Thanks again for all the comments.
We are considering a Fox body Mustang since they are everywhere around here for almost peanuts. The aftermarket support for them is excellent and you can buy used parts for them at any of the flea markets we have around here.
EF or EG Civic.
Civic HX 14" wheels with 185/60/14 Falken Azenis
Hawk HP+ Pads for the front
Cheap coilovers, and turn up the stiffness in the rear.
Spend the extra money on a cheap bucket seat and a steering wheel. Most people don't realize how much of a different it makes (until they try) to not need to use the steering wheel and dead pedal for support, therefore being able to be really light on the steering and pedal work.
An EF Civic has been moved to the top of our list as of right now since we are finding them in our price range. They are pretty badly rusted but a little welding and bondo will make it good enough. An EG would be good to, although all I'm coming up with is automatic sedans.
Does it really matter hatchback or sedan? I'm sure both have different characteristics.
Get a Focus
I wouldn't mind one of those but Focus are quite expensive in the Detroit area, it's hard to find even a high mileage one under $4,000 unless it has a blown motor or something else major wrong with it.
Again. Miata. Why don't you want one? All it needs for autox is gas.
Seriously, the only reason any person wouldn't want to buy a Miata is simply because they've never driven one.
None of us like Miata's at all, I'm probably the biggest hater of them but the others aren't far behind. I wouldn't mind having one if the others were all about it, but they aren't.
Our biggest roadblock is that there is not a huge supply of them in Michigan which makes the ones that are here pricey. This also poses a problem for parts since we just can't pop down to the junk yard and get what we need. None of us really know anything about them either, which means more mistakes and more costs. If we get something we know a little bit about it would be easier.
Also none of us can stand the Miata community around here, they are either old guys that use it as their summer car and know nothing about them or they are d-bags. Since we have limited knowledge it would be nice to have a community that we can at least turn to for advice that wouldn't be major Richards.
The only Miata I've ever been in is a guy from my old car club who had a 300hp turbo Miata that was scary to be in.
Unless you don't fit in one...
Considering one of the guys on the team is like 6'3" and about 240lbs., I really doubt he'd fit. Although he could probably pick the car up if we needed too
.