- 1,086
- St-Hyacinthe, QC
- GTP_pilmat
- pilmat
Ah, alas, I wasn't going to discus it, but now that you brought it up...What kind of spring sits in a master cylinder normally? Also progressive?
The TSS solution is NOT a true hydraulic brake, and I don't feel that they are marketing it as such. What it does is give a hydraulic feel (and by all accounts a very good one). Basically it is a mechanical spring system that has a hydraulic parallel component, note that the CSP II has a similar arrangement with the buggy shock mounted in parallel to the load cell. What they do for a signal IS hydraulic, in that the fluid is exercising a pressure sensor. But the fluid is NOT exercising the spring, as in a traditional hydraulic brake. These are all subtleties, but you'll see the tie in to your question.
In brake application, the differences between the systems are quite moot, as long as the pedal builds pressure in the hydraulic system, all is good for feel. The big difference happens in brake release. In a traditional system, the main spring (in most sim cases the spring is the elastomer stack) acts on the fluid in release, keeping a head of pressure on the sensor and releasing proportionally. In the TSS system, there is a problem that the reversing of the hydraulic fluid pressure (i.e. pulling the piston back) could cause a sudden dip in pressure at the sensor and have a "quick release". They use air pressure in the reservoir (which the sensor is mounted in) to overcome this.
The spring you asked about in a hydraulic master cylinder is not actually there to provide feel, it is a part of the valve in the master to ensure fluid does not get sucked back up by the plunger. The spring keeps a head of pressure on the valve so that when you release, it pops the valve open and allows the plunger to return without pulling fluid back from the slave cylinder. So the spring you mention is there to avoid the problem that TSS uses the air pressure for.
Does it matter? If the driver gets the feel that they want, the answer is no. We have discussed the short comings of simulator brakes before (i.e. using a static solution to a dynamic problem) and therefore as long as the driver is happy, it's all good!
Cheers! And the same to youNice to see you back in the saddle! Have a Happy Holidays!