Forza Motorsport 7: Demo Discussion

  • Thread starter PJTierney
  • 426 comments
  • 36,973 views
I've spent at least an hour trying to get the demo to run right. I can put it on medium settings and get ~20fps in benchmark. I think the handling problems I'm having with the cars are related to the fact that the game simply isn't running properly, and that the Porsche is just the most affected.

This isn't an isolated problem. There are a number of reports, both on the FM forums and elsewhere, of people with i5s/i7s and 1070s/1080s having stuttering, frame rate and performance problems.

This may be related to the fact that the game maxes Core 0. FH3 used to do this, and it caused a lot of problems for people (especially with higher end hardware) because there's only so much a single core can do. Eventually they patched it, but until then the best fix was to manually disallow affinity for Core 0. Unfortunately, that doesn't seem to work here.



And more unfortunately, it's by design and T10 recommends setting the game to VSync 30 (which doesn't really help either, actually). So there's not even really much hope that they'll apply the FH3 fix to this in the near future.



Props to all of you for who it's running great and are having fun, but I can't justify spending money on a game that won't work. Especially one that seems to be not working for the same problems that they ran into with FH3. I worked through them with that game, and I'm glad that I did, but I'm not eager to go through that again.

At this rate, I may end up buying none of the big three racers releasing this year.
 
sebmugi
good demo there is good and less good .. you have to make choices on one ;)
the competing cars have nevertheless taken a drastic level 3D model :/

1505980454-7a60a493-1eb2-4437-81d3-7216a07f8945.png


1505980452-afd4786a-b9bd-4d28-8308-5cb9de8562da.png


1505980334-c314c882-6714-4afe-ad9e-fc7f18b0ecb0.png


1505980331-60588aab-44f2-45b5-95b5-914cb29aa1d1.png


1505980951-bd909cf1-7870-409a-bd69-994cb3f49b58.png


1505980873-3993ac8e-0b57-4eb7-9888-8ddfdd6a73cd.png


1505980536-ca908ec8-14fb-48fb-abdc-c75bad386334.png



1505980565-07b6e713-fc9f-44d9-9048-13ba6439a3ec.png
Click to expand...
sebmugi is GT fan boy and cherry picking man
This screen shot is Very low settings
OfTsb0J.png
 
Hage dayo
sebmugi is GT fan boy and cherry picking man
This screen shot is Very low settings
Click to expand...

Ignoring the GT fanboy part, they definitely seem cherry picked. Even the player's car is low LOD on the last shot you quoted. I don't see the point of criticising model quality when you have it turned down, so here are some full detail shots at similar angles.

This is how the player's 911 GT2 looks:
8skyXCV.jpg


And here's how the AI's GT3 RS really looks:
tDRHFoQ.jpg

KO1bqDE.jpg


On PC max settings, the nearby AI cars are the equivalent of how the player's car looks on Xbox One.
 
It looks great, and I was afraid they would create solids like in the Rocket League
I buy RL Items and I love RL crates, I've seen some for sell
As for the Rocket League it is a good idea to buy Bodies and Nitro over the internet, I buy RL items and they are very cheap https://odealo.com/games/rocket-league
 
Last edited:
I liked the demo, to be honest! A little surprised at how well the truck handled.

Although, to be absolutely frank, I think they could tone down the camera tilt. I got really disoriented when I started the GT2 race.
 


Another youtuber that shares the concerns many of us(most of us) have when it comes to Forza series/Forza 7(demo) and steering wheels.
Bah, what is wrong with turn10, just make the wheel work as a steering wheel, not a pad with longer "throw"...
 
Symtex
That's fanboyism for you. Now can you stop being faster than me ? In the last FM, I had to hot laps for days to pass you on the leaderboard. Hopefully you got slower over the years :-)
Click to expand...
lol, I think my competitive days are behind me, gone are the days of being top 10 overall in C class, my favourite class! I'm getting old and not sure I have the same amount of time I used to dedicate to my racing games. Although with the big three releasing close together my competitive juices are beginning to flow. Hopefully see you on the track 👍
 
PzR Slim
Can you explain what you mean by feel with a controller? I've seem many people use that phrase and I'm yet to work out how you can have any feel with a controller.
Click to expand...

For me at least the feel with a controller comes down to 2 main areas.

