I don't really know if this should be put here, General Discussion is a rather vague topic, but here goes.
I have just read the GT4 Review in PSW and am feeling a mixture of great excitement and deep disappointment. I will buy the game and I am sure I will play it for years. I still play GT3 after buying on launch day.
For me the enjoyment is all about the handling and the tuning. It is the constant quest for improvement. Sometimes I will hammer the Time Attacks, sometimes the Licences and other times just free run, but I hardly ever do races.
In GT3 I find racing utterly pointless, other than for winning prize cars. I can get no enjoyment from it. If you drive a car to match the field, you either win comfortably, because the computer cars can't go around corners at sensible speeds, or you lose because the AI barge you off the track without deviating from their groove in the track. If you go in with an underpowered car and win, then so what! I know it is more down to the AI incompetence that allows me to win, not that I have developed Senna like skills.
From what I have read and what people are saying here, this has not changed in GT4. All the great things about GT3 are even better in GT4, so of course I will love it. But why can't we have decent races. I remember watching Senna win at Monaco after Mansell had caught him in what was a much quicker car at the end of the race. Senna just kept it smooth and on the racing line. There was nothing that Mansell could do. In GT, Mansell would have just punted him into a barrier somewhere and stormed to victory.
I can't help wondering if the reason damage isn't implemented is more to do with the fact that it would be more like a stock car race, as it is just about impossible to drive a clean race unless you overpower the opposition and keep well out of the way.
Oh well, rant over. Thanks for reading, if you got this far.
By the way, PSW scored 9/10 for GT4, though the reviewer spent most of the article talking about what was wrong with it.