I must be one of the few who really enjoyed the cafe. Yeah it could’ve been longer, but I didn’t mind it. It almost felt like a mini story mode IMO.
About the text. I think this might seem strange since most of us are probably from the West, but let’s remember PD are a Japanese developer and this feels…. well very “Japanese”. It’s not a bad thing of course. I have a lot of JRPGs so it’s not much of a shock to me to see dialogue being conveyed like this.
It probably also saved hiring voice actors just for a few lines and to make it easier from an accessibility standpoint to flip the text into a different language.
All in all I think the cafe had an innocent charm I find adorable and an interesting take on the typical “career”.
I'm in that minority as well.
I like the idea, but it could have been implemented much better. The talking heads were a bit cringe, but charming and quirky at the same time. They tried a different approach to the usual, so kudos to PD for that, it's just a shame the execution was lacking.
How I would have liked it done
The start was fine, book 1 buying your first povo car is pretty much a franchise staple, so no need to mess with it.
After that I would have liked to see the next menu book unlock a championship screen. Then you go there and complete the Sunday Cup. 1 prize car for the championship would be sufficient and you earn it by finishing top 3. (I do like that they implemented that part as opposed to winning is everything) Also there should be other championships now available, similar to the first set of championships in Sport. You can either race as many of these as you want, or go back to the cafe.
Next menu is tuning. You have the first menu available to choose from to tune your car up to a specific pp range.
Next book directs you back to the championships to compete in one of the other options in the open tier. You chose which one. Come top 3 and back to the cafe. All the championships award a prize car. Prize cars are sellable at 25% of retail and you can keep winning them.
Next menu opens up the new car dealership and a higher tier championship, race in one of those, back to the cafe.
Next level of tuning
and so on as you work your way up to Gr1 or whatever they deem the pinnacle to be.
The other bits and pieces from the cafe such as showing you scapes, liveries etc could be slotted in wherever.
Doing it like this those that want progression still have the option to take their time, and those that want to get into their preferred class of racing can get there fairly quickly.
Tracks would unlock with the introduction of each championship level. With all tracks unlocked by the time you hit Gr3. After that the championship menu books just unlock events for higher tier cars.
Obviously the above would need a few tweaks, but if I had 5 years I reckon it would be pretty spot on.
edit. I would also add some kind of meeting place setup in the cafe. Like a chat room where you can hang about and find friends to go and play in lobbies with.