I guess I'm quite qualified at this point to speak up on this.
Initially I started my Patreon feed for two main reasons: 1, in order to just generate some money for my Google Drive account, as the amount of projects I had on the go, along with backups etc, was getting out of hand, and I needed the space. And 2, the same time as a lot of stuff I was releasing as an 'Early build' onto places like RD to get feedback etc, were just getting the **** torn out of them in comments and reviews.
I'm totally open to peoples opinions on my work, but on Race Department or something like that, a 1 star review for somebody that really didn't like something that I never claimed was finished stays next to that mod forever, even when it is finished. I know I could just ignore it, or don't read the reviews, but it's impossible not to.
So the idea to remove access to entitled people that expected the world for free and perfect quality for a first draft, and generate enough money to keep my hard work safe on the cloud seemed to like a good one to me. It's removed a lot of negativity from comments and reviews, and I think my mental health, and enjoyment of the hobby has vastly improved because of it.
However, it did garner more attention than I expected, and has become a fair bit of money every month. So of course the attention has shifted slightly to try and keep paying supporters happy. I pointed this out in a previous post, and I admit I've got carried away on making new tracks and trying new ideas all of the time, and because of that public releases have suffered. But on the other hand, I think at this point i'm getting more enjoyment out of building tracks, than driving on them. I think this has always been the case, since I was a kid. With my endeavors getting attention from various websites see
https://www.carthrottle.com/post/oddly-accurate-monaco-grand-prix-circuit-created-in-far-cry-3/
https://wtf1.com/post/monaco-far-cry-3-map/
What i'm trying to say is, an unexpected side effect of my Patreon is I now feel responsibility for providing content for so many people that are generously giving me a bit of money each month. The upside is that my work is safe and I'm able to make loads of interesting tracks, real or fictional, get feedback, try new ideas, and also push aside a lot of negativity from freeloaders. The negatives are, now i'm not so concerned with trying to convince people that leave crappy reviews that my work is actually good, the public and finished releases have dropped to a slow trickle.
Another point i'd like to raise is, In my case at least, it's not so much "carrot dangling", as people are now seeing more of the behind the scenes stuff, it's worth noting I had 35+ tracks on my Patreon when I launched it, all in various stages of development. Theses are tracks which would probably have never seen the light of day otherwise. But now because of some positive feedback on ideas i'd certainly pushed to the side, they've been bought forward and are getting more work done on them. People are seeing more of my work, which is a good thing I think.