In the wake of former Republican Sen. Frank Artiles’ arrest on allegations he paid a sham candidate nearly $50,000 to influence a key Miami race, Florida Republicans are reluctant to chime in on what amounts to a credible allegation of voter fraud — something they have long said they are focused on rooting out.
Prominent Florida Republicans are not vocally calling out that alleged voter fraud in the same way they lamented so-far unfounded allegations of fraud in other areas of the state voting system after Miami-Dade State Attorney Katherine Fernandez Rundle on Thursday unveiled the results of her four-month public corruption investigation into Artiles’ role in recruiting his friend, Alex Rodriguez, to run as a no-party affiliated candidate to siphon votes from incumbent Democrat José Javier Rodríguez.
“This is a matter for local law enforcement and the courts,” Meredith Beatrice, a spokesperson for Gov. Ron DeSantis, said on Friday.
Many prominent Florida Republicans, including DeSantis, joined President Donald Trump in falsely claiming the 2020 presidential election was stolen. The GOP-led Florida House and Senate are teeing up election bills during the 2021 legislative session that would make changes to the state’s election system they say crack down on potential fraud. Opponents, however, say the bills are aimed at making it harder to vote.
A leadership-backed Senate proposal sponsored by state Sen. Dennis Baxley (R-Ocala) aims to, among other things, get rid of voter drop boxes, which were used by 1.7 million people to cast ballots in 2020 during the pandemic without significant issue, but Republicans say could potentially be vehicles for fraud.
DeSantis has not hesitated to get into local election fights in the past. One of his first acts as governor was to issue an executive order suspending Palm Beach County Supervisor of Elections Susan Bucher, a former Democratic lawmaker, over what he saw as failures during a contentious 2018 election cycle.
“Today, we turn our attention to the need to restore faith in our election processes here in Florida,” DeSantis said in a statement at the time.
On Friday, his office did not respond to POLITICO questions about whether he would call a special election, which Democrats requested because they believe José Javier Rodríguez, who lost by just 32 votes, would have beaten Republican Sen. Ileana Garcia without Artiles-planted candidate Alex Rodriguez, who got more than 6,000 votes despite not actively campaigning.
His office also did not respond to questions about whether the governor was concerned about the Artiles investigations after he has spent months railing against potential voter fraud, including encouraging people to give money to Trump’s legal defense fund as the former president was raising money off baseless claims that the presidential election results were illegitimate.
DeSantis has supported the Senate election bill that also would require everyone to submit new vote-by-mail requests for 2022, and limit the duration of future vote-by-mail requests.
“By strengthening these election integrity protections, we will ensure that our elections remain secure and transparent, and that Florida’s electoral process remains a blueprint for other states to follow,” DeSantis said in February when the bill was unveiled.
Baxley, the bill’s sponsor, told POLITICO in a text message Friday said he "will look into it” when asked if the Artiles allegations will impact election reform talks in the Florida Legislature this session.
“It is a concerning circumstance," he said.
The House election bill does not do away with voting drop boxes, but adds monitoring requirements, and also prohibits local elections officials from sending vote-by-mail ballots without someone making a specific request, and requires that vote-by-mail requests be renewed every election cycle.
“By all accounts, Florida’s elections last year ran smoothly, and we’re looking to improve on our successes,” House Speaker Chris Sprowls said in a Thursday statement announcing the bill. “Florida has come a long way since the 2000 election cycle. Our progress is a result of consistent work to ensure that our elections processes are the best in the nation – we cannot stop now.”
His office did not respond to a Friday request for comment about the Artiles allegations.
On Thursday, hours after the Artiles allegations were unveiled, Republican Senate President Wilton Simpson of Trilby said he is reserving judgement.
“I think you have to allow law enforcement to do what they do,” Simpson said. “I think we don’t have all the facts.”
He noted that there is no evidence tying Garcia, a candidate his leadership committee supported, to the alleged Artiles scheme, and was noncommittal when asked if he would support language being placed in the Senate election bill cracking down on the use of third-party sham candidates, which is legal in Florida.
“Two weeks ago, you all were asking ‘Shouldn’t we be doing other things in Covid liability [legislation],’ and so now this happens to be the topic of the day,” Simpson said. “And so now this happens to be the topic of the day. It will get accelerated based on the will of the Senate.”
Senate Democrats on Friday morning said it should be “no brainer” that a special election be held, and that the Senate to take up election language that would crack down on the use of sham candidates.
“This exposes some irony and inconsistencies on the party of the Republican Party,” Senate Minority Leader Gary Farmer (D-Lighthouse Point) said during a Friday press conference. “Two months ago we heard repeated charges over and over and over against from then-President Trump and Republican leaders across the country ... that was completely nonexistent.”
“Now, we have evidence of actual fraud,” said Farmer, who in 2020 ran Senate Democratic campaigns. “Real fraud. Fraud proven in evidence and facts contained in the arrest warrant.”
He noted that there are election reform bills filed in both chambers that could be amended with language cracking down on some of the allegations outlined in Artiles’ arrest warrant.
“We can fix this now,” Farmer said.