Dale Earnhardt Injured During ALMS Practice Lap

OK, first off.....the fuel cell didn't split. The car was full of fuel and had some in the fuel filler neck, had that same hit been one lap later, no fire. It was a big hit, he was doing 80-90ish and probably impacted around 60. On bare concrete with a side slap hit, thats big.

Second off, about the marshalls.... I can tell you have never marshalled a race before. The general accepted order of priority on the race course is 1) Ourselves 2) Our fellow marshalls 3) Cars still circulating and 4) Car(s) involved in incident. Fuel was spilled all over the station in the grass and you had fire spreading through the station, at this point its scramble...first to bail out as you see the car coming then to see where the fire is and attack accordingly. At the same time you have the yellow flagger who is warning oncoming traffic while the communicater informs control of the situation. Now if you watch the tape you will see the car ended up center track with driver side FACING traffic. Remember at this time track is still green. In order for the marshall to have intervened he would have had put his back to traffic through fire to assist. That violates rule #1. We cannot do a damned thing if we are hurt ourselves, nor can we get out of the way of an out of control car we can't see. But wait, there is still more. That driver is in a car with a rollcage, HANS, helmet and fire retardant suit. We have leather gloves, cotton clothes and boots. Now who is a more protected position? They did a damned good job with an oh **** situation. Please go out and marshall races for a year to get an idea of what we gotta do, you'll find there is a method to our madness.

Oh, just in case you ask I have been marshalling for 4 1/2 years with my home track being Road Atlanta. I have also worked Kershaw, Barber and Savannah... and in a couple of weeks will be working VIR. I average 25 days at the track/year with last year on corners for 40 days.
 
From a passionate post to an angry post... Okay, I mentioned that I applaud Dale Earnhardt Jr. for going outside of his oval racing element, but I never expected to hear sports journalists say that pulling off something like this is idiotic and suicidal. Well answer me this. I became a racing fan in 1999. Name me all the people who died in any leauge of NASCAR between February 1999 and June 2004. I thought so. Racing is a deathsport regardless, but don't go on b*tching about how unsafe sportscar racing is. I mean, he's done Rolex Sport Car at Grand-Am, and they are as much of sportscars as in my favorite, the American Le Mans Series. I've heard of Dale Earnhardt Sr., Adam Petty, and such dying in accidents in NASCAR. And I've heard of a death in at least one of the top three NASCAR series, Nextel, Busch, and Craftsman Trucks.

I may talk a lot about sports, but I can't stand SPORTS REPORTERS who downplay racing like some people did just today. I mean, Dale Earnhardt goes from an overrated racing series and going to a real racing series and just gets into a little accident. Heck, Colin McRae had a great debut at Le Mans this year. Danica Patrick cut the mustard pretty well last year in the ALMS. Dale Earnhardt put on a hell of a show in the 2001 Rolex 24. So I don't want to hear ANY complaining about Dale Earnhardt Jr. "going from a dangerous sport to something much worse." Stock cars are safe, but don't go attacking sportscar racing. You hear me, g** damn it? Dale Earnhardt had the guts to race in a real event during and off-weekend. You can either respect him for taking a challenge, or stay the hell away from racing. It's your choice. Your call. Do what you want. Dale Earnhardt is only boosting his racing resume. I'd applaud him, not get on him for what someone consdiers a mistake. It wasn't a mistake when Brian Urlacher of the Chicago Bears did some wrestling, so why Dale Earnhardt Jr.? Why a NASCAR driver doing a road racing stint? Earnhardt Jr. is out there giving sportscars a whirl, and I would love to have seen him race. I think it's better watching a NASCAR racer out of his/her than hearing about baseball all the time. I'd rather even hear about football season, just don't attack my favorite SPORT. Auto... freaking... RACING!!! Damn shame for America if you ask me.
 
Fair point, Firestarter - I was going off a news item I saw. There did seem to be a lot of marshall activity though, and no-one had an extinguisher, which struck me as odd. A big national meet like that here would see a fire marshall at each marshalling post.

I'd assumed the fuel cell had split.
 
