- 28,470
- Windsor, Ontario, Canada
- Johnnypenso
Official GT Blog: "Pit Stop" by Polyphony Digital
- Thread starter Dionisiy
- 2,207 comments
- 210,841 views
- Status
NixxxoN
(Banned)
- 2,712
- Barcelona
If i have to be 100% honest, I dont really like it, because its not very accurate... Its like the opposite of GT sounds. GT has too weak sounds, and those in Driveclub (aswell as other games) are too strong, so they are all innacurate.
This sounds quite different compared to the Driveclub video... This actually sounds like just 1 car revving up (and it obviously is only 1 car)... that was my point. Driveclub one sounds like several ferraris simultaneously revving up.
Last edited:
- 1,492
- Germany
- KiroKai
- KiroKai
But that raspyness is mostly caused by distortion. I just think it's a bad example of 'how a car sounds like'.
(I agree with your criticism though, if it was directed at NixxoN. I'm not sure if you meant 'guys' as in both of us.)
- 10,956
- Canada
- 17,185
- United Kingdom
The F12 in Drive Club sounds nice, but it doesn't sound much like an F12.
NixxxoN
(Banned)
- 2,712
- Barcelona
Apparently you and Johnnyperso are probably friends and members of the same anti-GT gang, because you are both canadian and reply exactly the same one after another, am I right?... "everything in GT is bad, everything in other games is good" ... please grow up
I was talking about the accuracy of the sounds and that DC example is definitely not very accurate.
- 858
- United Kingdom
- 28,470
- Windsor, Ontario, Canada
- Johnnypenso
- 1,029
- Ohio
- jimmyfoxhound
I was just wondering about people saying "louder does not equal better". In a sense, isn't louder more accurate? In reality, standing next to a powerful supercar that is revving it's engine you might be inclined to cover your ears because of the noise. I see people wearing ear protection at car races. Loud is exactly what powerful, highly tuned cars tend to be. I wouldn't ask GT to blow out my speakers every time I play it but if I'm driving a supercar it should sound like it wants to kill something at high revs (like the Zonda in this vid).
My friend had a rebuilt Ford Mach 1 and he gave me a ride and not only was the speed impressive, the sound was mind blowing! I'd hope one day PD could capture that experience in a videogame format.
My friend had a rebuilt Ford Mach 1 and he gave me a ride and not only was the speed impressive, the sound was mind blowing! I'd hope one day PD could capture that experience in a videogame format.
- 858
- United Kingdom
Oh crap.
- 11,660
- GTP_Orido
We need 10,000 watt sound system to experience the real thundering noise of a super car 
, it will literally shakes the house just like if you have the real car revving in your living room
, it will literally shakes the house just like if you have the real car revving in your living room 
- 5,897
- Canada
- 28,470
- Windsor, Ontario, Canada
- Johnnypenso
I don't have 10k watts, but I do have a 12" self-powered sub and it has no trouble rattling the windows and a couple of cabinetsWe need 10,000 watt sound system to experience the real thundering noise of a super car
. When no one is around I crank it up, when someone is around I use the headphones.
- 1,033
I honestly don't think that Driveclub video sounds good...The sound is a mess. I certainly want louder more agressive sounds from the future of GT but not like that.
NixxxoN
(Banned)
- 2,712
- Barcelona
Come on dont take it so seriously
I was just trying to be funny but I guess I failed.Just pointed out, I confuse johnnypenso and TokoTurismo because both are canadian and both seem to disagree with me whenever I try to defend GT.
This all depends of the volume of your TV. The car should sound exactly as in a video of a real car. And it should obviously sound more or less loud depending of the volume you apply...
Last edited:
mister dog
(Banned)
- 8,396
- Spain
- misterdog
- misterdog7
- 10,956
- Canada
What excatly does my nationality have to do with me being negative? What, you're getting so frustrated by the complaints and even constructive criticism, all of a sudden you target a person's country in which it makes you believe that is why their a anti-GT fan? Yeah no. YOU'RE the one who needs to grow up.
That is NOT funny whatsoever, you went too far with that...Come on dont take it so seriously
Last edited:
- 8,722
I'm not particularly impressed by DriveClub's audio, either. They make all these claims about recording with so many microphones, and all they end up with are two fixed sets of samples: interior and exterior. So no matter how the car presents itself externally, it sounds the same; the contrast between the exhaust and intake sounds on this car is half the fun, mixing them together in a fixed way is missing the point.
At least the interior will sound OK; they're surround-sound samples, right?
That's actually something I neglected to think about regarding PD's recording challenge: how do you get fully spatially expressive sounds, inside and out, using the bare minimum of in-game sources? I don't know, but I know how I'd approach finding out.
Oh, and regarding "volume" / "loudness", I think spatial reproduction plays a bigger role. That sense of envelopment is ultra-important.
At least the interior will sound OK; they're surround-sound samples, right?
That's actually something I neglected to think about regarding PD's recording challenge: how do you get fully spatially expressive sounds, inside and out, using the bare minimum of in-game sources? I don't know, but I know how I'd approach finding out.
Oh, and regarding "volume" / "loudness", I think spatial reproduction plays a bigger role. That sense of envelopment is ultra-important.
- 28,470
- Windsor, Ontario, Canada
- Johnnypenso
All I want to know is, when do you leave for Japan?I'm not particularly impressed by DriveClub's audio, either. They make all these claims about recording with so many microphones, and all they end up with are two fixed sets of samples: interior and exterior. So no matter how the car presents itself externally, it sounds the same; the contrast between the exhaust and intake sounds on this car is half the fun, mixing them together in a fixed way is missing the point.
At least the interior will sound OK; they're surround-sound samples, right?
That's actually something I neglected to think about regarding PD's recording challenge: how do you get fully spatially expressive sounds, inside and out, using the bare minimum of in-game sources? I don't know, but I know how I'd approach finding out.
Oh, and regarding "volume" / "loudness", I think spatial reproduction plays a bigger role. That sense of envelopment is ultra-important.
NixxxoN
(Banned)
- 2,712
- Barcelona
Get a sense of humor, or a chill pill
and no im not getting frustrated I tell you, I dont take internet forums so seriously (as others perhaps)To me it is quite easy although I may be wrong....
It is as simple as always recording (placing the microphone) in the exact place of the in game camera, on a real car. If its the cockpit camera, place the mic in the viewing spot. If its outside camera, place the mic below the back of the car, in the exact camera spot, and so on... Shouldn't that be it?
- 8,722
I'm not sure I could handle the criticism!
You can get away with that for the interior, but there is so much subtle variation outside (replays, several in-race views) that you need to develop a system which can reproduce it all on the fly (which PD have made good inroads on). Then maybe you can extend that system to the interior...Get a sense of humor, or a chill pill
To me it is quite easy although I may be wrong....
It is as simple as always recording (placing the microphone) in the exact place of the in game camera, on a real car. If its the cockpit camera, place the mic in the viewing spot. If its outside camera, place the mic below the back of the car, in the exact camera spot, and so on... Shouldn't that be it?
stash
(Banned)
- 117
- United States
i dont defend it but you really need to lighten up and learn how to have fun
- 549
- Where i'm at
- xmalcolmpowderx
If i did not reply, then how are YOU supposed to know that I dont care?
- 858
- United Kingdom
If you're not having fun with playing GT6, at least you can throw the disc like a ninja star or frisbee at people that piss you off.
- 549
- Where i'm at
- xmalcolmpowderx
I cant do that. I am already using it for a mug coaster.
- 10,956
- Canada
- Status
