Today I finally got the chance to sight in my 10.5 inch barrel AR. I was surprised how many things I read about short barreled AR's weren't true in reality. First of all, with 3 different brands of ammunition + my own reloads there was no visible fireball, nothing at all, with a standard flash hider.
The concussion blast wasn't as insane like many people claim, it was a bit louder than my 20'' AR but nothing to worry about. Any long barreled rifle with a muzzle brake is
considerably worse.
Side to side compared with my 20'' barrel AR the recoil was hardly any different, I could shoot it as fast and stay in the target as well as with my long AR. The recoil might be a tiny bit faster but it makes no difference to me.
The velocity loss wasn't so big, I had a chronograph with me and I measured 2640 fps with standard 55 grain FMJ.
My own reloads bumped that up to 2705 fp/s without overpressure. Reliability with all brands was 100%. (60 shots or so) Brass ejection wasn't crazy, it ejected like my long barrel AR.
Accuracy was also good, that's what I shot with a red dot with no magnification at 100 meters. And I shot it fast.
And this with the backup iron sights, also at 100 meters. I was a little high but got it dialed in now.
Despite the short sight radius with the 10.5 inch barrel and me not trying very hard, with good iron sights its accurate and fun to shoot.
So all in all I'd say a 10.5 inch barrel AR is more than just a fun range toy or a fad, in fact I'm so happy with mine I'll make it my go-to rifle from now on.
If you have ever considered getting a short AR - all I can say is - get one!
Oh and buy the way, I shot this with my scoped 20'' AR, with FMJ ball, 100 meters (110yds). The red circle is 2'' in diameter. That's not too bad for plain ole ball ammo.