- 2,810
- Tasmania, AU
- stigsdaddy
Maybe they'll listen if you are Mark Skaife
More likely they'd claim the sound is accurate and it's only youtube videos that sound different lol.
The Great Project Cars Whinging and Crying Thread
- Thread starter Johnnypenso
- 815 comments
- 73,284 views
More likely they'd claim the sound is accurate and it's only youtube videos that sound different lol.
mister dog
(Banned)
- 8,396
- Spain
- misterdog
- misterdog7
I guess Stephen is getting a bit pissed at the moment 
:
http://forum.projectcarsgame.com/showthread.php?30208-v8-supercars&p=1223106&viewfull=1#post1223106
:http://forum.projectcarsgame.com/showthread.php?30208-v8-supercars&p=1223106&viewfull=1#post1223106
- 2,810
- Tasmania, AU
- stigsdaddy
I guess Stephen is getting a bit pissed at the moment
http://forum.projectcarsgame.com/showthread.php?30208-v8-supercars&p=1223106&viewfull=1#post1223106
Haha that thread is just as pathetic as the other one. How a bunch of people can claim that sound is anywhere near the real thing is beyond me. Even the sound guy gets butthurt and has a carry on at people giving feedback. If this is how they react to people pointing out inaccuracies in the game, it's no bloody wonder it has so many issues lol.
People who have never even seen one of these cars in person arguing with not one, but two people who have not only seen them quite a lot in person, but actually been inside them. This is getting beyond a joke now. Obviously we're going to be stuck with the weedy sound we've got.
The fact they're claiming the sound is fine (SMS that is) is them suggesting the sounds in other sims are inaccurate. Anyone with ears can tell the iRacing sounds are great.
This is just the same old rubbish as Ian was spewing when I reported track inaccuracies, and he tried to claim their version of Monza was more accurate than the laser scanned version in AC. Do they even read what they're writing? It's hilarious how much they bury their head in the sand. "What? No we haven't done anything wrong, everything in Pcars is perfect. I don't care if other games have actually recorded the real sounds, or have laser scanned their tracks, ours are better, lalalalalalala" *fingers in ears*
Last edited:
- 1,391
- vermont
- diesel4x497
I guess Stephen is getting a bit pissed at the moment
http://forum.projectcarsgame.com/showthread.php?30208-v8-supercars&p=1223106&viewfull=1#post1223106
Did you notice that not one WMD,mod,or dev came to his rescue with the "Like Button" that doesn't happen very often
- 2,810
- Tasmania, AU
- stigsdaddy
Give them time man lol. They love doing that. Anyone who defends the game or blindly praises it gets a ton of likes from all the other robots involved in the SMS circle jerk.
Edit: I should add, before anyone misunderstands, I love driving that Falcon. It drives very nicely, and feels how you'd expect it to. They've done a good job on it on that front. It's just painful to hear what sounds more like a V6 with a fart cannon than the brutal V8 sound the real car has.
- 2,744
- England
- RacerPaul65
I guess Stephen is getting a bit pissed at the moment
http://forum.projectcarsgame.com/showthread.php?30208-v8-supercars&p=1223106&viewfull=1#post1223106
Formula1269
(Banned)
- 426
Yea, sound of the V8 is not as impressive as the real thing, for sure. Shame.
mister dog
(Banned)
- 8,396
- Spain
- misterdog
- misterdog7
Yeah that made me laugh too
.Feel a bit sorry for the guy as he's getting a lot of criticism, but it's a bit short sighted to think that you'd get away with a sound sample like that and not have people moaning about it. Like stated by a lot of folk already the sounds are hit an miss in PCARS, as half of the car roster sounds original, but then the other half sounds very generic. Also practically every gearbox sounds exactly the same too which is not helping neither.
- 2,810
- Tasmania, AU
- stigsdaddy
Yeah that made me laugh too
Feel a bit sorry for the guy as he's getting a lot of criticism, but it's a bit short sighted to think that you'd get away with a sound sample like that and not have people moaning about it. Like stated by a lot of folk already the sounds are hit an miss in PCARS, as half of the car roster sounds original, but then the other half sounds very generic. Also practically every gearbox sounds exactly the same too which is not helping neither.
Imagine the backlash if they released the Fusion Nascar and it sounded like a V6 camry with a ricer exhaust. Some cars they can get away with this, but a car like a V8 Supercar, which has very distinct sounds that are a big part of the sport's spectacle, must have decently accurate sounds if people are to be happy with it. As it is, it's missing quite a vital part of what makes it a V8 Supercar.
Even Codies Race Driver series had more accurate V8 Supercar sounds, and the first of those came out 14 years ago lol.
- 2,810
- Tasmania, AU
- stigsdaddy
Ian Bell
Head of Studio
Join Date
Jul 2011
Location
London
Posts
3,552
Originally Posted by MISTER WU
Well said mate, its not wrong its just way off.
We'll look at the sound guys.
Mods, please pass to Bruno.
looks like they might be listening
Wow, that's not the reaction I would have expected from him. He must have gotten out of the right side of the bed for once lol.