First, how the game interprets my inputs, most racing games usually have settings that allow you to change this with options like steering sensitivity and linearity. I started playing PCARS 2 last night and the default controller options didn't work for me, when I made an input I wasn't really sure what the car would do which made driving at any reasonable speed almost impossible, I changed the settings based on their descriptions and immediately I could place the car much more confidently. Different people will have different preferences much like they can have different styles of input, some people like to tap the stick, I prefer to make small precise movements, and this may also change depending on what kind of cars they prefer driving. I've yet to find a game this generation where I can't make the car on screen respond to my controller inputs as I expect, if the game isn't already great out of the box then so far I've had no problems finding comfortable settings myself.

The second part is IMO where some games are a lot better than others and that is the feedback through the controller, much like you can get FFB from a wheel which may help you find the limit of grip, we get vibrations through the controller, I'll just add here that the XB1 controller is great for this with the rumble triggers. When I have played games with a wheel I can usually tell when the car is oversteering/understeering based on the FFB and change my input accordingly, on a controller I get vibrations which help me decide how to adapt my inputs. With the XB1 controller and the rumble triggers I can also get vibrations which tell me I'm on the limit of grip when accelerating/braking, this can help people who use no TCS or ABS a huge amount.

I haven't played the Forza 7 demo yet, but from the games I've played Forza 5/6 > PCARS 1/2, Dirt Rally, > WRC 5/6, Assetto Corsa when it comes to vibration feedback. I've tried playing FM6 with no vibration and my race pace drops by 2+ seconds because I have no confidence accelerating or braking and get caught by surprise sometimes when the car oversteers as I'm used to having that kind of feel through the controller, however I can play with no sound without it massively affecting my race pace. With Assetto Corsa there isn't as much feedback through the controller so I find myself relying on sound and visual feedback a lot more than other games, which I at least find more difficult to react quickly to and therefore have a slightly harder time keeping the car facing the right way.

I'm curious now if anyone uses no vibration when playing racing games, and if so how their performance is affected by having no sound?

TL;DR - 1) How the game interprets inputs and applies them to the car. 2) The vibration you feel in the controller can be very helpful.
 
Im_Lukas
For me at least the feel with a controller comes down to 2 main areas.

First, how the game interprets my inputs, most racing games usually have settings that allow you to change this with options like steering sensitivity and linearity. I started playing PCARS 2 last night and the default controller options didn't work for me, when I made an input I wasn't really sure what the car would do which made driving at any reasonable speed almost impossible, I changed the settings based on their descriptions and immediately I could place the car much more confidently. Different people will have different preferences much like they can have different styles of input, some people like to tap the stick, I prefer to make small precise movements, and this may also change depending on what kind of cars they prefer driving. I've yet to find a game this generation where I can't make the car on screen respond to my controller inputs as I expect, if the game isn't already great out of the box then so far I've had no problems finding comfortable settings myself.

The second part is IMO where some games are a lot better than others and that is the feedback through the controller, much like you can get FFB from a wheel which may help you find the limit of grip, we get vibrations through the controller, I'll just add here that the XB1 controller is great for this with the rumble triggers. When I have played games with a wheel I can usually tell when the car is oversteering/understeering based on the FFB and change my input accordingly, on a controller I get vibrations which help me decide how to adapt my inputs. With the XB1 controller and the rumble triggers I can also get vibrations which tell me I'm on the limit of grip when accelerating/braking, this can help people who use no TCS or ABS a huge amount.

I haven't played the Forza 7 demo yet, but from the games I've played Forza 5/6 > PCARS 1/2, Dirt Rally, > WRC 5/6, Assetto Corsa when it comes to vibration feedback. I've tried playing FM6 with no vibration and my race pace drops by 2+ seconds because I have no confidence accelerating or braking and get caught by surprise sometimes when the car oversteers as I'm used to having that kind of feel through the controller, however I can play with no sound without it massively affecting my race pace. With Assetto Corsa there isn't as much feedback through the controller so I find myself relying on sound and visual feedback a lot more than other games, which I at least find more difficult to react quickly to and therefore have a slightly harder time keeping the car facing the right way.

I'm curious now if anyone uses no vibration when playing racing games, and if so how their performance is affected by having no sound?

