Would you rather?

  • Thread starter motortrend
  • 22,046 comments
  • 961,870 views
Normally I would pick the Rangie but considering I wouldn't have particular use for its off-road prowess I'll take the Mercedes ML, because it's not a BMW X5 and I'm not a particular fan of the Volvo.
 
joshie's got some catching up to do

Focus. The RS is a nice car, though.

2014 Ferrari LaFerrari
2013-03-05_Geneva_Motor_Show_8278.JPG


or

2014 McLaren P1
1024px-2013-03-05_Geneva_Motor_Show_7846.JPG


or

2014 Porsche 918 Spyder
porsche_918_spyder_1.jpg


or

2015 Lamborghini Asterion LPI 910-4
lamborghini-asterion-lpi-910-4-hybrid-concept-02.jpg


or

2013 Jaguar C-X75
CX10.png


or

2013 Rimac Concept One
2012-05_RHjhSeSDddqFS0hgfN5Q.jpg

1. LaFerrari
2. 917
3. P1
...
4, 5, 6. Others

2015 BMW M4:
2015-bmw-m4-convertible-images-35-750x500.jpg


2015 Audi RS5:

2015-Audi-Rs5-Release.jpg


2015 Cadillac CTS-V:

2015-Cadillac-CTS-Picture.jpg


Or 2015 Jaguar F-Type:
jaguar-f-type-coupe.654x436.Nov-19-2013_22.39.16.712349.jpg


I'll take the Jaguar.

1. F-Type
2. M4
3. RS5
Luxury convertibles:

Aston-Martin-DB9-Volante-36-photos.jpg


ferrari-california-t-625x323.jpg


Bentley-Continental_GT_Speed_Convertible_2014_1600x1200_wallpaper_0f.jpg

1. Ferrari
2. Aston Martin
3. Bentley

Dagger311
American icons:

hrdp_1002_07_o%2B1967_ford%2Bmustang.jpg


69camaro.jpg


292001-870-0.jpg

1. Challenger
2. Camaro
3. Mustang

Dagger311
American icons round 2:

47_163_1960_CHEVROLET_CORVETTE_1.jpg


ford__thunderbird_1960_1_lgw.jpg


1960_Plymouth_Fury.jpg

I don't know what that bottom one is but I like it.

1. Bottom one
2. Corvette
3. Thundercock

Dagger311
American icons round 3:

cadillac-el-dorado-1975_1.jpg


1975_Lincoln_Continental_Mark_IV,_Dutch_licence_registration_05-YB-59_p1.JPG

I don't really think I have to explain this one.

Dagger311
American icons round 4: final showdown.

2010shelbygt500fdp1_30_opta.jpg


2012-chevrolet-camaro-zl1-9_653.jpg

Easily the GT500.

Dagger311
Family sedans:

2014_nissan_altima_sedan_35-sl_fq_oem_6_815.jpg


2014-Accord-PHEV-550x308.jpg

Altima, I guess.



I'll take the Megane RS, LaFerrari, the F-Type, the Vanquish Volante, the Challenger R/T, the C1 Corvette, the Lincoln Continental, the Camaro ZL1, and the Accord.



A Selection of Ungainly-looking Ferraris


Ferrari 330 GT Navarro Special
1966_Ferrari_330_GT_2+25DA.jpg



or


Ferrari 410 Superamerica Ghia Coupé
56ghia_ferrari_410_superamerica_31.jpg



or


Ferrari FZ93
Ferrari-FZ93_2.jpg

Oh god.

I think I'm just gonna do 1st, 2nd, 3rd on this one.

Luxury hatchbacks:

Audi A3
View attachment 237644

BMW 1-Series
View attachment 237646

Mercedes Benz A-Class
View attachment 237645

I don't really know anything about any of these but I'm usually pretty partial to Mercedes when it comes to the German big three so I'll go with the A-class.

Tesla Model S P85D (691hp, 687 lb ft)
Model_S_P85D-sm.jpg


vs

Dodge Charger SRT Hellcat (707hp, 650 lb ft)
15-ld-ex-3.jpg.pagespeed.ce.xuPXOcb3LF.jpg

Easily the Hellpussy.

Gallardo-ACR-GTR-1837.JPG


1: Gallardo.
2: Viper.
3:
4:
5: GT-R.

1. Viper ACR
2. Gallardo
3. GT-R
30's American luxury cars:

1930 Cadillac V16.
cadillac-v16-1930.jpg


1930 Buick Series 60.
30-Buick_Series69_num287_DV-07-MBA_04.jpg


Lincoln Zephyr. Exact year I don't know, but definitely 30's.
Zephyr-1.jpg


1940 (only one I could find) Mercury something.
Mercury_Sedan_Coupe_1940_Rick_Feibusch_2010.jpg


I'll take the Caddy, then Buick, then Ford, and Mercury last.

I'm just going to assume the Lincoln was supposed to be in good condition when I'm doing my rankings.

1. 1930 Cadillac V16
2. Lincoln Zephyr
3. "Mercury something"
4. Buick Series 60

Dagger311
Foreign 1930's luxury cars:

1930 Mercedes Type 770.
30_Mercedes_770K_VR_CL_DV-06_PB_01.jpg


1930-ish BMW 327.
BMW_Museum_2012_37.jpg


I'll take the Mercedes.

Mercedes for me, as well.

Dagger311
1930's Bentley vs Rolls Royce.

Phantom II:

30rollsphantomII4.jpg


Or

8 Liter.
1930-bentley-8-litre-1-lg.jpg


I'll take the Bentley.

