Voted Sub-Zero but it was close:
For:
-It's a Lotus
-It's a Lotus that handles exceptionally well
-By all accounts, it has great steering compared to the competition (Cayman and the like... yes... compared to the Cayman)
-It's a car that doesn't rely on headline figures to justify itself.
Against:
-It's not a particularly pretty Lotus... especially compared to classic looks of the Elan, the techno-geekiness of the Elan M1 and Esprit or the mad hornet looks of the current Elise.
-Camry. V6. A more agricultural V6 there isn't. At least the ZZ engine in the Elise is suitably zingy... but big Toyota engines? No. Hell, if marketing needs didn't force them to keep a 6000+ rpm redline, they'd probably limit them to 5500. It may actually rev to 7000 rpm in the Evora, but it's character is basically still the same... torquey, not keen on high revs.
-
Personally, I felt the negatives weren't enough to justify downrating to cool, but I can see a lot of votes going that way.