TL;DR - 1) How the game interprets inputs and applies them to the car. 2) The vibration you feel in the controller can be very helpful.
Click to expand...
I can play pretty well without vibrations, it might even help me.
Sound, on the other hand, is a must have for me. If I really focus I can do "alright" but for the most part, I completely suck without sound.
 
ClydeYellow
Data is not merely "raw stats", tho - and a good physics engine will be able to provide a satisfying simulation with a sufficiently accurate dataset without any amount of "fiddling" needed.
Click to expand...

A lot of data is raw stats, curb weight, horsepower/torque to the wheels, balance, and on and on.

Fiddling is always involved, physics engine not properly working with 30s GP? You have to implement frame manipulation that affects the driving dynamics quite a bit in those old race cars.

There is no such thing as a perfect physics engine and anyone claiming such a thing is laughable.
 
FordGTGuy
A lot of data is raw stats, curb weight, horsepower/torque to the wheels, balance, and on and on.

Fiddling is always involved, physics engine not properly working with 30s GP? You have to implement frame manipulation that affects the driving dynamics quite a bit in those old race cars.

There is no such thing as a perfect physics engine and anyone claiming such a thing is laughable.
Click to expand...
The physics "engine" shouldn't be changed (and isn't) from car to car. That would simply take far too much data and space for current hardware.
The parameters for each car are what may or may not need adjusted.

Much like real life, physics don't change from car to car, the car and it's physical dimensions change.
 
CSLACR
The physics "engine" shouldn't be changed (and isn't) from car to car. That would simply take far too much data and space for current hardware.
The parameters for each car are what may or may not need adjusted.

Much like real life, physics don't change from car to car, the car and it's physical dimensions change.
Click to expand...

Exactly who said that it changes car from car?

I said that if they add a new type of car it could require expansion and advancement of the engine to replicate how it works in real life better.

Frame flex is extremely important to how a 30s GP car handles on a track but not so much for a more modern vehicle.

I never once stated that the cars are treated differently by the physics engine.

Turn 10 themselves have publicly stated that they do not program 0-60 times or any other performance metric into Forza, they input all the raw data on the specifications of the vehicle into the engine and the cars are usually spot on with their real life counterparts performance.

In certain instances this isn't true due to limitations of the engine(frame flex) that are added for all vehicles but only effect cars that are effected in a noticeable way in real life.

Physics engines are constantly evolving.
 
FordGTGuy
Exactly who said that it changes car from car?

I said that if they add a new type of car it could require expansion and advancement of the engine to replicate how it works in real life better.

Frame flex is extremely important to how a 30s GP car handles on a track but not so much for a more modern vehicle.

I never once stated that the cars are treated differently by the physics engine.

Turn 10 themselves have publicly stated that they do not program 0-60 times or any other performance metric into Forza, they input all the raw data on the specifications of the vehicle into the engine and the cars are usually spot on with their real life counterparts performance.

In certain instances this isn't true due to limitations of the engine(frame flex) that are added for all vehicles but only effect cars that are effected in a noticeable way in real life.

Physics engines are constantly evolving.
Click to expand...
I didn't say that you did, I wasn't quite sure which you were saying.
So I said what they do, that's all.
 
FordGTGuy
A lot of data is raw stats, curb weight, horsepower/torque to the wheels, balance, and on and on.
Click to expand...

A lot of data is data. "Stats" is a term improperly used for the Top Trumps figures of a car (horsepower, torque, curb weight, top speed & acceleration, etc.). And if you look at it that way, everything about a car can be expressed in "stats", from the configuration of the suspension to the weight balancement to the stiffness of the chassis.

physics engine not properly working with 30s GP?
Click to expand...

...then you fix your physics engine.

There is no such thing as a perfect physics engine and anyone claiming such a thing is laughable.
Click to expand...

There is definitely such a thing as reasonably accurate physics engines. They're used everyday for countless purposes (from scientifics pursuits, to design & engineering, to digital forensics, to actually making cars work). And there is such a thing as physics engines that can reasonably represent in real time the behavior of the kind of vehicles presented in Forza Motorsport without the developers having to give the game different engines for different cars.

But at this point I feel like we may be saying something very similar, and... Arguing semantics more than anything else.
 
I had no issues with the demo, i7 4790k and with only one of my gtx970 cards spooling gpu usage, both spool memory. I will admit I couldn't run everything on high, I bumped it down to medium, which still looks great. The benchmark I could run high but in a race I couldn't.
 
