Haven’t got to stage rally yet but as a three time THSCC rallyX champion (06 WRX swapped 95 Impreza L in profile pic) I can say I know what they were going for even though I sometimes wish it was a little heavier.
However, when you’re in the grove and setting a good pace the FFB reminds me of all the good driving sensations you feel when pushing the limits off tarmac. How you can let the wheel slide through your hands, the way it feels when you throw your car into a corner sideways, even surface transitions, and The response you get when testing front traction before diving into a turn. Does it replicate the real thing exactly, no but that would be impossible anyways.
When I get in the zone and drive the car how t should be driven the FFB sometimes brings a smile to my face and I say damn, that brings me back to the real thing. Another reason I love this game, I’m sitting this season out with a blown engine. It’s going to be a little while before I can rebuild it since I’m getting married next month but this game is the best I’ve got for now and I’m more than happy with it and the FFB!!!!!
Figured I'd add that when you're driving 70-75mph on dirt or gravel (which is as fast as I've been on a rally course) you don't feel every little rock or bump, especially with a rally specific suspension which has more travel and designed to soak up all the little stuff. Going that fast flying sideways past trees doesn't give you time to think about all the little bumps and terrain so you really don't even notice it. If you consciously think about how to react its too late, you almost have to drive at a subconscious level and train your muscle memory to automatically react to a situation before you have time to process it. That is what the game is trying to recreate. I can imagine it being difficult to get it if you haven't felt it in real life but the forces that come through the wheel are pretty comparable to the real thing, though weaker than you would feel in real life and leaves out things you don't notice anyway. I'm sure it'll be improved further over time but for those complaining and getting upset about it, you just don't know what you're supposed to be feeling.......... Its a game, an awesome game but just a game, just have to keep that in mind........