There were fire bottles but we do not have enough ammo for that kind of fire at the corner. NO ONE does. We generally have 2-3 fire bottles at our disposal at the station, question is did any of them get doused in fuel making their use in a fire dangerous? The rest of the bottles will be spread through the coverage area in key strategic locations.
 
Jr's crash was a freak, that will be stopped in future races with a slight redesign.

NASCARS on the other hand are based on 1950's technology. Need I say more!

Unfortuantely for the US, NASCAR is completly dominant despite being stuck in a time warp tech wise. The series is probalby a little pissed that Jr described the C5-R as probably the greatest car he has ever driven.

The 'sport' is becoming more like professional wrestling by the day. The fans are actually brainwashed into beliving NASCARS are the greatest machines on the planet, in all regards. Little do they know that a small 2 litre ETCC European Touring car with 270BHP could thrash a 750BHP NASCAR dinosaur on a road course.

IMO NASCAR is sports 'entertainment'.
 
There's some talk now that the car's suspension pierced the fuel cell, and that the fuel itself may have contributed to weakening the call.

In terms of extinguishers (and this isn't intended as a criticism of the marshalling), I thought the idea was not so much to extinguish the fire, but to supress the fire near the driver enough to allow him to escape. Your theory may be correct, though - it may be that there was a big splash of fuel over the marshalling post, which would certainly explain the marshalls being unwilling to get too close to the car!
 
JAGUAR brings up some great points. But in my view, this accident could have happened to ANYONE. I'm just angered about people saying that a sportscar isn't even half as safe as a "stock car." So, I've noted that it was a shame for Earnhardt Jr. to not be able to compete. And didn't Jr. race the Rolex 24h with his late father in 2001? What was the car? THE CORVETTE C5R. So don't tell me that this C5 was unsafe, or any other sportscar for that matter. And to all the people who say that NASCAR racers shouldn't shift series need to be silenced. Hell, you can't tell Tony Stewart (or some call him "Smoke") to not race sprint cars and 1/4 midgets or whatever dirt program he has, so why tell other NASCAR racers that they can't shift series? Sebasiten Bourdais went from Champ Car to Le Mans this year only to get a disappointing DNF. Juan Pablo Montoya in 2000 was ailing in then, CART, but he wins the Indy 500 later that year, going from CART to the IRL to win a race. It's a buch of crap. And what about the ALMS racers that do road racing duties for NASCAR Nextel Cup?

To me, there's a double standard with this. It's okay if a ALMS racer can race in a NASCAR event to fill in for some driver and some team. But if a NASCAR racer jumps into ALMS and has some sad moments, people think it's not right? What the hell is wrong with traditional American racing, if not racing in general? Jr. does a stint in another series, gets into a unfortunate accident during practice, and people like to ask "why did he/she jump to (the) ___ series?" I mean, get off of Dale Jr. talking like that. What? Do you expect him to apologize for jumping series? You want a court trial against him for doing such a thing? If not, leave Jr. alone. Leave the ALMS alone. And grow up. Crybabies against Dale or sportscar racing need to wear a pacifier and go play in their baby cribs.
 
Firestarter75
Nascrap fans have never been known for their brains.
Listen, asshole. Don't go thinking every Nascar fan is an idiot because of some idiots. I would like to see you drive a 700 Hp stockcar 500 miles, non-stop, being 140 degrees in the cockpit. 👎
 
Firestarter75
Actually one of the guys involved posted over on the scca.com board that just to get a path to the car they had to knock down fire.

That certainly supports the theory there was a big splash of fuel. That wasn't clear from the footage shown.

Whilst not a big fan of seeing cars going up in flames (I can remembering shuddering when Berger's Ferrari went up at Imola in '89) given modern fireproofing it wasn't as big a deal as everyone made out - the big concern was that Earnhardt was knocked out or somehow incapacitated inside the car. Then, there would have been a big problem.
 
Nick_Johnston28
Listen, asshole. Don't go thinking every Nascar fan is an idiot because of some idiots. I would like to see you drive a 700 Hp stockcar 500 miles, non-stop, being 140 degrees in the cockpit. 👎

Fans..... drivers...... fans....... drivers......fans....drivers. Hmmmm, nope, don't see how they are alike. Actually rather different. Thanks for proving my point.
 
Back