Ak1504
I drive without assists and when the batteries are low and the vibration is gone then i can´t drive a single corner ^^
Click to expand...
I also play without assists (except for abs on all the road cars that have it)
I turned vibration off last night to check it out, I don't think I will be turning it back on. (Extra battery life)
The brakes in Forza games aren't progressive enough for me to drive without ABS well, regardless of vibration.
Forza might be the only game I need abs to drive really well in, too.

Edit: I forgot, at least in FM 5 and 6 with the wheel and pedals braking without abs was fantastic, it was another game that didn't give good brake feel, I'm not sure which, maybe FH3. I haven't had the wheel out much lately, just FH3 with the controller.
 
Last edited:
Imari
And more unfortunately, it's by design and T10 recommends setting the game to VSync 30 (which doesn't really help either, actually). So there's not even really much hope that they'll apply the FH3 fix to this in the near future.
Click to expand...
The wccftech article you quoted has been updated.

Turn 10 Studio Architect Chris Tector
Forza Motorsport 7 is not limited to running on one core. There seems to have been a miscommunication along the way. “Forza Motorsport 7” uses as many cores as are available on whatever system it runs on, whether that is a 4- to 16-core PC or the 7 cores available on Xbox One.
Click to expand...

So it sounds to me like it's not intentional and there is a chance of the game being fixed via a patch like Horizon.
 
Hello,
Check my first race in Forza Motorsport 7 Demo on 4K Gaming PC (i7 6700k + GTX1070 + Thrustmaster wheel).

The demo is too short but the fisrt impressions are : Beautiful grafics (cars, circuit and weather).
Next week will be so long !
:)
 
UKMikey
The wccftech article you quoted has been updated.



So it sounds to me like it's not intentional and there is a chance of the game being fixed via a patch like Horizon.
Click to expand...

Interesting.

However, Chris Tector is fighting a strawman there. No one claimed it was limited to running on only one core. Both FH3 and the FM7 clearly use multiple cores and always have. The problem with FH3 (and what seems to be happening with FM7 demo) was that what seemed to be happening was that some calculationally hefty physics and graphics systems were all being forced onto Core 0. To the point that even with low settings and relatively untaxing game states the core would be pegged at 100%, making the OS try and shuffle priorities and generally causing stutter and lag.

In FH3, you could disable Core 0 and the game would intelligently redistribute the tasks that it had designated for Core 0 among the remaining cores, resulting in a much more stable experience. FM7 demo doesn't seem to do this.

It's sort of assumed that this design is a hold over of creating a game that has to run on the Xbox 1. After all, the X1 doesn't have anything like the GPU power of most gaming computers, so it makes sense to offload as much of the graphical workload to the CPU as possible. But presumably on X1 they're very careful what they assign to each core so that they make sure they're getting the most bang for their buck. They know they have essentially 7 cores to work with and they know what those cores are capable of. They can make sure that the most taxing or sensitive tasks get their own core and have plenty of spare overhead.

That's not the case on PC, people can have anywhere from 2 to a buttload of cores with a fairly wide range of speeds and instruction sets. Not to mention the general difference in CPU to GPU power on PCs. So the game has to be able to divvy itself up sensibly to make use of the hardware that it's running on, and in some cases (like mine) it appears unable to do so.

I hope they fix it, but I'm not holding my breath. It took a long, long time for them to even acknowledge it as an issue in FH3.
 

Similar threads

Famine
Forza Motorsport Update 7 Out Now: Brands Hatch, Retro Racers, & More
2 3
Replies
73
Views
12K
RogsR34UK
R
AudiMan2011
Forza Motorsport Update 11: Road Atlanta, Multi-Class Racing, and More
Replies
15
Views
4K
Morbid65
Morbid65
GTPNewsWire
Forza Motorsport 7 Coming to Xbox Game Pass, Arrives October 8
Replies
8
Views
3K
-Fred-
-Fred-
AudiMan2011
Forza Motorsport Update 10: Proximity Radar, Forza GT Splits, Nemesis Tour, and More
Replies
9
Views
4K
Draugnimir
D
AudiMan2011
Forza Motorsport Road Map: Bathurst, Permanent Builders Cup Changes, New Features, and More
Replies
19
Views
5K
symo63
symo63

Latest Posts

Back