The "Rate My Photo" thread! **Read the OP Before You Post**
- Thread starter MSD Drifter
- 2,388 comments
- 170,877 views
- 391
- Austin, TX
- Amblo2u
Just what you guys think overall
I'll give this one a solid 7. The subjects look great in matching colors, the focus is fairly well done, and the background gives the sense of a warehouse district old school drag race...I get the feeling of 'daring' when I look at this.
Here's a couple of mine. +/- is accepted all the same.
Brabus-illac: A European Counterpart.
"Calm Before the Storm: A Play on Power, A Play on Words"
An Introduction: 'Industry'...Meet 'Consumption.'
The Sitting Man: "Il ya une première fois pour tout, et surtout quatre cents quatre-vingts trois km à l'heure."
- 112
- Damascus
- KimoKiller200
10/10 Absolutely terrific picture! Perfect in everything!
Laguna Seca Raceway_4 by KimoKiller200, on Flickr
Laguna Seca Raceway_4 by KimoKiller200, on Flickr
- 5,999
- Over there
- ask me
Stunning work... perfect in every way...MadMoss gets 10/10 x 2
now some less impressive work
now some less impressive work
- 2,452
- Singapore
- lowzikai
First: Few problems with this one. It's a little dark and the vignette is unnecessary. Dig the toning though, it's pretty good. 
6.5/10
Second: Vignette is again, unnecessary. Composition is not as strong in this one, and the framing could be improved on. Maybe move the car to show more of a 3/4 view. Also, the space between the rear and the frame is way bigger compared to the almost non-existant space in the front. The difference irks me quite a bit. (Forgive my OCD.
) Photo's pretty bland as well. 6/10
Third: This photo is way better than the previous two, IMHO. Good job. 👍 There is action in the photo so that's a plus. The composition and framing in this is much better. The aperture is just right and the vignette helped in this. The toning's good in this as well, as both of your previous pictures. I especially like how there is a glow in the smoke from the brakes. 8.5/10
Be nice!
6.5/10Second: Vignette is again, unnecessary. Composition is not as strong in this one, and the framing could be improved on. Maybe move the car to show more of a 3/4 view. Also, the space between the rear and the frame is way bigger compared to the almost non-existant space in the front. The difference irks me quite a bit. (Forgive my OCD.
) Photo's pretty bland as well. 6/10Third: This photo is way better than the previous two, IMHO. Good job. 👍 There is action in the photo so that's a plus. The composition and framing in this is much better. The aperture is just right and the vignette helped in this. The toning's good in this as well, as both of your previous pictures. I especially like how there is a glow in the smoke from the brakes. 8.5/10
Be nice!
- 5,999
- Over there
- ask me
great feedback slzk.. thank you!
- 1,131
- London, England
- manciocio
Pretty cool photo you got there, nice work with the blur to give it that incredibly fast movement effect.
The composition could be a bit better though as the grass overpowers the car...
It's still an awesome photo though so I would give it a 7/10 ^^
The composition could be a bit better though as the grass overpowers the car...
It's still an awesome photo though so I would give it a 7/10 ^^
- 5,999
- Over there
- ask me
Nice work manciocio.. overall it's a fantastic shot... great composition and sense of speed ...it may be cropped a bit too much and overly gray.. I still give it a solid 8/10
- 1,511
- Michigan
- tahoe01
First photo
It is evident that you intentionally left the car out of focus, but I don't think that works. I naturally want to see the details on the car and I'm left unsatisfied. The car is also too centered in the shot, zoom out and pan to the left for a more dynamic photo.
3/10
Second photo
This is a good shot. The car isn't centered, I can "feel" the dust hitting my face, and there is a realistic amount of motion blur. Not much to be improved.
8/10
Third photo
I don't think the partial color filter works in this photo. Perhaps it would be a bit more bearable if the exposure was dropped some so that the whole photo wasn't washed out.
On the plus side, the framing of the cars is good and I like the blurry trees in the background.
5.5/10
To rate:
It is evident that you intentionally left the car out of focus, but I don't think that works. I naturally want to see the details on the car and I'm left unsatisfied. The car is also too centered in the shot, zoom out and pan to the left for a more dynamic photo.
3/10
Second photo
This is a good shot. The car isn't centered, I can "feel" the dust hitting my face, and there is a realistic amount of motion blur. Not much to be improved.
8/10
Third photo
I don't think the partial color filter works in this photo. Perhaps it would be a bit more bearable if the exposure was dropped some so that the whole photo wasn't washed out.
On the plus side, the framing of the cars is good and I like the blurry trees in the background.
5.5/10
To rate:
- 4,420
- nealcropper
Love that shot! I seen the day and night set in the realistic photo thread. Awesome 10/10.
- 4,420
- nealcropper
Horde_R35
Thanks pal!
Similar threads
