- 1
- Romania
Can anyone send me a link for a motor? I can’t manage to find one.
You all are so smart getting the voltage higher to get stronger FFB - did nobody consider getting stronger motors that would run at less voltage ? For instance 24v motor exchanged to 18V or even 12V would give you double the strength - pull more Amps on same supply !Hello everyone. I found this thread after seeing someone mention upgrading their G29 on Reddit & to be honest, even though the stock FFB strength seems enough for my twig arms, I would like to carry out an upgrade. I've found quite specific motors that should fit, but I'm having some issues, mainly:
- They push 0.04Nm torque each where as the stock G29 ones are ~0.02 each;
- I'm worrying that just passive heatsinks won't do a good job at cooling the components (motors & mosfets) which could make the wheel overheat & potentially fry something on the board at worst;
- I'm not sure if I will be able to use them with the standard power supply, considering the motors are 24V & 1.2A each (but also 7000RPM);
The other thing is that those motors come from a Canon printer (no idea which, though) so trying to find another ones of those is pretty much impossible unless you track-down the printer they came from. I've searched far & wide for them on the interwebz but found nothing similiar; the motors in question are RS-555SH-TD058419
Any kind of help would be appreciated as I don't want to destroy my wheel completely just yet
I did consider that in my further testing as it was making sense, but all the motors with lower voltages I could find had the same or less peak torque which would be just a money waste if you were to swap them, hence why I ended up searching for something more powerful, like a RF-545 motordid nobody consider getting stronger motors that would run at less voltage ?
Search for 540, 550 or 555 class motors on places like eBay or Aliexpress. Just be sure to not get any motors that are too strong for the circuitry of the G27 as the mainboard might let out some magic smoke after a while; torque increase of 0.02Nm might be able to work wellSo, anyone can find those motors?
Thanks! I assumme it should be 24v right? 550 are very commonSearch for 540, 550 or 555 class motors on places like eBay or Aliexpress. Just be sure to not get any motors that are too strong for the circuitry of the G27 as the mainboard might let out some magic smoke after a while; torque increase of 0.02Nm might be able to work well
Either 18 or 24V will work fineI assumme it should be 24v right?
I forgot to mention that you should look for ones that have the shaft of equal length on both ends as you need to mount the encoder wheel onto the back of it. Search for something like "dual shaft 550 motor" on there & you should find plentyThanks! Will this one fits/works?
https://a.aliexpress.com/_mPJKhl3
Honestly, I'm not entirely sure if a PSU upgrade will be necessary. The control board might get somewhat hotter than it does with the stock motors, but I don't think it will have issues with power delivery. Altough, after looking at the listing you linked, it seems that those motors provide pretty much the same torque rating as the stock ones, so I don't think you will feel any more force than you do now. You will need to look for motors that have more than 150g.cm while also not being too power hungryThink I'm ready with two of these? Also, i need an upgraded PSU right?
That is more than enough as the stock motors are like 4000RPM if I remember correctly, your wheel will definitely fly from lock to lock now. Altough calculating its torque, it seems like it's only 0.003Nm which seems really extremely low, so you will need to search some more.10900rpm is enough?
If that calculator is right, at this moment with 24v, 1.75a and 4000 or so RPM, the torque would be 0.1nm. if that's true, 0.3 sounds amazing to me. Like how many RPM I'm looking for? Until it breaks i meanThat is more than enough as the stock motors are like 4000RPM if I remember correctly, your wheel will definitely fly from lock to lock now. Altough calculating its torque, it seems like it's only 0.003Nm which seems really extremely low, so you will need to search some more.
Use this to calculate their torque:
https://www.electrical4u.net/calcul...calculation-formula-torque-calculator-online/
I don't really know how many RPMs can it take, so I would possibly try to stay below 10kLike how many RPM I'm looking for? Until it breaks i mean