- 3,268
- London
- Mauler_77
Might just be a case of if they're trying to get licences for cars but can't even get the sounds right it might not look too good for prospective future deals from other manufacturers. Like 'you put this car in the game but didn't get the sound right so you can't have another one' or something. It looks bad to players, what do manufacturers make of it? They must have teams that check the authenticity of their products.
Or else just a good decision by them regardless.
Or else just a good decision by them regardless.
dopedog
(Banned)
- 880
- United Kingdom
Ian Bell
Head of Studio
Join Date
Jul 2011
Location
London
Posts
3,552
Originally Posted by MISTER WU
Well said mate, its not wrong its just way off.
We'll look at the sound guys.
Mods, please pass to Bruno.
looks like they might be listening
I remember when he said similar about custom championships and then said it would be here when its solid... take it with a pinch of salt. The ammount of interst its generated i'd not be at all surprised to hear in a few days "THE FALCON WILL BE BACK IN PROJECT CARS 2 WITH FULL PROPER V8 SOUND GUYS!!!!!!"
With loads of likes from all the cling ons and try hards....
Decided I wanted to try some fun with a good career mode, started with Clio Cup... Lag, frameskipping, audio freaking out and the Clio seemingly randomly and repeatedly losing itself at speeds below 70kmph without any home of recovery. Absolutely ridiculous.
Back to GRID Autosport I suppose...
Back to GRID Autosport I suppose...
dopedog
(Banned)
- 880
- United Kingdom
Only just found out that not only did they raise the minimum payment to enter PCars 2 WMD..."To keep the idiots out", but they won't be paying the WMD guys a penny in return on investment...lol...looks like in fact they kept the idiots IN....
Ian Bell must just be uncontrollably laughing every night.
He and SMS also now know that they can pretty much get away with anything now. But then I think they learnt they could do that with Shift 1 and 2..
Ian Bell must just be uncontrollably laughing every night.
He and SMS also now know that they can pretty much get away with anything now. But then I think they learnt they could do that with Shift 1 and 2..
- 1,007
- Québec
While we won't receive money, we still receive different things depending on what we paid, plus we get acces to the game way before the release, plus we get to see the development of the game. That's worth it, imo.
Thats said, since you pretty much called us idiots and since you can't stop talking about Ian in every single post you make, I welcome you to be the first member in my ignore list.
dopedog
(Banned)
- 880
- United Kingdom
Wow, you get to SEE the development of the game....not alter it or help it...very telling response... they knew enough people would join up again for some odd bragging rights whilst they run off into the sunset with the cash... bravo to them I say.
Oh and the 'idiots in' well everyone according to SMS and WMD not in are 'idiots', stop being so precious. Jeez.
dopedog
(Banned)
- 880
- United Kingdom
FFS so i can't even say anything in this thread now?
Please explain how i have gone too far when SMS have got people to pay into this the same as PCars 1 yet unlike that they get nothing back?
I felt sorry for you when Ian booted you from the forum, you didn't deserve it.
I don't hate anything, PCars 1 is my most played game....
- 91
- UK
- cornishbrooksy
- cornishbrooksy
Then its a good job you didn't join...if you don't want to then you don't have to.
For me, the entry fee money is worth it....the days inside WMD were really quite enjoyable, i consider to have met a lot of new people with like minded interests....and whatever you think we do have an impact on the game and choices inside it.
At the end of the day we get the game free, DLC free and lots of other small stuff....and while the monetary value may not be exactly equivalent (i actually havent worked it out).....to have dev builds, feedback and see what they are up to for the next 2/3 years means i will get more hours of gameplay out of it before it even releases than most games i buy in the shop.
Also if the opportunity to invest comes up again....i for sure as will. But if not....no issue to me.
dopedog
(Banned)
- 880
- United Kingdom
Good for you, well done. Not enough whining or crying though 3/10, try harder.
Oh and how do you know I didn't join?
I don't think anyone would say £50 is a vast amount of money, I know several people who joined for varying reasons.
I know that they call the new engine 'phoenix'.... witty..
Last edited:
- 91
- UK
- cornishbrooksy
- cornishbrooksy
Where is agent 47 ?!
I need him right now.
Bob must die.
Lmp2 endurance series @ 50% race distance.
After 71 laps I hand over to Bob. Total race is 86 laps. End of the race it starts to drizzle a little bit. On the last lap of the LMP1 leaders - BOB pits in. The pit box is just in front of the finish line
all he had to no was to drive 10 laps ! But UHH NO let's play the player for a fool!!!🤬🤬
I need him right now.
Bob must die.
Lmp2 endurance series @ 50% race distance.
After 71 laps I hand over to Bob. Total race is 86 laps. End of the race it starts to drizzle a little bit. On the last lap of the LMP1 leaders - BOB pits in. The pit box is just in front of the finish line
all he had to no was to drive 10 laps ! But UHH NO let's play the player for a fool!!!🤬🤬Similar threads