I never take a Bentley over a Rolls but I am this time. The Bentley just looks so much better in this case.

Early 00s luxury superminis:

Audi A2
View attachment 237920

Lancia Y
View attachment 237921

Mercedes-Benz A-Class
View attachment 237922

A2. I've always liked it for some reason.

2013-audi-rs5-2011-bmw-m3-cadillac-cts-v-front-2.jpg


Or

2013-audi-rs5-2011-bmw-m3-cadillac-front-3.jpg


Or

2013-audi-rs5-2011-bmw-m3-cadillac-cts-v-front-4.jpg


I'm taking the Caddy, even though it's not the sedan.

1. Cadillac
2. Audi
3. BMW

Powerhouse Ponies

2014 Ford Shelby GT500
04-2013-shelby-gt500-top-speed-test.jpg


or

2015 Dodge Challenger SRT Hellcat
01-2015-dodge-challenger-srt-hellcat-fd-opt.jpg


Personally, I would go with the Mustang for just not being as bloated as the Challenger, but that's just me.

That one's really tough. I've always loved Shelby Mustangs, but I really like the new Hellcat. I guess I'll go with the Hellcat for now that it's an all new car pretty much, but my decision will probably change in a few years.

Limited-edition Ferraris that Honor the USA (only Ten Units Made/Will be Made)


528546.jpg

Ferrari 275 GTB/4 NART Spyder


or


2014_Ferrari_F60America-0-1536.jpg

Ferrari F60America




F60 I guess.

The Hellcat and the F60 America.

Rotary eXperimentals

Mazda Capella Rotary Coupe/RX-2

Mazda_Capella_001.JPG


Mazda Savanna GT/RX-3 (S102)

1280px-Mazda-rx3-1st-generation01.jpg


Mazda Savanna RX-7 (SA22C)

1280px-Mazda-rx7-1st-generation01.jpg


Mazda Savanna RX-7 (FC)

Rx7FC1.jpg


Mazda ɛ̃fini RX-7 (FD)

1280px-Mazda-rx7-3rd-generation01.jpg


There were a couple of others that have worn the RX- name (internationally at least) but I decided to go with the more well-known ones. I'd take the RX-3.

1. RX-2
2. RX-3
3. RX-7 (FD)
4. RX-7 (SA22C)
5. RX-7 (FC)

2010 Marussia B2
2010-marussia-b2-2.jpg


or

2012 Tushek Renovatio T500
Tushek-Renovatio-T500-White.jpg

Marussia, I suppose. The name is less stupid sounding and it's less ugly.

Modern performance Roadsters:

Chevrolet Corvette Convertible C7
View attachment 238955

Jaguar F-Type V8 S
View attachment 238954

Porsche 911 Carrera S Cabriolet
View attachment 238956

1. Jaguar
2. Chevy
3. Porsche

I'll take the Marussia B2 and the 911 Carrera S Cabriolet.



Obscure Lightweight Two-door Sports Cars with Outsourced Engines


Isis_AM01-9369.jpg

Isis AM01


or


P_47ccc5b5f7174f63b28c9294c066df51.jpg

Mastretta MXT


Mastretta. It doesn't look like a stupid kit car.

Saker RapX
saker-launches-rapx-and-sniper-for-track-use-only_20.jpg


or

Lotus 2-Eleven
lotus-2-eleven-01.jpg


or

Caterham Superlight R400
Caterham-Superlight-R400.jpg

1. Caterham
2. Lotus
3. Saker

Nissan 240SX (first generation)
Red_240SX_II.jpg


Or Toyota Supra Mk 3.
2.jpg


I'll take the Supra.

Supra. It's a little bit more special since they're not as common.
Large luxury SUVs:

BMW X5
View attachment 239744

Mercedes-Benz ML
View attachment 239745

Range Rover Sport
View attachment 239746

Volvo XC90
View attachment 239747

1. Mercedes-Benz ML
2. Range Rover Sport
3. Volvo XC90
4. BMX X5
 
Isis AM01 vs Mastretta MXT; I don't know much about either, so I'll pick the AM01 for looks.

Track Day Cars; Lotus 2-Eleven

Nissan S13 240SX vs Toyota MA70 Supra; Simple, I'm going to pick the Supra, because that is one of my favorite cars of all time and I don't care for the S13 240SX that much. I actually prefer the Silvia over it.

Sport Utilities; Volvo XC90 please, I'm starting to like the XC90 quite a bit and I see too many of the other 3 SUVs around anyway. The Volvo would stand out.
 
I'll take the Caterham R400 Superlight, the S13 240SX, the Range Rover Sport, the Agera R, (but not a shoddy replica of the real thing, and I'll take the Huayra instead if the replica was the actual car in the comparison) and the Fiesta XR2.

Two sets of WYRs coming now... (I've seen this done previously, so I suppose it's okay...)



Set One


18sq7pj0ky951jpg.jpg

Vuhl 05


or


14944630201890629202.jpg

Elemental RP1


or


magnum_mk5_main_01_crop.jpg

Magnum Mk5


or


safe_image.php

Zenos E10



Set Two


intro1.jpg

Ultima GTR (565bhp version)



or


stealth_b6_by_furlined-d5eks3n.jpg

Stealth B6


or


image.jpg

Radical RXC
 
Ultimate track day cars 1:
1. Vuhl 05
2. Magnum Mk5
3. Elemental RP1
4. Zenos E10

Ultimate track day cars 2:
1. Ultima GTR
2. Radical RCX
3. Stealth B6
 
Back