- 1,201
- Arrakis
You keep missing the point and thinking we are saying something we (or atleast I) are not pretending to say.
It's not about restricting the kind of mods people can share. Is about cataloging them. About knowing what are you going to find before downloading them. You want to upload the most disastrous mod ever made? Good, but let the people know what are they going to find. Even the most broken mod has it uses (e.g.: AI competitor or photomode), but it would help to know what are you going to find or what needs that mod can fulfill.
And there are a lot of objective stuff about mods. Issues mostly. Regarding the subjective part, is not complete caos and anarchy. It does help to know what the community thinks about some mod. Is there really somebody that doesn't like Sol? If a mod is not broken, works like a dream and has an reasonable behavior, Is there somebody that will say "no, don't download this, is garbage"?
The idea of a catalog doesn't come from a negative perspective or censorship. On the contrary, it would help to shine those mods that wouldn't otherwise.
I'm not missing the point SlimCharles. All I'm saying is that it's just totally unrealistic to expect "the community" to all test mods and then come to some sort of mass consensus on each one. You simply have to rely on yourself do the testing, cataloging and rating.