Got to laugh at some of these replies...
The assumption is that, if there is
any criticism of a game, you MUST hate it
. Far from it. That's kind of the point. With very little added, this is easily the best racing game
ever. Currently though, it's not even the best sim. That's probably iRacing. The best handling and FFB? That's probably AC. The best, most flexible online system? That's probably GTS (or, IMHO, GT5/6!). Best content? Definitely PC2.
But PC2 comes closest to best all round. And with very little added, becomes the ultimate car game for both hardcore simmer
and casual weekend player. But the resistance to change, from both the devs and the kind of people that show their colors shooting down ANY change rather than admit the game's flaws, it looks very likely the game will be stuck in this mediocrity.
The game needs refinement. Refinement of lobby options, refinement of AI behavior (honestly, guys, who can watch a replay of 30 AI going into T1 without squirming in embarrassment?), refinement of parity in stock tunes (some stock tunes are almost perfect, some are close to undriveable), refinement by squashing bugs, etc., etc..
Now, of course I realize there's no chance of a PC3 with little more than bugs fixed. But what worries me, and the PC1 to PC2 transition seems to illustrate, is that SMS will once again bite off FAR more than they can chew, add a bunch of stuff that remain buggy for most of its lifecycle, leave in bugs from the previous game, and once again develop a game sold to console players that can barely run on it and lacking vital features for the PC version. I believe that, if all SMS did was completely fix Livetrack 3.0 (and call it Livetrack 4.0 to justify the new game!), completely fix the AI quirks, the handling quirks, the lobby quirks and just added a few tracks and cars, it would easily be worth the price of a new game.
But another game with poorly functioning features, a buglist the length of War and Peace, and a console release far inferior to the PC version (I'm not talking resolution or framerates, I'm talking things like no lobby titles in the console version, stuff like that), with hidden rooms and massive obstacles for casual, non-league players to create a clean community, I'm not sure how anyone expects the franchise to grow.
Happy with the current game? Happy with how few players it has, online (especially consoles)? What are you doing on a wishlist thread in the first place?! You have to question the motives of people that come onto wishlist threads and try to shoot down the desire for improvement...