The Duel Challenge
Unofficial Review by DaBomm4
Tested with ABS 1, no other aids, DS3
Since I cannot test for scoring purposes in this challenge I decided to have a little fun with the rules, I tested all of the cars on Comfort Soft and Sports Hard tires.
Tuner # 1 RX-8
Best Lap CS: 1:16.386
Best Lap SH: 1:12.882
DC Score:8
Comments:
On CS tires, this car was fun, the right throttle and steering control and the car is spot on, a little too much throttle or steering angle out of a corner, roasting the tires.
On SH tires, the same stands true, but I could throw the car into the corner a little more.
Tuner # 2 S2000
Best Lap CS: 1:16.876
Best Lap SH: 1:13.935
DC Score: 7
Comments:
On CS tires, front end understeer and acceleration made this tune hard to go fast.
On SH tires, slow acceleration, the car wants to drift high speed corners.
Tuner # 3 RX-8
Best Lap CS: 1:15.224
Best Lap SH: 1:12.356
DC Score: 10
Comments:
On CS tires, the car is stable, easy to drive, only starts spinning if you try to.
On SH tires, feels like I'm glued to the fast track, can go flat out everywhere with no caution.
Tuner # 4 RX-8
Best Lap CS: 1:16.012
Best Lap SH: 1:13.214
DC Score: 9
Comments:
On CS tires, the car feels very similar to tuner # 3's tune except it does not seem to have as much acceleration.
On SH tires, very good corner attack speed and handling, but the acceleration cannot compete coming into the straights.
Tuner # 5 S2000
Best Lap CS: 1:16.224
Best Lap SH: 1:13.219
DC Score: 9
Comments:
On CS tires, mild throttle control needed, slides nicely but not always at the right times.
On SH tires, felt very solid around the track, good slip/grip range, able to go flat out on most of the course.
Tuner # 6 RX-8
Best Lap CS: 1:15.430
Best Lap SH: 1:13.013
DC Score: 9.5
Comments:
On CS tires, feels very smooth, easy to attack corners with little fear of wheelspin.
On SH tires, very tight around the track.
Tuner # 7 RX-8
Best Lap CS: 1:15.473
Best Lap SH: 1:12.908
DC Score: 9
Comments:
On CS tires, feels more loose and more prone to wheelspin.
On SH tires, feels like there is a little front end understeer on acceleration, otherwise the car felt tight on the track.
Tuner # 8 S2000
Best Lap CS: 1:15.866
Best Lap SH: 1:13.840
DC Score: 8.5
Comments:
On CS tires, the rear has a tendency to oversteer on the whole track but is very controllable if you work with it.
On SH tires, a real struggle to get a fast lap compared to on CS tires,
@biffa3 must be onto something with the low power on this tune. The oversteer has faded, but in turn has brought some front understeer.
Tuner # 9 RX-8
Best Lap CS: 1:16.010
Best Lap SH: 1:13.218
DC Score: 9
Comments:
On CS tires, steering and throttle are touchy, once I got use to that, this tune was fun to slip and drift around.
On SH tires, the car would rather be sliding sideways instead of speeding through the corners, still fun just not as fast.
Tuner # 10 RX-8
Best Lap CS: 1:15.787
Best Lap SH: 1:12.486
DC Score: 8.5
Comments:
On CS tires, all this tune wants to do is go sideways, either by front end understeer or power oversteer. My best lap was when I quit trying to drive fast and tried to drive safe instead.
On SH tires, the understeer has disappeared and the oversteer is reduced but still present on apex to exit in some corners.
Tuner # 11 S2000
Best Lap CS: 1:16.685
Best Lap SH: 1:13.927
DC Score:8.5
Comments:
On CS tires, it has a drift/grip feel to it but there is a hint of understeer. Fun around the track.
On SH tires, understeer did not go away, fun and stable around the track.
Edit: BONUS
Just for those curious, tunes and positions by tire for my testing only.
Tuner CS SH
Tune 1 9 3
Tune 2 11 11
Tune 3 1 1
Tune 4 7 6
Tune 5 8 8
Tune 6 2 5
Tune 7 3 4
Tune 8 5 9
Tune 9 6 7
Tune 10 4 2
Tune 11 10 10