- 13,865
- Adelaide
- Neomone
It doesn't if you played it when you first came out, but it absolutely can to a new player. Expectations change over time. The Model T Ford was one of the best cars available for it's time, but if you try and give it to someone to drive now they will find it incredibly frustrating. The car didn't change, but the bar for what constitutes a "good" car did.Ratio
Time doesn't automatically make a game bad unless you're Jim Ryan.
This happens with games too. We can recognise that games were good for their time and were influential on the genre or industry as a whole, while still admitting that compared to an average modern game of the same type they don't really hold up as an experience.
This isn't a fault, no product stays the absolute best in it's category forever. Or if they do then it means that no one is doing anything to try and advance things, and that's not exactly great. We want new games to be better than old games, and that means also recognising that actually the old games aren't as good as the new games.
Gran Turismo's problem has been that the new games haven't been head and shoulders above the old games. So you end up with old games that are outdated and new games that are worse than the outdated games. Ugh. Butter me up and call me a **** sandwich.
It's outdated because it's a 2004 take on those ideas. Compare GT4 to something like FM7. Let's ignore the graphical stuff, because that was always going to get better just with more computing power and because while graphics are nice they're not generally what makes a game fun.Ironic, considering that GT4 represents, pretty clearly if we go by modern GT history, the absolute zenith of the series and one that the developers either took from blatantly in order to fortify the next game in the series, or actively model their game after in order to win back fans. So how is it outdated considering those factors?
FM7 is largely GT4, but improved in almost every way.
Physics are better.
AI is better and more adjustable.
Weather exists in a limited way.
Tuning and upgrades are more extensive.
Customisation of cars and drivers is much more extensive.
Career progression is more structured and with a wider variety of events.
Several types of online modes are added.
GT4 has a few things that are unique to it but they're largely ones that didn't really take off, like dirt/snow racing and B-Spec. Both fine ideas, but I'm not writing home about GT4s implementation of either of them.
Overall, if a new player wants a broad driving sim of this type to play then I'm going to recommend FM7 to them because I think they'll have a better time. If they enjoy it and want to see some of the history and lineage behind the genre I'd absolutely recommend them to play GT4, but afterwards.
I would describe the measure as something along the lines of a combination of "consumer expectations" and "established norms". Think about what your expectations of a good internet browser are these days. Whatever you're using now is probably fine, but any "good" browser from 2004 would probably not be that fun to use in 2021.By exactly what measure? Only case I can see that being 100% true is in terms of technology, but that by itself doesn't make a game better. There's plenty of cases of a newer game being not as well received, or objectively worse than its predecessors, and the Gran Turismo series 100% falls into that.
GT4 can both be the pinnacle of Gran Turismo and be a bad game by modern standards. Actually, bad is probably overstating it. Let's say it's "meh". It's fine, it's not offensively bad or anything and it's totally playable, but if someone released Bland Torsiono 4 (a carbon copy of GT4) in 2021 I reckon it gets at best middling ratings.
Gameplay kinda stale, AI is garbage, no online, lots to do but not much to engage with, multiple other games that do the same stuff better, pretty good if you're trapped in lockdown and just want a project. 7.5/10.
I think that's fair by 2021 standards. Whereas by 2004 standards the discussion was "is this masterpiece 9/10 or 10/10?", because those are the only options.
Lol. You forget that this is Polyphony, the developer not known for their use of logic in design.Geez. Calm down lol.
Just wait and see for example GTS, just before the servers are taken down, they should release a final patch to be able to play and save the game offline. Pure logic.
Last edited: