how parents and children will be reunited after the parents are jailed or deported.
Sadly, however, the border forces have to deal with everyone - legitimate or not - and they can only do what they are legally allowed to do.
Last edited: