Rape 5 Year Old Dies in India

[Ranman20]

http://abcnews.go.com/m/story?id=19072159&ref=http://news.google.com/

People are sick these days I tell you.

Edit* meant to put raped.

 

[MoLiEG]

Ugh...

Horrible... They should burn them, just like her mother said...

 

[Ranman20]

Ugh...

Horrible... They should burn them, just like her mother said...

The world is full of sickos out there but I believe every human should be forgived.

 

[Rykon Zero]

The world is full of sickos out there but I believe every human should be forgived.

I'm glad you do. I'd be more than glad to condemn these men to oblivion, personally. There are certain things that cannot be redeemed in my mind, and this is one of those.

 

[Carbonox]

The world is full of sickos out there but I believe every human should be forgived.

Maybe in a wicked imaginary world they would.

 

[Liquid]

The world is full of sickos out there but I believe every human should be forgived.

*forgiven

And how do you propose we rehabilitate these people, with their new found forgiveness? Would they still have the shame of raping a child on their minds?

 

[Slash]

Why someone would do this to a helpless child who has no, or shouldn't have any concept of sex at that age, let alone against their will is just beyond me. I hope that scumbag burns in hell for eternity. Pile of 🤬

 

[Crumpet]

Pretty sick for anyone to even consider. This guy did, and I hope he faces the harshest consequences possible for his actions.

 

[e30 freek]

maybe in a wicked imaginary world they would.

+1
Only 5 years old, what spineless bastard tramp would do such a thing

 

[Eks]

Why someone would do this to a helpless child who has no, or shouldn't have any concept of sex at that age, let alone against their will is just beyond me. I hope that scumbag burns in hell for eternity. Pile of 🤬

My thoughts exactly. I'll hold back my harsh words, all I will say is that I hope he suffers punishing consequences for what he did.

 

[sumbrownkid]

I don't even know how one can defend the perpetrators in the criminal court. These guys are marked men no doubt.

 

[Carbonox]

Having to Being supposed to defend "people" like this in court would definitely be one of the most difficult things for any lawyer to do.

 

[Anathema]

Can the 'perpetrators' be forgiven here?

Maybe in the eyes of God, but no one else. Stopping short of wishing eternal hell on someone, but I hope that full justice is metered out.

 

[Johnnypenso]

I'd have no trouble forgiving them...after they were repeatedly 🤬 raped themselves with various broom handles, baseball bats, maybe a couple of different hairbrushes (the bristle end of course) and then hung or gassed or whatever they use for the death penalty in India these days.

 

[dice1998]

The world is full of sickos out there but I believe every human should be forgived.

They didn't know what they were doing, right?

 

[MarinaDiamandis]

They didn't know what they were doing, right?

No, but they are human, just like the rest of us.

When so many people want to see criminals tortured, killed, or locked away and forgotten about instead of trying to help them, then I think it's rather telling of the kind of world we are living in. We may as well be sitting in the Coliseum in Rome.

We don't learn anything from locking people away.

 

[Northstar]

I'd have no trouble forgiving them...after they were repeatedly 🤬 raped themselves with various broom handles, baseball bats, maybe a couple of different hairbrushes (the bristle end of course) and then hung or gassed or whatever they use for the death penalty in India these days.

Am I the only one that finds comments like these almost as disturbing as what the sicko did to the poor child?

 

[MarinaDiamandis]

Am I the only one that finds comments like these almost as disturbing as what the sicko did to the poor child?

Certainly not. If people honestly find the idea of a rapist being raped several times to be suitable justice, I think they may need some professional help.

 

[Crumpet]

after they were repeatedly 🤬 raped themselves with various broom handles, baseball bats, maybe a couple of different hairbrushes (the bristle end of course)

 

[arora]

I'm always interested in the why; abused, taught, born as a human who behaves in a way society doesn't accept etc.

Obviously hurting a child is one of the worst things imaginable and it's going to bring out emotions(thank god it does). The most important thing is to insure the guilty will not be able to repeat the act imo.

I'm not sure it's possible to rehab a pedofile, so what to do with them is in constant question for now.

 

[Slash]

That worked so perfectly

 

[Carbonox]

I'm not sure it's possible to rehab a pedofile, so what to do with them is in constant question for now.

I'm sure there's a way to cut the problem.

 

[Crispy]

No, but they are human, just like the rest of us.

When so many people want to see criminals tortured, killed, or locked away and forgotten about instead of trying to help them, then I think it's rather telling of the kind of world we are living in. We may as well be sitting in the Coliseum in Rome.

We don't learn anything from locking people away.

You realize people like this rarely, if ever, revert to normal? There is something seriously screwed up in your mind if you think rape is okay, and something extremely screwed up if you think that raping a kid is okay. You don't just revert their brain back to normal, it's a mental illness and it is just the way that persons brain is wired.

Certainly not. If people honestly find the idea of a rapist being raped several times to be suitable justice, I think they may need some professional help.

You are right. Someone who sees rape as justifiable might need a little help. But I see no problem in killing this person, why? Well why should someone like them get 15-20 years, or get out on good behavior, only to be put on a list which will never stop them from doing the exact same thing.

 

[Pagey279]

You realize people like this rarely, if ever, revert to normal?

Even so, does that automatically mean we should deny them the chance?

There is something seriously screwed up in your mind if you think rape is okay, and something extremely screwed up if you think that raping a kid is okay. You don't just revert their brain back to normal, it's a mental illness and it is just the way that persons brain is wired.

Where did you get that from?

I don't mean to put words into your mouth here Marina. But his comment was referring to rather disturbing posts like these:

Why someone would do this to a helpless child who has no, or shouldn't have any concept of sex at that age, let alone against their will is just beyond me. I hope that scumbag burns in hell for eternity. Pile of 🤬

I'd have no trouble forgiving them...after they were repeatedly 🤬 raped themselves with various broom handles, baseball bats, maybe a couple of different hairbrushes (the bristle end of course) and then hung or gassed or whatever they use for the death penalty in India these days.

 

[Johnnypenso]

Even so, does that automatically mean we should deny them the chance?

I don't mean to put words into your mouth here Marina. But his comment was referring to rather disturbing posts like these:

Call me crazy but I find it rather disturbing that in a thread about the rape and eventual murder of a 5 year old your only two comments revolve around giving the rapists a chance to rehabilitate and outrage that people are upset at a 5 year old being raped to death. Not a word about the dead child. If it was your 5 year old raped to death I wonder if those would be your first two comments on the matter.

 

[Slash]

Even so, does that automatically mean we should deny them the chance?



Where did you get that from?

I don't mean to put words into your mouth here Marina. But his comment was referring to rather disturbing posts like these:

I think my post was rather minimal in disturbing content to the other one you compared mine to in all fairness.


@ Johnny I agree with you there. Well said.

 

[Pagey279]

Call me crazy but I find it rather disturbing that in a thread about the rape and eventual murder of a 5 year old your only two comments revolve around giving the rapists a chance to rehabilitate and outrage that people are upset at a 5 year old being raped to death. Not a word about the dead child. If it was your 5 year old raped to death I wonder if those would be your first two comments on the matter.

So because my two first comments weren't about the dead child that means I don't feel any sympathy at all for the family of the child, or any sadness for the child herself? Of course I do, but just because my first post didn't say as much that means I don't hold that sentiment, of course.

You find that disturbing and not raping someone with a wooden mop or a baseball bat or a frickin' hairbrush?!? Your heads not working properly.

 

[MarinaDiamandis]

There is something seriously screwed up in your mind if you think rape is okay, and something extremely screwed up if you think that raping a kid is okay.

Please quote where I said that rape was okay. Oh, that's right, you can't, because I didn't...

I can hardly believe that you have just tried to claim that I support rape from my previous post. Just... I don't even... Why are you even allowed in this forum?

You are right. Someone who sees rape as justifiable might need a little help.

Like you need help with your reading comprehension? Yeah, I'm none too pleased that you've posted something that stupid.

But I see no problem in killing this person, why? Well why should someone like them get 15-20 years, or get out on good behavior, only to be put on a list which will never stop them from doing the exact same thing.

Well, I don't quite understand at which point you were given the right to decide whether someone lives or dies, could you clarify for me? Why should someone like you stop someone like this from getting several years in a good rehabilitation program and a second chance at life? Just because it makes you feel safe, it doesn't solve the problem.

Locking someone away for 15-20 years and then releasing them and expecting them not to reoffend rarely works for any crime. The same is true for putting them on a register, giving them curfews, and most of the other penalties that they receive. Rehabilitation is what works.

This idea you have that sex offenders will carry on committing offences of a sexual nature once released shows how little you know about the subject. They respond to treatment as well as any other criminal group, and are certainly not a lost cause to be cast away.

Oddly enough, the less you isolate and punish sex offenders, the less likely they are to reoffend. This is true for all criminals.

EDIT: Oh, and Johnny, please stop. Next you'll have us stamping all our posts with "Just my opinion". Being upset at a story as tragic as this is no justification for typing out some very sick wishes. If anything, it is an insult to the victim, as you are doing nothing to fix the problem.

 

[Liquid]

I'm with MD here, while I think it is an abhorrent crime, and I do believe that reacceptence into society would be problematic, I do condemn eye for an eye-esque punishments. As with my view on capital punishment, it [eye for an eye] is as hypocritically barbaric as the crimes which are punished; frequently the punishment is the same as the crime. I don't see the development and advancement of society there.

 

[Johnnypenso]

So because my two first comments weren't about the dead child that means I don't feel any sympathy at all for the family of the child, or any sadness for the child herself? Of course I do, but just because my first post didn't say as much that means I don't hold that sentiment, of course.

You find that disturbing and not raping someone with a wooden mop or a baseball bat or a frickin' hairbrush?!? Your heads not working properly.

You are right, just because your first post didn't say as much doesn't mean you don't hold that sentiment, but seeing as how you chose to sympathize with the rapists first it might indicate where your priorities lie.

Outside of mentally diminished capacity where the perpetrator has no concept of right and wrong, I have no sympathy for anyone who would commit such a crime. You are free to be concerned about their rehabilitation and whether or not they'll rape and kill anymore children in 20 years after they get out of prison. As far as I am concerned if they are tried and convicted on DNA evidence, they deserve nothing less than death. My empathy starts and ends with that little girl and her family..

EDIT: Oh, and Johnny, please stop. Next you'll have us stamping all our posts with "Just my opinion". Being upset at a story as tragic as this is no justification for typing out some very sick wishes. If anything, it is an insult to the victim, as you are doing nothing to fix the problem.

Stop what? Stop posting my opinions? I thought that's what this forum was about, posting opinions. You don't like them so you want me to stop posting them...lol. Thanks for the offer but no thanks. Obviously you didn't bother to read the article because I think the Mom and I are in perfect sync on this:

"The court should give them the strictest punishment ever," she sobbed Tuesday.
"These men should be burned alive so that the whole world will see how such criminals ought to be punished," she said, wiping her tears with the corner of her sari."

We agree.