Tyre sound from the E3 Trailer
- Thread starter petter mo
- 85 comments
- 5,182 views
- 9,058
- Murica
- BasedAckbar
This is off topic, but Conquerer, are you on Gamefaqs GT5 board also?
- 9,058
- Murica
- BasedAckbar
Any of the GTR games for the PC I guess...that's all I can think of.
- 482
- Aero-R
The tyre sounds on that R8 / La Sarthe video are the same ones that we've always had since 1998, it's a shame I know. But the worst part, is that if you close your eyes while watching the video, that R8 sounds like a scooter... and that's something serious when we're talking about a game like Gran Turismo. They must improve the sound part, it's really downgrading the whole image of the game.
- 9,058
- Murica
- BasedAckbar
^ Really? The stuck rear cam in gt4 didn't bother me at all...
- 9,058
- Murica
- BasedAckbar
Isn't sound one of the hardest things to record since it has to go through many elements, conversions, audio systems, etc? Maybe the recording is awesome, but when implemented some of the data isn't read properly.
- 237
- RANKO_GT_SERBIA
Don't hate me, but I really think that NFS series allways had a good engine sounds.
I played Most Wanted only because of the sounds, ignoring the stupid gameplay.
Ignore this video, just listen to the sound and imagine that you're driving Supra in GT, heaven
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vHLWod1ze8A
I played Most Wanted only because of the sounds, ignoring the stupid gameplay.
Ignore this video, just listen to the sound and imagine that you're driving Supra in GT, heaven
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vHLWod1ze8A
- 482
- Aero-R
You can't be serious. It's quite coloured. It's the perfect score for a spacial ship movie... take a listen to the sounds related to the turbo and some kind of N2O over-effect. That's much..Don't hate me, but I really think that NFS series allways had a good engine sounds.
I played Most Wanted only because of the sounds, ignoring the stupid gameplay.
Ignore this video, just listen to the sound and imagine that you're driving Supra in GT, heaven
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vHLWod1ze8A
Sound, for me, is something like this (the best soundtrack you can listen):
- 482
- Aero-R
Ferrari Challenge Trofeo Pirelli did a great job with some engine sounds. At the same time they have a easy task because they only have to do a few engine sounds for the few ferraris featured (not hundred of cars like in GT..) but well, that's an example of a game with a good sound in some aspects.I agree, but we are talking about games, not real life, right now I can post 15 videos with crazy engine sounds but it's not the point
- 967
- Delaware
- Watevaman78564
- Watevaman78564
- 283
- neopheX
the tire squeal from the nascar sounded good appose to the normal sounds,
If PD and KAZ said many times, its going to be something very much worth waiting for, i think things like sound would be fixed, they have to be, cause its only really going forward in 1 thing, and thats graphics and and physics nothing else.
I think they are looking to take a big leap forward, so hopefully all new sounds will be implemented!
If PD and KAZ said many times, its going to be something very much worth waiting for, i think things like sound would be fixed, they have to be, cause its only really going forward in 1 thing, and thats graphics and and physics nothing else.
I think they are looking to take a big leap forward, so hopefully all new sounds will be implemented!
- 1,443
- Conquerer13
I think people are reading way too far into the trailer sound effects. PD has always added extra sound to its trailers and videos to make the game sound better than it actually is. Someone showed an example of the GT5P trailer, but look even before that -- the intro to GT4. Skip to 1:40 and tell me cars sounded like that in the game.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xV8m37_2Y6w
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xV8m37_2Y6w
- 518
- Draith
I always thought it was interesting that the sounds in GT were different from inside to outside the car, and facing forward to facing back... I mostly drive the S1 Elise and I thought they had attempted to make the in car sound similar to what you would expect to hear with a helmet on... similar to how you would hear the car if you were at a track day... that's why I thought they emphasized all the highs and have bass that only works well if you have a sub woofer. I thought they had deliberately made the mid range sound like it was muffled by the helmet?
Actually, it is. If they can get the graphics right, they can get the sound right too. It's as simple as that.I agree, but we are talking about games, not real life, right now I can post 15 videos with crazy engine sounds but it's not the point
I don't want to be driving a beautiful shiny hairdryer Corvette anymore.
It's so bad that I really can't think of a game that has worse sound than the GT series.
- 1,096
- Wattsterplus
- XML Binging Language?
maybe its just my setup, but GT5P sounds a hell a lot better than any other racing sim i've played when set to large theatre. Now i have to admit, i've got quite a high end sound setup, but thats what you need to get the best of the games sound.
Its kinda like people complaining about ps3 graphics on thier 42" tv. Its not until you dig deeper do you find the TV they're using is pants.
I think when making judgements on sound quality maybe you should quote what kinda speakers your listening to. And no, 5.1 speakers you picked up for under £100 at pcworld, bestbuy etc dont count as high end.
Its kinda like people complaining about ps3 graphics on thier 42" tv. Its not until you dig deeper do you find the TV they're using is pants.
I think when making judgements on sound quality maybe you should quote what kinda speakers your listening to. And no, 5.1 speakers you picked up for under £100 at pcworld, bestbuy etc dont count as high end.
- 713
- UK
It seems 'sounds' are a very personal thing..
I haven't got any real complaints with GT5p's sounds, sure some aren't comparable to vids I can find on the net, but I'm lucky that I have a reasonable surround system setup in the same room as my consoles which does go quite loud with good bass, so I adjust the overall ambience a bit.
I can't wait to get better tyre noises, it's the one area that for me sticks out more then anything with GT5p.. I'm sure if the trailer (even if engineered) has different/better noises, it'll be in the final thing!
I haven't got any real complaints with GT5p's sounds, sure some aren't comparable to vids I can find on the net, but I'm lucky that I have a reasonable surround system setup in the same room as my consoles which does go quite loud with good bass, so I adjust the overall ambience a bit.
I can't wait to get better tyre noises, it's the one area that for me sticks out more then anything with GT5p.. I'm sure if the trailer (even if engineered) has different/better noises, it'll be in the final thing!
No doubt Polyphony Digital record the real engine/exhaust car sounds , you can see it on every "making of" GT.
But I think after recording, they edit all these sounds before including on the games, because, in my opinion, you listen all of them soften, smoother. For example, if you hear a muscle car on real life, the sound is brute, louder. Not to mention competition cars, F1... you can go deaf!
In conclusion, perhaps they uniform the sounds so you can hear all the cars on the race (if for example there are Renaults and Ferraris on the race, be sure you will only listen the italians on real life
) and music too.
But I think after recording, they edit all these sounds before including on the games, because, in my opinion, you listen all of them soften, smoother. For example, if you hear a muscle car on real life, the sound is brute, louder. Not to mention competition cars, F1... you can go deaf!
In conclusion, perhaps they uniform the sounds so you can hear all the cars on the race (if for example there are Renaults and Ferraris on the race, be sure you will only listen the italians on real life
) and music too.
